4 ms·
Why does the US use a complex 3 injection cocktail? In countries where assisted suicide is legal people just swallow a pill and go peacefully to sleep. Yet in
by sschueller 11y ago
Why does the US use a complex 3 injection cocktail?
In countries where assisted suicide is legal people just swallow a pill and go peacefully to sleep. Yet in the US there is this "crisis" of not being abel to source the injections needed.
Pets are also put down very easily with a single injection which makes them go to sleep and the heart beats slower and slower until it stops in a few minutes.
- githulhu 11y agoThe complexity makes it look like we are going to great lengths to minimize the pain of the condemned, supporting the pretense of a "humane" execution and undermining the claims of opponents that the punishment is cruel and unusual.
- tokenadult 11y agoYet in the US there is this "crisis" of not being abel to source the injections needed. Many medical doctors (persons with legal authority to prescribe drugs) and pharmacists (persons with legal authority to dispense drugs) object to capital punishment, and thus will not supply prisons with drugs that have the sole purpose of killing someone.
- gadders 11y agoSo they wouldn't supply medication for assisted suicide either? Also, allowing people to opt out on supplying the drug on matters of conscience is a slippery slope. What about letting people opt-out of providing abortions? Or marrying gay couples? A case could made for people refusing to do these as matters of conscience as well.
- icebraining 11y agoMultiple countries allow doctors to refuse to perform abortions.
- tP5n 11y agoNo, it's not a slope. Gay marriage and the death penalty are two very different things and I can't believe I'm typing this out. There also numerous reasons to be against the death penalty but not abortions, but something tells me I'd rather not have this discussion here and now [1]. [1] for what it's worth, an example not related but relevant: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9770221 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9770221
- blfr 11y agoThey're not very different if you believe that personal ethical beliefs can be used as a justification to not provide a service.
- chucksmash 11y agoIf you supply drugs to be used in an execution, you are part of a chain of actions that ends with the intentional taking of a life. If you bake a cake for a gay couple, you are part of a chain of actions that sort of, kind of, indirectly might offend your sensibilities. Those two outcomes are vastly dissimilar - equating them because they are both "doing things you object to as a matter of conscience" is too reductionist by half.
- blfr 11y agoIf you supply drugs (or facilities) to be used in an abortion, you are part of a chain of actions that ends with the intentional taking of a life. Same with assisted suicide. But even the magnitude cutoff is arbitrary. At which point is the result "bad enough" that ethical reservations start to apply?
- happyscrappy 11y ago>I'd rather not have this discussion here and now Yes, because you want politics on HN, but only the politics you agree with. All political articles should be flagged.
- 11y ago
- Jtsummers 11y ago> What about letting people opt-out of providing abortions? Or marrying gay couples? A case could made for people refusing to do these as matters of conscience as well. They already can to both your examples. No doctor (excepting, perhaps, military doctors stationed overseas, or so I've been told but not confirmed) can be forced to perform an abortion. Similarly, no member of the clergy is forced to marry gay couples. The only people required to do so, now, would be state officials (justice of the peace) whose job it is to perform weddings and who work for the public (rather than being part of a private, though religious, practice).
- geographomics 11y agoSame drugs but with different intent. Assisted suicide is a compassionate medical treatment for end stage incurable diseases, with full consent of the person being treated. Execution by the state is a coercive, non-medical procedure that deliberately causes harm.
- jkyle 11y ago> What about letting people opt-out of providing abortions? No doctor, hospital, or medical facility has _ever_ been forced into providing abortions. Ever. None. > Or marrying gay couples? No private organization has or ever will be forced to marry gay couples. Ever. None. > A case could made for people refusing to do these as matters of conscience as well. They don't have to make a case. They can just do it. Now. And forever.
- DanBC 11y agoThe other problem with sourcing is the manufacturers refusing to sell medications for use in execution. http://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/dec/19/death-penalty-boycott-drugs-execution-new-low http://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/dec/19/death-penalty-b...
- msandford 11y agoIt'd be nice if a bunch of other companies would be able to find their spines re: objectionable things the government does. Like spying on everyone all the time. You know, like teclos and the like. It's pretty crazy that drug companies are more ethical than telecoms. Especially considering all the problems with reproducability that we're seeing on the cancer treatment front and plummeting drug effectiveness.
- icebraining 11y agoNot sure about those ethics. If you read the article, the main supply restriction was imposed by the European Commission, following the UK government. The US company that used to make them "suspended production because it was suffering commercially as a result of having its drug connected to executions," not exactly based on moral principles. There's also the difference that telecoms have (if secret) court orders mandating them to do so, while drug companies only have a few sales to lose (even at the peak of 300+ executions/year, it's probably not a very lucrative business).
- VLM 11y agoSomething to think about, is if most of the civilized world sees what the executioners are doing as inherently immoral or unethical, the government has nothing to lose by violating medication licenses and laws, its not like the rest of the world is going to see a tiny little delta in immorality or lack of ethics as being much worse. So simply civil forfeiture a pharmacy safe or a chemical plant warehouse, after all the .gov sees civil forfeiture as a universal good...
- gadders 11y agoI have always wondered how it is that there is a humane set of drugs that are used for assisted suicide, but none can be found for the death penalty. (Not that I'm pro-death penalty, but it does seem a contradiction).
- KineticLensman 11y agoSome drug companies / jurisdictions don't allow drugs to be used in ways that they consider unethical https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lethal_injection https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lethal_injection