3 ms·
I guess the good thing in all this is that it's what you'd expect if you took Carnivore from the 90s and threw a ton of intelligent people and pervasive fibre a
by MichaelGG 11y ago
I guess the good thing in all this is that it's what you'd expect if you took Carnivore from the 90s and threw a ton of intelligent people and pervasive fibre access at it. There doesn't seem to be anything breakthrough, like "holy shit they can do that" kind of stuff.
Now yes, the scope is amazing. And I was getting this technical excitement just reading the system. So many questions! Like, how do they distribute jobs fairly or deal with resource over use? What stops some dumbass oper from submitting a super-expensive query? How do they manage all this stuff? It's pretty damn neat.
I'm wondering what the impact of TLS is on all this. Cause it seems like that'd sort of destroy this system, eh?
Edit: https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/2116191-unofficial-xks-user-guide.html#document/p1 https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/2116191-unofficial-x... - Interesting how they are really explicit how USSID 18 stops them from doing stuff. Like they give the example of finding a phone number without a country code. Not allowed! Unless you combine it with something that'd limit it to foreign countries. But they note it's not a 100% solution.
- codezero 11y agoThe tone of the references to USSID 18 makes me feel like they are tongue in cheek. For example this one: https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/2115979-advanced-http-activity-analysis.html#document/p91 https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/2115979-advanced-htt... They are saying: are you unsure if an IP is a proxy? Well, given that you know so little about it, query all the users on the IP... you know, as long as the IP is USSID 18 compliant... given that you know so much about it already. Hrm.
- MichaelGG 11y agoHard to tell. I remember seeing in the docs somewhere that they suggest capturing for 5 minutes and checking out to make sure it's OK to investigate further. As a practical matter, what more can they do? I wouldn't expect them to actively try to give up on following leads. Seems like the intent of the law is being attempted to be followed.