3 ms·
They may have meant the various agencies under DOJ (DEA, FBI, ATF, etc.) and not the US Attorney's office, but then again HN often finds plea bargaining irredee
by tedunangst 11y ago
They may have meant the various agencies under DOJ (DEA, FBI, ATF, etc.) and not the US Attorney's office, but then again HN often finds plea bargaining irredeemably evil too.
- sarciszewski 11y ago> They may have meant the various agencies under DOJ (DEA, FBI, ATF, etc.) and not the US Attorney's office Indeed, that is precisely what I meant. I'm not interested in the US Attorney's office when I speak of the DoJ.
- rhino369 11y agoEven if you meant DEA, FBI, etc. etc, it's beyond naive to think of the average workers as cartoonish villains plotting to destroy people's lives. You might as well say anyone who works for Google or Facebook deserves to hang for spying. Even if you strongly disagree with their views and actions it isn't corruption.
- wfo 11y agoAnyone in law enforcement is in the business of destroying lives. They don't protect people (you can't really, in a free society), they punish people after the fact in an attempt to reduce antisocial/immoral/"impure" behavior. Doing their jobs correctly and with moral forthrightness is making absolutely sure the lives they destroy are lives that deserve to be destroyed. But as it turns out they are human and want to keep their jobs so they inevitably focus on "winning" cases -- that is, not failing to destroy lives, rather than being appropriately cautious with the power they are given. Cartoonish villians? No. It's more the opposite; they think of themselves as cartoonish superheroes and have a hard-on for "punishing the wicked", and often forget that the wicked aren't always so wicked and maybe the extreme and brutal punishment associated with even being touched by the US justice system isn't appropriate -- but why give up a case you can win and tank your career? The guy in the cubicle next door is happy to get the commendation and promotion if you won't take it.
- superuser2 11y agoPlea bargaining is not irredeemably evil, setting laws so that a plea bargain is the only reasonable course of action even when you're innocent is evil.
- derekp7 11y agoIt's not the plea bargaining itself, it is the wide gap. The way to fix that is if someone is offered a plea deal, and doesn't accept it, then put a cap on the max sentence based on the rejected plea bargain. After all, if a prosecutor was fine with someone getting off on 2 months, why is it necessary to try to lock them up for 20 years if the case goes to trial?