3 ms·
> There is no push to reduce the Freedom of Panorama in countries that do not have it restricted. This is not true. European copyright law would not allow indi
by TazeTSchnitzel 11y ago
> There is no push to reduce the Freedom of Panorama in countries that do not have it restricted.
This is not true. European copyright law would not allow individual member states to introduce exceptions beyond what it explicitly permits.
https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_Panorama_in_Europe_in_2015/Learn_more https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_Panorama_in_Europ...
https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_Panorama_2015_EVA_GESAC https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_Panorama_2015_EVA...
> They now want to add a new rule in place that allows to make a distinction between commercial and noncommercial usage.
Yes, but "non-commercial usage" and "commercial usage" are poorly-defined terms, particularly in the Internet age.
- the_mitsuhiko 11y ago> This is not true. European copyright law would not allow individual member states to introduce exceptions beyond what it explicitly permits. Maybe I did not make myself clear: a country that does not have a restriction on freedom of panorama will not have a restriction after those rules. This only tries to harmonize the restrictions between the countries that have such restrictions already.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y ago> Maybe I did not make myself clear: a country that does not have a restriction on freedom of panorama will not have a restriction after those rules. No, existing member states will have a restriction. It will only have Freedom of Panorama for non-commercial use. Member states are NOT allowed to have freedoms beyond those in the directive: https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_Panorama_2015_EVA_GESAC#Will_the_provision_adopted_by_the_JURI_Committee_rule_out_the_exceptions_that_are_in_place_in_some_Member_States.3F https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_Panorama_2015_EVA...
- kuschku 11y agoThat’s wrong! The new law would add those restrictions for ALL the countries. That’s why everyone is in such an uproar. The changed proposal would make it illegal for a nation to allow the freedom of panorama. Read the blog of the MEP who wrote the original proposal (which had a clause saying that the Freedom of panorama should apply everywhere): https://juliareda.eu/2015/06/fop-under-threat/ https://juliareda.eu/2015/06/fop-under-threat/
- the_mitsuhiko 11y ago> That’s wrong! The new law would add those restrictions for ALL the countries. That’s why everyone is in such an uproar. Can you link to where this is written?
- kuschku 11y agoRead the blogpost I linked? It’s from the MEP who wrote the original proposal, and explains why it would add those restrictions for all the countries in the first few paragraphs already.
- seanp2k2 11y agoInteresting point re:commercial usage. If a user of a social media site posts an image not for their own profit, it's still contributing to the social media network's profits in that it's keeping users engaged with the site while the social network runs ads.