3 ms·
The cab drivers I talk to (which is a fair number, since I still take cabs) by and large hate Uber and are quite happy to talk about it, so if you're really cur
by wpietri 11y ago
The cab drivers I talk to (which is a fair number, since I still take cabs) by and large hate Uber and are quite happy to talk about it, so if you're really curious, drop $20 and ask.
That said, my take: Taxi drivers were mostly contractors, and they did have to rent the cab. But I think that's way better than having to buy the whole goddamn car and then hope that they make it back. Plus paying all of the maintenance and being out of work if a car broke. They also had to pay the medallion fee, but most of them liked that system, because a) it restricted the number of cabs such that they could make decent money if they worked hard, and b) they saw the medallion system as their version of retirement planning. Specifically, here in SF medallions could be bought only by working taxi drivers, and in order on a waiting list. So the ones that talked about it to me were pretty comfortable with the system.
So along those axes, I think Uber is actually worse, and I think that mainly because cabbies say so. I agree that the previous condition still wasn't great, though.
- icebraining 11y agoBut I think that's way better than having to buy the whole goddamn car and then hope that they make it back. Plus paying all of the maintenance and being out of work if a car broke. There are already multiple companies renting cars for driving for Uber/Lyft/etc. Specifically, here in SF medallions could be bought only by working taxi drivers, and in order on a waiting list. So the ones that talked about it to me were pretty comfortable with the system. Yeah, no shit, they got in. It's like measuring the average outcome of a lottery by only surveying the winners. What about everyone who didn't? How do you measure the loss inflicted on everyone who remained unemployed when could they have been working?
- wpietri 11y ago> There already multiple companies renting cars for driving for Uber/Lyft/etc. And what percentage of the total fleet are those? What percentage of the markets are they in? My guess: vanishingly small. And it's also not clear whether those businesses would survive; there's a reason Uber dodged that end of the business. > How do you measure the loss inflicted on everyone who remained unemployed when could they have been working? So your notion here is that there are some number of people who were saying, "Gosh, I wish I could be a taxi driver" but are otherwise sitting around idle because of medallion restrictions limiting supply? What's your evidence that number is greater than zero? As far as I know, taxi companies have pretty much always been hiring in SF. And that's despite the fact that the medallion system artificially boosts individual income through supply restrictions. Also, given that taxi drivers are on the order of 1/1000th of the American labor force, I suspect the medallion system caused exactly zero unemployment, but instead, if it had any effect at all, created an infinitesimal decrease in the labor price.