4 ms·
I think the asinine part is copyright transferring to another medium. Its one thing to copyright the lighting installation (which is a fine thing, more power t
by protomyth 11y ago
I think the asinine part is copyright transferring to another medium. Its one thing to copyright the lighting installation (which is a fine thing, more power to you), but another thing to now own copyright a photo that happens to have said installation in it.
- icebraining 11y agoWhat if I take a high quality picture of a painting? What about a video of a photograph? What about a film based on a book?
- protomyth 11y agoI think we are talking about a public installation like a sculpture, building, etc. No photograph, book, or film is an actual copy; but your examples are all basically trying to make a copy that can function like the original.
- bostonpete 11y agoCouldn't a series of photos be composited to function like an original sculpture? E.g. a photosphere or VR-like presentation that allows the viewer to experience the sculpture from different angles, perhaps even in 3D?
- protomyth 11y agoLet me get this straight. To justify the protection of a light sculpture from photography, you create a scenario where the photographer is taking a bunch of pictures to build a "photosphere or VR-like presentation"? I shouldn't be allowed to photograph the sculpture because there is the possibility I will use these photographs to create some virtual replacement? This is how bad laws are made.
- sogen 11y agoWhat about clothes? chairs? umbrellas? Soon we won't be able to take photographs of anything...
- protomyth 11y agoThat's my point, the photograph, video, painting, etc. is not a replacement for any physical item.
- lmm 11y agoIf someone's e.g. selling a poster of the Eiffel Tower at night, I think a lot of that poster's value derives from the efforts of the lighting artist.
- protomyth 11y agoOk, let's go with that. What can you photograph outdoors that does not have someones efforts to style an area?
- candu 11y agoNature? (I suppose you could argue that the ability to get to said nature is often dependent on roads and other transit networks...)
- lmm 11y agoIf the photo's "of" an artist's work then you probably do owe the artist. If you're photographing something that happens to have an artist's work in the background, that's going to be fair use, like the "dancing baby" video that has a bit of a Prince song in the background.
- NittLion78 11y agoI don't understand how this could ever be enforceable. Maybe it's just a symptom of my inability to imagine how this would play out in other justice systems outside the US.
- germanier 11y agoThey already enforce that in France. How? Just like any other regular old copyright violation.