4 ms·
Excellent. The Lean (as in Lean Manufacturing) perspective is that you should think of people as assets, not costs. With that perspective, you start thinking:
by wpietri 11y ago
Excellent.
The Lean (as in Lean Manufacturing) perspective is that you should think of people as assets, not costs. With that perspective, you start thinking: How can I invest further in these valuable assets? How can I protect that investment?
A good software example is training. One common objection to spending money on learning and training is, "What if people get better and then leave?" Not recognizing that the alternative is, "What if people stagnate and stay?"
I understand why some companies want to treat workers (programmers, customer service people, anybody) as fungible, by-the-hour machines that can be hired and fired as demand shifts. But I think that traps a lot of companies in a local maximum: there's only so far you can go without continually helping your people up their games.
- joshjkim 11y agoI agree here - this puts pressure on the company to make sure their drivers are (1) more efficient (2) make more $$ and (3) stick around for a while which then goes back to (1) more efficient, and generates a cycle of improvement that benefits everyone. Of course this requires the company to make an upfront investment, but exactly as you said human capital is an asset, not a cost, so IMO it's a solid investment to make. The alternative is the current uber-model which is: (1) Focus on bringing as many people in as quickly as possible (2) try to pay them as little as possible as soon as you can which results in (3) high churn (probably disproportionately churns out the higher-quality folks who won't work for so little) and then leads you back to (1). This results in low quality and high recruitment costs and depletion of the labor pool. Uber did reach a solid state in most markets, but I would argue that they could have spent less on recruiting and retained a higher quality fleet for similar long-term costs, with the added benefit of not looking like a-holes for the past couple years.
- prostoalex 11y ago> this puts pressure on the company to make sure their drivers are (1) more efficient (2) make more $$ Switching to W-2 doesn't necessarily imply full-time employment. In fact, it's in their interest to cap the hours at 30 to avoid the healthcare benefits. Having someone work 10 hours a week on company's schedule and then issuing a W-2 is how a bunch of part-time employers operate.
- colechristensen 11y ago>as fungible, by-the-hour machines that can be hired and fired as demand shifts I have no problem with a situation like this if A: It's a small-ish minority of the economy B: It's well known by both employer & employee from the start C: Employees get an adequate compensation bump for the increased risk (i.e. both employer and employee benefit from the situation) There are plenty of people who _want_ that fluidity in their lives and an economy which expects you to be employed 100% of the time between 18/22 and retirement can be stifling.
- datasage 11y agoThe biggest problem is that C rarely happens except for high-skilled positions.
- PaulHoule 11y agoEven then it rarely happens. Although theoretically a contingent worker could be paid more because his employer sheds risks, practically contingent workers are often paid horribly. Just to take an example, it is often shocking how ill-paid and overworked adjunct faculty are. Go look at at the tenured professors and you see they are well paid AND have security. If adjuncts got high pay and the tenured had security it might work out that way, but it never does.
- exstudent2 11y agoI also have no problem with this and never understood the issue. Certainly if being a 1099 contractor for Uber (for example) wasn't the best option for someone, they simply wouldn't do it, right? No one is forcing anyone to be a contractor so the arguments against it from the perspective of the contractor seems odd. People will take the best employment option that works for them. If it's the difference between being a W2 McDonnald's employee or a on-demand 1099 driver, I'd take the 1099 as well.
- revmoo 11y agoYou'd almost certainly make more money at McDonalds.
- oldmanjay 11y ago> One common objection to spending money on learning and training is, "What if people get better and then leave?" Not recognizing that the alternative is, "What if people stagnate and stay?" it's interesting how many business fallacies boil down to optimizing for pathological cases