4 ms·
Lennart is very good at the political wrangling required to get code into distros and make it an unavoidable part of using Linux. His actual code quality is not
by makomk 11y ago
Lennart is very good at the political wrangling required to get code into distros and make it an unavoidable part of using Linux. His actual code quality is not so great. PulseAudio is still a mess a decade on, and I gave up even trying to figure out why it breaks because it's a nightmare of misleading variable names and uncommented code. I finally abandoned hope when I tracked down a crash, found that a patch that was literally unfinished and labelled as such had made it into a release before being backed out, realised they don't do stable releases and the next upstream release with the fix would have other major changes with new bugs, and eventually discovered that reverting it didn't even fix the problem. The underlying code was simply broken and there was no way to see how it was ever meant to have worked in the first place, because it was completely uncommented.
systemd seems to have slightly better code, probably because it has kernel developers on the team, but like PulseAudio there are no stable releases. It's up to individual distros to try and turn the stream of upstream releases into something that works. I think this is a Red Hat thing - they're happy to develop new features collaboratively and in the open, but actually turning software into stable, reliable working releases is their secret sauce that people pay them big dollars for. They're also the only major distro that doesn't co-operate with the upstream Linux kernel's process for stable and long-term releases.
- scrollaway 11y agoI think your point about code quality is very poorly expressed, but I'll disregard that for now, I wanted to address this: > I think this is a Red Hat thing - they're happy to develop new features collaboratively and in the open, but actually turning software into stable, reliable working releases is their secret sauce that people pay them big dollars for. I'm not sure what you're talking about. Are you saying RH magically makes stuff stable only on their distro, and doesn't fix bugs in master? Because that's not only BS, it's not permitted by the software licenses they themselves choose. And regardless, yeah, making stable releases is not an obligation. Never have been, never will be. It's a nice thing to do, and often it's useful, but still optional. Web Browsers don't do stable releases (in the LTS sense) anymore either.