4 ms·
> So are they claiming that it infringes copyright if your implementation is a superset or a subset of the original implementation, but if it is an exact implem
by wtallis 11y ago
> So are they claiming that it infringes copyright if your implementation is a superset or a subset of the original implementation, but if it is an exact implementation, then it's not copyright infringement?
They're claiming that any of the above would require an API license, and that a license (requiring GPL for the implementation) was granted only to the latter, so a subset would be unauthorized infringement.
- pyre 11y agoBut when you start creating an implementation, it ends up being a subset while it is a work in progress. Are you stating that works in progress are infringing, until they become "magically" not infringing at the point where they reach parity? Does Mono infringe on Microsoft's .NET API because it has always lagged behind the official .NET API, even though the goal of the project is to achieve compatibility?
- wtallis 11y ago.NET isn't relevant because Microsoft isn't trying to control it with the same kind of licensing terms that Oracle's using to try to ensure that anybody else's Java implementation adheres to their standards.