2 ms·
It's possible to vigorously and robustly attack software without resorting to insulting the people behind that software.
by DanBC 11y ago
It's possible to vigorously and robustly attack software without resorting to insulting the people behind that software.
- viraptor 11y agoBut this actually does not have anything to do with software. Parts of systemd are pretty good. For many people it's Lennart decisions and leadership that are the problem. This doesn't change even if systemd becomes a bugfree software masterpiece.
- scrollaway 11y agoSystemd enjoys a steady stream of regular and new developers and pretty much all of them seem happy with Lennart. The criticism comes from internet forums and other places, like this one here, which are completely disconnected from the people actually doing the work. Armchair problematism.
- viraptor 11y agoSame description applies to MS's EEE. (they retained and hired developers) Yet, we probably agree the results were terrible. BTW, I'm somewhere in systemd changelog with a security bugfix to an issue in systemd resolver. So I became a "new developer" and I fixed it, because practically I have no choice of init in my system, not because I'm happy with Lennart. I still disagree that systemd should have its own resolver. (and the bug wouldn't even exist if they didn't decide to write their own resolver)
- DanBC 11y agoIt's possible to attack a leadership style and the positions that leader takes without resorting to insults. "Bob, you are being weird and stupid here" will not make Bob change his behaviour. If anything it will make him convinced that he's right and that anyone who opposes him is just another hater.
- vacri 11y agoIn the particular case of the linked article, it is a personal issue, not a software issue. The software is using bad defaults, referencing servers that the owners explicitly say not to reference. The response is, basically, "I'm too lazy to fix this issue". That's not a software problem, it's a problem with the lead dev's behaviour. While we shouldn't resort to outright insults, we also shouldn't shy away from calling out bad behaviour, when it's related to the software at hand.
- DanBC 11y agoYes, we can and should attack the decision. I think we agree that attacking the decision a person makes is different to attacking the person.