3 ms·
> First, is that taking away national currency is taking away the ability to print and devalue your way out of trouble, This is only true for the United States
by paganel 11y ago
> First, is that taking away national currency is taking away the ability to print and devalue your way out of trouble,
This is only true for the United States and, partially, for the UK, any other nation on this planet cannot just print their own paper-money and convince lots of foreign investors to buy local-currency-denominated debt. It pains me whenever I see this opinion posted whenever the Greek crisis is mentioned, because I grew up in a country where inflation was running in the high-double-digits for an entire decade, and trust me, there were lots of "trouble" for the Government and for us, normal citizens.
Nevertheless, I think you're spot on with the rest of your comment, I never quite understood how come the Governments are so enamored with the banking system (to this day I think that the 2008 financial crisis could have been a lot less worse had Bear Stearns been allowed to go bust with no strings attached in the early spring of 2008, and its creditors to accept the haircuts). I also believe that no-one knows where this is all going.
- digi_owl 11y agoIts a bit tricky but thing is that "money printing" can be used to buy domestic goods and services, that in turn help pay down business and personal debt. This while also devaluing the currency vs foreign ones, benefiting exporters while giving the population a incentive to spend domestically. But it has to be performed while there is otherwise a slump in the overall economy. I think term is countercyclical spending. And it has to be used on domestically produced goods and services. Otherwise one is just asking for trouble.
- kamaal 11y agoThis might be a newbie question. But why can some countries simply "print money" while others can't and have to earn it?
- hugofirth 11y agoAny country can do it. It comes down to an issue of investor trust, which you only earn through a good track record.
- netcan 11y agoI think the parent is referring to the ability to sell bonds (borrow money) in their own currency. If Zimbabwe wants to borrow money, nobody will agree to be repaid in Zimbabwean currency. So, they need to borrow in foreign currency, which they can't print. But, I think he overstated that point quite a bit. First, most countries do sell bonds in their own currency, so they can print and devalue to pay it back if necessary. They use a combination of their own bonds and foreign denominated bonds. More importantly (especially in Greece's case), most government's obligations are not bonds. They're salaries, pensions and other things denominated in local currency. If Greece had its own currency, they would print more of it and use that money to pay government salaries and pensions. It is true though that the US has an advantage. (A) they have very little foreign currency obligations and (B) inflation is like a cost to everyone that holds a currency. When the US prints money, the cost is spread out among anyone who holds dollars. Lots of them are not american.
- kamaal 11y ago>>If Greece had its own currency, they would print more of it and use that money to pay government salaries and pensions. Doesn't this lead to hyper inflation situations. Basically money is what you trade for effort. When you freely "print money" you are simply supplying a lot of cash for the same effort. In return you simply pay a higher price for the same things. There fore only way to increase the supply of money is to increase trade able effort in some way. How will simply printing money solve anything? And how are few countries exempt from this rule?
- netcan 11y agoIt causes inflation. A lot of it causes hyperinflation. With lots of extra caveats and clauses, naturally. You can think of it as a tax on everyone who holds the currency (or other assets directly tied to it, like bonds). If the government prints money, they have it and they can spend it on (for example) salaries. That solves the problem of not being able to pay salaries. No country is exempt, but if a lot of foreigners hold reserves in your currency, they have to share in the cost of inflating it. Al lot or a little is relative to the total stock of money in circulation. Lots of countries hold US Dollars, so the US can print with milder domestic consequences.