2 ms·
I don't think this has anything to do with Cochrane's methodology. This is about choice of presentation. They are very clear in the paper that they are review
by jessriedel 11y ago
I don't think this has anything to do with Cochrane's methodology. This is about choice of presentation.
They are very clear in the paper that they are reviewing a certain body of studies, and that there are other plausible reasons (not backed up by RCTs) to believe water fluoridation could have beneficial effects. The numbers they quote summarize the evidential content of the RCTs. I don't need or want them to bundle this all into one Bayesian percentage. This would be dominated by their own priors which I do not necessary share nor are necessary shared by anyone I discuss the study with. (Yet we can all agree on the frequentist summary of the RCTs.)