2 ms·
Companies should provide an option. Let's SWOT this thing. 1099 contractor: * gets paid per ride * road wear, maintenance and mileage is tax-deductible * n
by prostoalex 11y ago
Companies should provide an option.
Let's SWOT this thing.
1099 contractor:
* gets paid per ride
* road wear, maintenance and mileage is tax-deductible
* number of working hours is not capped
* open schedule
* specific geography (mainly airport, mainly residential, mainly events) is up to the contractor
Employee:
* gets paid a set rate per hour
* no car expense is tax-deductible
* number of working hours is capped at 30
* schedule is set by employer
* potential pickup destinations are now more controlled by employer, the app could now demand an employee be at a certain place at a certain time (large sporting event ended, busy hour at the airport, surge in demand in some areas).
The way I see it employee status would be beneficial for some, and contractor status for others. Common assumption in such debate, since that one California driver sued Uber, is that everybody wants to be an employee, meanwhile my UberX conversations with drivers regarding their backgrounds suggest that's not the case, with ability to set their own hours being the key.
- jsprogrammer 11y agoWhy must an employee get a set hourly rate? Car expenses are deductible if they are non-commute miles that are required for employment and that are not reimbursed by the employer. 30 hour / week cap? Uh, where? Why must employer set schedule?
- mahyarm 11y agoOther companies do the 30/hr/wk thing because of benefit payouts. http://cnsnews.com/news/article/obamacare-mandate-anyone-who-works-30-hour-week-now-full-time http://cnsnews.com/news/article/obamacare-mandate-anyone-who...
- prostoalex 11y agoThey don't have to, yet if they don't, they open themselves to larger liabilities (30 hour/week requirement alone will land them into buying medical benefits). Thanks for the correction on mileage deduction, I looked into this, and it turns out mileage is not deductible if the vehicle is being used "for hire" http://www.irs.gov/uac/Car-and-Truck-Expense-Deduction-Reminders http://www.irs.gov/uac/Car-and-Truck-Expense-Deduction-Remin... But that covers both scenarios (1099 or W-2), which makes it a non-point. > Why must employer set schedule? I believe that follows from the Uber argument that cheaper prices increase the usage of the service (and hence surge pricing is beneficial to neither consumer nor Uber). Previously lack of supply was only correctable via surge pricing (which would bring more potential drivers on the road), but now a second corrective mechanism opens up - requiring certain number of vehicles to be present at certain location at certain time.