4 ms·
Personally, I think this article is very negative, and I think that if the author themselves is unable to live in accordance with the polemic they forward, they
by tedks 11y ago
Personally, I think this article is very negative, and I think that if the author themselves is unable to live in accordance with the polemic they forward, they should reconsider its wisdom.
This isn't a "gotcha." The fact that you need only one line to point out this contradiction is irrelevant.
Further, in this case, it is very much worth posting, because otherwise someone could miss this contradiction and think that the article has any legs at all, when in reality it doesn't, and only exists to sell eBooks.
- Karunamon 11y agoHypocrisy is only a heuristic (and a pretty bad one), it doesn't impact the rightness or the wrongness of the advice given. Someone who smokes telling you that smoking sucks and you shouldn't do it is a great example; do you dismiss them out of hand because they're a hypocrite? All claims should be evaluated on their own merits. The author's selling a book has nil impact on whether their thoughts about consumerism or minimalism are correct.