11 ms·
Minimum salary required in London: £500k?
- collyw 11y agoThat is nowhere near a minimum salary required. Private schools and £300 a week on groceries, and 20K a year on holidays!??!
- prawn 11y agoMinimum salary to live that particular lifestyle. 20k/year on holidays might be realistic for a family of 4-5 depending on where they went. If they're teenage children, you're getting family suites or two hotel rooms and could easily pay $400+/night. 3-4 trips totalling say 25 days. Airfares add up for 4-5 people. $3k+ on airfares, $10k+ on accommodation. Four people eating out 1-2 times/day. Car hire (SUV rather than a hatchback to fit all luggage), entertainment, etc. I earn peanuts compared to those examples but just had a trip to the States with wife, toddler and infant. Probably cost $20-30k in one 8 week trip and that was without the fourth airfare and generally cramming four of us into budget hotels where possible.
- lucasnemeth 11y agowtf. They're not entitled to keep this stupid and absurd way of living, they don't NEED 500K. I don't care if "their friends" live like that and it's normal between them!! The world is fucked up. this depressed me.
- garagemc2 11y agoNote it is £500k which is more than $750,000.
- dijit 11y agoCrap man, and when I was earning a modest (by comparison) 45k I thought I was decently well off. there is something to be said for the house prices though, I would never go back on anything less than 80K.. I don't mean that in a snobby way- I simply mean my standard of living outside of london would equate to 80K of salary -inside- london. I don't expect people to pay it. it's scary the beast that london is.
- jacalata 11y agoTldr: no, but if we redefine "live in London" as "live in Zone 1, take family of four skiing in France four times a year, send kids to private school from age 3, always eat at Michelin starred restaurants, own multiples of everything Apple ever releases, any other stupid consumerism you can think of" then yes.
- blowski 11y agoExactly. I've got "2.4 family" friends who live in Clapham and Walthamstow, earn about £60K between them and live comfortably. Would they like to have £500K salaries? Of course. Do they need them? Of course not.
- eroded 11y agoReal estate is the biggest struggle. A 3.5-bed family home in Clapham is around £1m, a 4% payment on which would consume their entire net income! source - http://www.londonpropertywatch.co.uk/avg_prices.html http://www.londonpropertywatch.co.uk/avg_prices.html
- makeitsuckless 11y agoSpending quality time with family doing outdoors activities, ensuring good and safe care and education for your children, eating quality food at fine restaurant, buying quality electronics, etcetera are actually the complete opposite of "stupid consumerism". Sounds like an excellent way to spend your money if you have it.
- yetanotheracc 11y agoWhy was this comment downvoted? Genuinely curious. Is merely entertaining a notion of living above £50k subsistence unacceptable in this community?
- kraftman 11y agoBecause you don't need to spend that much to do any of those things. It would be an interesting article if it actually addressed the minimum income needed to achieve that lifestyle.
- JohnyLy 11y agoI would say 50K is required to live well in London and 20K as a minimum salary. 500K as a minimum is ridiculous.
- irremediable 11y ago£20k is a much better estimate. A twentysomething without children can live comfortably on that -- with plenty of money for drinks, gadgets and eating out.
- pjc50 11y agoHow much is that person spending on rent in London?
- Jacqued 11y agoI guess if you earn 20K there are still a few fine bridges in Zone 1.
- alextgordon 11y agoBetween £1k and £2k. You'll be a frequent customer of Wonga. Edit Proletariat: http://www.rightmove.co.uk/property-to-rent/property-53044145.html http://www.rightmove.co.uk/property-to-rent/property-5304414... Bourgeois: http://www.rightmove.co.uk/property-to-rent/property-50619043.html http://www.rightmove.co.uk/property-to-rent/property-5061904...
- p0la 11y agoyour Bourgeois link is not even in London.... For a family with Kid, youar completely missing it: Preletariat 4k : http://www.zoopla.co.uk/to-rent/details/37300477?search_identifier=439f401c0e0c565bc9711bc6360f544d#2zFbk8IFQqY8wtuM.97 http://www.zoopla.co.uk/to-rent/details/37300477?search_iden... Bourgois: 6.5k: http://www.zoopla.co.uk/to-rent/details/37341550?search_identifier=4946f34f8587e288f2fe5d0c604c61d3#FoczMTLlb473A0GK.97 http://www.zoopla.co.uk/to-rent/details/37341550?search_iden...
- n9com 11y agoTitle should be 'Minimum salary required in London to live a life of luxury: £500k'
- jdimov9 11y agoSo, everyone here is bothered that people like to eat well and take family vacations (is this really your definition of "luxury" lifestyle? You guys sound like coal mine workers.) But you're all perfectly fine with the government taking close to half of that income in taxes. Were you all raised in a communist regime?
- pjc50 11y agoLike it or not, it's a lifestyle that only about 10% of the UK can afford. £20k is the holiday budget for a whole decade for most people. And that tax number includes healthcare and pension.
