6 ms·
It's not entirely the Marines' fault. If there was enough room in the budget to credibly deliver a next-gen replacement for the F-16 and F/A-18 platforms as wel
by philwelch 11y ago
It's not entirely the Marines' fault. If there was enough room in the budget to credibly deliver a next-gen replacement for the F-16 and F/A-18 platforms as well as a separate Harrier replacement, the Marines would take it in a heartbeat. The problem is that the Joint Strike Fighter concept is a bean-counting "let's use one plane to meet everyone's requirements" program.
- mcv 11y agoSeveral specialized fighters would probably be a lot cheaper, and they'd all be a lot more effective too. It's really the requirement of "it has to do everything and then some" that's crippling the design here.
- cdash 11y agoWell, maybe we don't need a Navy's Army's Airforce. More importanly, VTOL is a just plain dumb idea and should not be used at all for a jet fighter.
- jcoyne 11y agoThis is due to hard feelings from when the Navy abandoned the Marines at Guadalcanal. Also tradition and territory is so important in the military. They aren't really capable of making some monumental change like doing away with Marine aviation.
- philwelch 11y agoIt's not so much that (Marine aviation existed before the U.S. entered World War I) and more to do with the fact that the Navy and Marines have entirely different aviation missions. The Navy specializes in fleet defense, naval warfare, and light bombing while the Marines specialize in close air support. Different mission specializations, unsurprisingly, call for entirely different technical requirements. Even if the Marines didn't have their own aviation, they would still need close air support from the Navy, and the requirement for a STOVL aircraft would still exist.
- philwelch 11y agoThe Marines specialize in close air support, and for that role STOVL is incredibly useful. It's the only way to effectively deliver close air support with a jet aircraft.
- commandar 11y ago> It's the only way to effectively deliver close air support with a jet aircraft. Not really true. There's a reason why the A-10 is still flying and the Harrier is not.
- Someone1234 11y agoThe Harrier is still flying. The F-35B is set to replace them but since that aircraft hasn't been manufactured in large numbers yet, the Harrier remains in front line service and likely will for many years to come. > The U.S. Marine Corps has extended the retirement date of its AV-8B Harrier IIs in increments until 2030, and most of the fleet will remain active through 2027, according to Boeing, which supports the 1980s-generation strike aircraft. Harriers were originally scheduled for retirement in 2015.
- commandar 11y agoYou know, you're totally right. I was thinking of the British Harriers for some reason.
- astine 11y agoIt's also worth mentioning that the Harrier is an older plane than the A10; by around ~8 years actually.
- dragonwriter 11y agoThe Harrier is, but the thing actually in service (the Harrier II) is newer than the A-10. Harrier introduced 1969 A-10 introduced 1977 Harrier II introduced 1985.
- storgendibal 11y agoLol @Navy's Army's Airforce. Did you coin that?
- a3n 11y agoSynergy!
- bdavisx 11y agoSo you're saying that they couldn't have designed two planes for 500 billion each?
- protomyth 11y agoThey could have, but some dumb fool thought we could design 1 plane for everyone. I cannot remember the movie about that.
- jcoyne 11y agoWe're talking about the F-111, right?
- protomyth 11y agoI think the movie was about the Bradley, but the F-111 was an amazing example of "too many missions".
- TeMPOraL 11y agoIt's from Pentagon Wars, and it's an obligatory YouTube clip always linked in F-35 HN threads: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aXQ2lO3ieBA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aXQ2lO3ieBA.
- fnordfnordfnord 11y agoPentagon Wars, it's brilliant. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iDYpRhoZqBY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iDYpRhoZqBY
- kelvin0 11y agoAgreed, but more specifically here is the 10 minute video which best distills the whole movie. It's worth watching: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aXQ2lO3ieBA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aXQ2lO3ieBA
- 11y ago