4 ms·
For people who don't understand the context, this is incredibly misleading. >the Air Force organized specifically to test out the F-35’s prowess as a close-ran
by colechristensen 11y ago
For people who don't understand the context, this is incredibly misleading.
>the Air Force organized specifically to test out the F-35’s prowess as a close-range dogfighter
They fail to mention that dogfighting is as antiquated as Snoopy and the Red Baron. Talking about this test without the context is plain irresponsible.
Modern air superiority strategy is about delaying detection with stealth combined with advanced electronic warfare and coordination intelligence suites to destroy the enemy before he even sees you, or at least when it's much to late to have any meaningful response. It isn't 'perfect' stealth, but it doesn't need to be. Just need to get close enough that your missiles get to where the need to go opening up the theater for other assets to do their thing.
"Too close for missiles, switching to guns" is ancient history.
The F-35 is no good at dogfighting because it wasn't designed to be, the test was just something you do to test your outer limits. "Failing" isn't failure.
- srean 11y ago> dogfighting is as antiquated as Snoopy and the Red Baron So they said during Vietnam too.
- colechristensen 11y agoPeople being wrong on a subject 40 years ago doesn't mean the same arguments are valid today.
- lagadu 11y agoHad they really felt that dogfighting was obsolete, the F-35A wouldn't have a gun.
- tsotha 11y agoYes, and that was fifty years ago. Let's put this into context. Fifty years before US involvement in Vietnam Manfred von Richthofen was on the cutting edge of air combat.
- colechristensen 11y agoPeople who downvote, why? Is it because you think I'm factually incorrect or a simple distaste for a military hardware program or what?
- zipwitch 11y agoI'd guess you got downvoted for a number of reasons. People do dislike the program. The F-35 has been hyped and sold as a good dogfighting aircraft. That dogfights are now obsolete and replaced by missiles is the exact claim made before Vietnam, and is going to push some buttons. Also, there's no real-world evidence that its true. And as earlier comments indicate, if close-combat agility is completely unnecessary, then the whole F-35 program has proceeded from really flawed presumptions and needs to be re-thought.
- Mikeb85 11y agoCounter-measures are a thing. They are equally as advanced as missiles. Assuming both planes are equally matched technologically, neither will destroy the other with long range missiles, and the result will always be a dogfight. It just hasn't happened in awhile because world powers have been taking on weaker countries.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]