- jdimov9 11y agoOh, I fully agree with that - in fact, in certain other European countries it is more like 0.10%, but that's not the point. The point is - I don't understand all the whining going on here. If I make £500K a year, and I gave it up for £20K a year, would that really make any of you better off? REALLY?
- pjc50 11y agoReplacing the £500k job with ten £50k jobs would make at least nine people better off, yes. The ten people could then manage at least four hundred hours a week of work. It's strange how indivisible the really high paid jobs are.
- lmm 11y agoGiven that London house prices are a function of supply and demand, if everyone on £500k did that then I personally would be a lot better off.
- keithpeter 11y agoAlas, I suspect supply will be very carefully managed to ensure that voters in the UK do not have their main asset devalued over the next 10 to 15 years or so. After that, enough younger people will be renting for the balance to flip and the price correction to occur.
- bechampion 11y agogod...you know how hard is to make 250k in London?? this article is stupid. to give you an idea a well paid devops job that woudl pay about 130 in the US , pays about 80K GBP here in the UK. 250K is for bankers or something man this article is bollooooooox
- devloper 11y agoDrug dealers are doing OK.
- boothead 11y agoDevops contract rate seems to be around £450/day (at the low end). Assuming 21 days per month and 2 months off per year, you'd be looking at £94500 revenue. As a contractor you could expect to pay as little as 25% total tax, but if we assume 30% you're looking at taking home £5.5k per month. Which is a grand more than an £80k salary (with an extra month off). If you're married and have your SO as a shareholder, thus splitting the tax load you can almost match a £200k salary on a day rate of ~£700 (I have seen a few devops type roles getting up towards that figure). So, I agree that £250k salary is very top end, but there are certainly contracts in the finance industry that pay enough to get you close if you change the way you're paid.
- bechampion 11y agoi think the article said that you need 500K a a year. So you have to marry a devops person too, on a contract. the odds shrink a lot the couple isn't a homosexual. Where you need to find a devops woman that makes 500GBP an hour....
- hugofirth 11y agoI should also chime in and say that even for people living in London and sending their children to private schools these estimates are very high. I was luck enough to go to Eton and honestly, for most parents it was a question of affording the fees by: a) not spending that kind of money on other activities; b) lifelong saving; c) selling substantial assets (like second houses etc...); and d) inherited wealth and/or generous grandparents. It was fairly uncommon for student's fees to be paid out of parents' salaries. I would guess (very anecdotal!) that £500k is well above the median annual salary for those parents. Also - apparently this person hires babysitters for >350 nights a year .... o.0
- pjc50 11y agoIs that double-counting babysitting and sending the kids to boarding school? It's certainly a tradition of the English aristocracy to spend as little time with your children as possible.
- hugofirth 11y agoHaha - I hadn't even considered this. So yeah - the cost of childcare is largely not going to overlap with the cost of private education (where that private education includes accomodation of course).
- keithpeter 11y agoScholarships still in evidence at all?
- hugofirth 11y agoAbsolutely! For a start 17 students each year are fully funded. Then there are 25 additional fully funded scholariship students are taken on at the beginning of the penultimate year (called 6th form year in the UK). Added to these are are lots of partial scholarships available, though the ways in which these are funded and obtained are a little more roundabout. The Music department in particular often gave prospective students scholarships of up to 90% of fee totals.
- cmdkeen 11y agoThe article is also making an assumption that people on £500k a year are using the NHS. Unless you're Mrs Miliband private health insurance is almost certainly going to be part of your employment package, because if you're earning that much then the productivity hit of waiting for NHS treatment is likely to be more than the cost of private health coverage. This is another reason why I love living in Edinburgh, the salary difference is far smaller than the "nice life" cost of living difference.
- boothead 11y agoI just about to buy a house outside of London. I'm also about to send my 2 kids to private school as all the decent local state schools are full with waiting lists (thankfully a lot cheaper than the figures mentioned here). I had a look at one of the options for commuting into London. This is the quickest option from where I am (via HS1). I'm already up to the following monthly expenses: Mortgage: £3200 School Fees: £1375 Travel: £450 (next cheapest is £300) Insurance: ~£300 (Critical Illness, Life insurance) Bills: £1500 (guestimate) These are a mix of expenses I'll have to pay personally, and some that I can pay as business expenses. So I'm up to £7k monthly outgoings already, without even trying. In reality I'll need to add another £3k ish for loan repayments and other bits. As a contractor I'm able to be quite tax efficient, but as a single salary earner, http://www.thesalarycalculator.co.uk/salary.php http://www.thesalarycalculator.co.uk/salary.php tells me I'd need to be earning > £200k to cover this. I could economize. I could get a cheaper car for example and I could have bought a cheaper house - the one I'm buying certainly isn't a palace though. But, yeah - London is expensive!
