4 ms·
Google: A friend or the "new Evil Empire"?
- cturner 17y agoGoogle Books is a prime example For the purpose of demonstrating that Google is an evil empire then Google Books is an appalling example. But the consensus is the company fomented an avoidable backlash by forging ahead with its controversial plan without consulting the parties with the most at stake. In the list that follows you may have missed that Temple fails to mention 'consumers'. His perspective stems from a common evil perspective - that the world should rotate around the interests of the current elite.
- ErrantX 17y agoGoogle Books is a prime example, Enderle said. It's an open debate whether the plan to scan millions of books and make them searchable online will prove the benefit to humanity that Google promises - or hand it a monopoly over certain digital works, as opponents allege. The issue I have with statements like this is that it is really searching for the "evillness" in something. If "doing it first" is the new definition of monopoly then that sort of sucks ;)
- apowell 17y agoIt's a monopoly because Google has been granted the exclusive right (via a lawsuit) to digitize and distribute orphaned books. It would be a copyright violation on a grand scale if anyone else were to try. http://www.wired.com/epicenter/2009/06/google_books/ http://www.wired.com/epicenter/2009/06/google_books/
- RyanMcGreal 17y agoIt wasn't Google that initiated the lawsuit. If this turns out to be a landmine, it will be the publishing industry that planted it.
- ErrantX 17y agoReading the whole article I cant come to the same conclusion really. As I read it Google has "sidestepped" the copyright violation via this lawsuit; a step which any other company doing the same thing would also have to do. It's untested (and therefore somewhat difficult to assert with way) whether anyone else could win a similar lawsuit to attain similar rights. Also it is not yet tested whether publishers could be approached with a license model for orphaned work without it having to go to the courts. I think granted the exclusive right is simple an opinion; because none of the court documents appear to grant an exclusive right.
- apowell 17y agoToday Google is the only entity with the legal right to do what they do with the books. If I were to try it, I'd be sued into oblivion by the publishers. For Google, forgiveness was easier than permission. For anyone else, forgiveness won't be an option. The settlement and ruling applies to Google and only Google. Perhaps in the future some organization will slog through the legal system and change that situation. If that happens, it won't be a monopoly anymore. But today it is. http://www.wired.com/epicenter/2009/04/the-fight-over-the-worlds-greatest-library-the-wiredcom-faq/ http://www.wired.com/epicenter/2009/04/the-fight-over-the-wo... (Questions #17 - #21 make the point much better than I am able)
- ErrantX 17y ago> If that happens, it won't be a monopoly anymore. I think the problem is the definition of monopoly. It's arguably a very good thing (tm) [for consumers] that Google have done - if the fact they had to fight the legal system in a way that is beyond the means of most companies makes it a monopoly then that, to me, seems a bit screwy logic. What about the argument they have now paved the way for much simpler lawsuits - or even opened the way for people to convince publishers to license content without needing the courts.... Till someone else bothers to try (note: bothers) this is impossible to judge either way. Also lets be careful here: monopolies aren't necessarily (in a legal sense) "bad". Unfair monopolies are what we have to avoid - and evil ones. This was evidence for Google being an evil corporation; to my eyes it seems hard enough to argue this is really a monopoly let alone one with "evil" intent :) (ultimately the argument does seem to come down to: Congress needs to fix a silly situation)
- RyanMcGreal 17y ago> Google says it does recognize the threat. Like Microsoft a decade ago, it has dramatically scaled up its lobbying and public relations efforts. Hmmmmm.
- potatolicious 17y agoLobbying and PR is a defensive measure that IMHO is justifiable without being evil. There are plenty more competitors out there who will use their deep pockets to curry politicians into doing things to harm you... having your own lobbying strength helps defend against that.
- pchristensen 17y agoI don't see Google as evil, but I do see them as frighteningly hungry.
- compay 17y agoI worry more about Google's future than present - benevolent dictators are great until they decide to stop being benevolent.
- marknutter 17y agoIt depends on who's running the company. If they have someone at the top who has strong ethics, they should continue to be benevolent.
- 27182818284 17y agoI understand Google has made some questionably evil decisions, but I'm bothered by the number of articles written about Google's evilness just because they have a recognizable brand. December 3 marked the anniversary of the Bhopal disaster. An article on December 7 about Google maybe being an evil entity seems like a joke when placed next to what Union Carbide did and continues to do through inaction.