3 ms·
I can only comment on Carlos Castro, the link of yours at archivefreedom.org. Near as I can tell, he claims to have come up with a unified field theory. As far
by yummyfajitas 17y ago
I can only comment on Carlos Castro, the link of yours at archivefreedom.org. Near as I can tell, he claims to have come up with a unified field theory. As far as I know, the arxiv filters out proofs of P=NP, the Riemann Hypothesis, unified field theory and similar things. So what?
That's not the same as trying to get JMP shut down or editors ousted because it publishes papers on Bohmian mechanics.
The fact is, Steve McIntyre is not a crackpot. He has made important contributions to the field, most notably making corrections to Michael Mann's "hockey stick". The CRU folks conspired to keep data from him in order to prevent him from making further corrections to Briffa's hockey stick.
With regards to angry muttering, there is far more than that. There is conclusive evidence of a conspiracy:
And don’t leave stuff lying around on ftp sites – you never know who is trawling them. The two MMs have been after the CRU station data for years. If they ever hear there is a Freedom of Information Act now in the UK, I think I’ll delete the file rather than send to anyone.
Can you delete any emails you may have had with Keith re AR4?
With regards your point c), the people who conspired to hide data now claim that other data was lost. And we believe them because they are so trustworthy?
With regards to a hacking war, I wasn't advocating it. I'm simply pointing out that the recent incident does give us evidence that the consensus (which is not a substitute for solid science, BTW) is manufactured.