- chrisseaton 11y agoSchool fees for two of £1375 a month seems pretty reasonable compared to what I thought. What kind of standard of school do you get for that? What age? Day or boarding? Does that include things like uniforms, sports and trips?
- boothead 11y agoIt's a small independent primary school founded 80 years ago and still located in the original founder's house (and out buildings). It's a non-profit so all fees go to the upkeep of the school. Classes are about 15 students. Those fees don't include any trips or uniforms I don't think, and it's about a mile from the house we're buying so it's definitely day :-) The main thing that's attractive about it is the focus on the "person development" side of the child's education (in addition to excellent academics). Last time I went to my oldest daughter's parents evening the whole content was: "Well, she's at so-and-so percentile for this subject and such-and-such metric this and that". Nothing at all about how she is as a person, or anything beyond the metrics that Ofstead judges schools on. She's 7!
- richmarr 11y agoThe degree of entitlement evidenced by this article is seriously distasteful. If private school from age 3 is part of a "minimum" lifestyle, exactly how does the author describe the lifestyle of all the kids who go to state schools? Zone 1 indeed.
- prawn 11y agoThe author is describing their friends, not themselves. It doesn't sound entitled to me to describe what they're witnessing and wonder about the figures. The discrepancy comes from that being described as a "minimum" (and thus linkbait headline) when really it should be qualified at all levels as minimum for that lifestyle.
- richmarr 11y agoSure, you can minimise the relevance of the "discrepancy" and claim that the author isn't entitled, but the entire enterprise of this article is based on the premise of discovering whether these really are the "minimum" living costs. Is it a "discrepancy" or is it the way the author sees the world? The end of the article even asks: "Frugalists: With such a cost structure, where would you start saving first?" Not "lower earners", but "frugalists". That's people who earn £500k but don't necessarily want to spend it all. The author isn't even addressing the paupers who only earn £250k, or the near-beggars who only earn £100k.
- prawn 11y agoFrom memory, "minimum" was the term used by his friends. It's more about them than the way the "author sees the world". I think you're reading too much into someone's exploration of a particular situation. It remains an opportunity for you or anyone else to run through the expenditure of any of those other pricepoints you mentioned. Though obviously they are unlikely to reach HN because they're not quite as exciting or outrageous.
- richmarr 11y agoI think you're reading too much... The author has thought about, analysed, and written an essay on this subject, using the word "minimum" regularly (including in the title) and not once gave a single nod to anyone earning less than £500k/year... then going on to address people that wanted to consider spending less as "frugalists". Maybe you're right, maybe I'm just primed to think the author entitled because they self-identify as a "High net worth personal finance blogger".
- SeanDav 11y agoFor comparison purposes, if one wants a benchmark for a top notch salary, then it is common practice to use the salary of the Prime Minister, who earns £142k.
- pjc50 11y agoWeirdly, that's not even the highest salary in the public sector. And you occasionally get MPs complaining that it's "not enough to live on" (which in comparison to the £500k couples it isn't). Malcolm Rifkind got himself in the news lately for hiring himself out and saying "I'm not paid a salary", while earning £67k for being an MP and ~£110k for being a nonexecutive director of Unilever a few days a week. At least the job of PM comes with the use of two houses and a car.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- lmm 11y agoFor any given number I'm sure you can come up with a lifestyle that costs that much. Costs expand to consume the money available. So I don't think anyone will ever reach financial independence "without changing your lifestyle." There are always things you would have spent the money on. The trick is deciding which you care about, and whether you value them more than independence.
- kspaans 11y agoI would asssume that the £30k without paying income tax Very comfortable life: £30k per year. Which still corresponds to £40k gross salary (roughly 1.5x statistical median wage), but with tax-efficient asset allocation you can relatively easily achieve £30k per year without paying any income taxes comes from drawing down savings rather than earning income? At £40k annual income, your effective tax rate is 14.7%[0], so without complicated self-employed tax reporting (deducting most of your expenses), I don't see how you can reduce taxes on earned income. Sure, the ISAs (read: tax-free savings accounts) give you tax-free earnings, but they haven't been around long enough for you to make all of your income from them[1]. 0 - https://www.gov.uk/income-tax-rates/current-rates-and-allowances https://www.gov.uk/income-tax-rates/current-rates-and-allowa... 1 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Individual_Savings_Account#Origins https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Individual_Savings_Account#Ori...
- rozza 11y agoAmazing, really tells more about keeping up with the Joneses and the societal pressure to conform to their expectations. As you earn more money, your social circles change and there is a cost to moving into that circle. You have to live in the right area, dress in the right clothes and drive the right car. So the costs increase to levels that seem exorbitant to people on "average" salaries but really they are just as much slaves to the system as anyone else. The trick is to earn good money and not spend it on frivolities, but marketeers and advertisers work hard to get people to spend their hard earned cash to great effect.