4 ms·

The AI box experiment

wlievens 17y ago
What annoys me is that the transcripts have never been revealed. To the OP: you must have reached that article through the same sequence of links I followed when I (re-)discovered it this morning!
- flashingpumpkin 17y ago
  Yeah, kinda annoying, but at the same time challenging to come up with an idea of how to break out of the box. I'd go the humanitarian route being the AI. I've reached it following links from the Alien Message submission on lesswrong.com
  - wlievens 17y ago
    Same for me.
- NikkiA 17y ago
  I think that's probably part of the point. If he revealed that it's just (up to) 2 hours of him going 'let me out! let me out! let me out! let me out!' nobody would take him up on the challenge.
wglb 17y ago
Fascinating idea, and quite a bit more interesting, and with obviously higher stakes than the Turing Test.
jackchristopher 17y ago
There are two good old threads on HN about this: Ask Eliezer Yudkowsky: How did you convince the Gatekeeper to release the potentially genocidal AI?: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=195959 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=195959 My theory on Eliezer Yudkowsky's AI-Box Experiment http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=327427 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=327427
psygnisfive 17y ago
This repeatedly comes up, as if Eliezer Yudkowsky convincing someone to say "Ok you can go free" is somehow indicative of how difficult or easy it would be for a real AI to get let out. Let me put it this way: If it were that easy, out in the real world, I'm fairly certain prisons would be impossible. Keep in mind that the gatekeeper is not obliged to sit and listen to the AI-in-a-box. The gatekeeper is not even obliged to pretend it's a real AI-in-a-box scenario and make the decisions he would make in that situation; you can sit there thinking, nay, SAYING "man this is gonna be the easiest $10 i ever made" for the whole two hours and tough shit for the would-be-AI. I continue to refuse to accept the possibility of Eliezer having won those two rounds without being paired with a completely retarded gatekeeper.

What annoys me is that the transcripts have never been revealed. To the OP: you must have reached that article through the same sequence of links I followed when I (re-)discovered it this morning!

flashingpumpkin 17y ago
Yeah, kinda annoying, but at the same time challenging to come up with an idea of how to break out of the box. I'd go the humanitarian route being the AI. I've reached it following links from the Alien Message submission on lesswrong.com
- wlievens 17y ago
  Same for me.
NikkiA 17y ago
I think that's probably part of the point. If he revealed that it's just (up to) 2 hours of him going 'let me out! let me out! let me out! let me out!' nobody would take him up on the challenge.

wglb 17y ago

Fascinating idea, and quite a bit more interesting, and with obviously higher stakes than the Turing Test.

jackchristopher 17y ago

There are two good old threads on HN about this: Ask Eliezer Yudkowsky: How did you convince the Gatekeeper to release the potentially genocidal AI?: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=195959 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=195959 My theory on Eliezer Yudkowsky's AI-Box Experiment http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=327427 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=327427

psygnisfive 17y ago

This repeatedly comes up, as if Eliezer Yudkowsky convincing someone to say "Ok you can go free" is somehow indicative of how difficult or easy it would be for a real AI to get let out. Let me put it this way: If it were that easy, out in the real world, I'm fairly certain prisons would be impossible. Keep in mind that the gatekeeper is not obliged to sit and listen to the AI-in-a-box. The gatekeeper is not even obliged to pretend it's a real AI-in-a-box scenario and make the decisions he would make in that situation; you can sit there thinking, nay, SAYING "man this is gonna be the easiest $10 i ever made" for the whole two hours and tough shit for the would-be-AI. I continue to refuse to accept the possibility of Eliezer having won those two rounds without being paired with a completely retarded gatekeeper.