5 ms·
>as fungible, by-the-hour machines that can be hired and fired as demand shifts I have no problem with a situation like this if A: It's a small-ish minority o
by colechristensen 11y ago
>as fungible, by-the-hour machines that can be hired and fired as demand shifts
I have no problem with a situation like this if
A: It's a small-ish minority of the economy
B: It's well known by both employer & employee from the start
C: Employees get an adequate compensation bump for the increased risk (i.e. both employer and employee benefit from the situation)
There are plenty of people who _want_ that fluidity in their lives and an economy which expects you to be employed 100% of the time between 18/22 and retirement can be stifling.
- datasage 11y agoThe biggest problem is that C rarely happens except for high-skilled positions.
- PaulHoule 11y agoEven then it rarely happens. Although theoretically a contingent worker could be paid more because his employer sheds risks, practically contingent workers are often paid horribly. Just to take an example, it is often shocking how ill-paid and overworked adjunct faculty are. Go look at at the tenured professors and you see they are well paid AND have security. If adjuncts got high pay and the tenured had security it might work out that way, but it never does.
- exstudent2 11y agoI also have no problem with this and never understood the issue. Certainly if being a 1099 contractor for Uber (for example) wasn't the best option for someone, they simply wouldn't do it, right? No one is forcing anyone to be a contractor so the arguments against it from the perspective of the contractor seems odd. People will take the best employment option that works for them. If it's the difference between being a W2 McDonnald's employee or a on-demand 1099 driver, I'd take the 1099 as well.
- revmoo 11y agoYou'd almost certainly make more money at McDonalds.
- colechristensen 11y agoI _do_ have a problem with employers abusing what a 1099 is. Uber drivers don't cut it. McDonalds employees don't cut it. There are a list of things required for being a 1099 employee which involves a whole lot of autonomy for the contractor which are very commonly not provided. Likewise I wouldn't believe a similar argument about employers paying minimum wages because 'nobody is forcing them'
- exstudent2 11y agoI see that as a separate issue around why we feel the need to have rules around what it means to be a 1099. My point is that regardless of the current legitimacy of how Uber et al are handling this, the contractors themselves have a choice to participate or not in the system as it exists today. If it works for them, why would anyone question it?
- colechristensen 11y ago"If you have the right to control or direct not only what is to be done, but also how it is to be done, then your workers are most likely employees," and "If you can direct or control only the result of the work done -- and not the means and methods of accomplishing the result -- then your workers are probably independent contractors." I have no argument with the law as it is. The number of rights/obligations in the employee/employer relationship goes up when the employer exerts. That is, these are rights that employees cannot give away. I am fine with this because if it didn't exist it wouldn't be a matter of 'employees choosing the level of employment they want' but 'employees not given the choice'
- exstudent2 11y agoSo you think if the rules around what it means to be 1099 were relaxed that employers would all band together to take away employee rights? Would market forces then not kick in to push up 1099 contractors rate to cover any needed expenses? It seems we're intervening with the free market where it's not needed.
- wpietri 11y ago> Certainly if being a 1099 contractor for Uber (for example) wasn't the best option for someone, they simply wouldn't do it, right? So if I understand you rightly, you have never known anyone who has done something that they later turned out to regret? You have personally never regretted a choice? And you have never seen rational individual choices that add up to a bad systemic result?
- exstudent2 11y agoSo if I understand you correctly we should limit individual freedom because people may do something they regret? I'll pass, I can make my own mistakes.