9 ms·
The Law on Cursing at Cops
- Karunamon 11y agoNot to be a downer, but the practical effect of this ruling is nil. You curse out a cop, he'll just ruin your day and the taxpayers will foot the bill even if you successfully complain. The cop got to flaunt his ego and show up the uppity citizen who backtalked him. He still won, even if he "lost" in the end.
- qopp 11y agoThe practical effect of this ruling is that: instead of spending time in prison or paying a large fine and having a misdemeanor on record-- you just have to spend a night in a jail and go to a few court hearings.
- meric 11y agoBeing offended at a flipped bird loses the citizen's respect, and increases citizen's contempt for officers. Even as his ego won, trust in the police is diminished. Imagine a police acting out and making an arrest due to anger, as opposed to a police that winks and says, "Have a nice day to you too.". Which officer would you respect more? http://www.quora.com/What-are-common-shit-tests http://www.quora.com/What-are-common-shit-tests
- XorNot 11y agoIt doesn't matter. There is no individual benefit to doing this. It is a stupid idea to go through life presuming you can do, and it's to an extent, a violation of the social contract: we notionally let people do all sorts of things on the assumption that they will generally avoid doing them but that human nature is a finicky beast. You want good and fair outcomes from the police force? Then be respectful, but also support a justice system which won't screw someone over for just having a bad moment.
- meric 11y agoIf the police force wants to be respected, then it must act in a way worthy of respect. Showing respect where none deserved is like painting the brown leaves of a dying tree green to make yourself appreciate it. Respect stems from behaviour like fruit springing from a tree. Neglect the tree, lose the fruit. Act foolishly, lose respect. The US police has lost my respect, because there are so many instances of police getting offended at flipped birds - none of which I'm responsible.
- na85 11y agoWhat you seem to be missing or perhaps just not acknowledging is that the police don't care. They'll get paid whether you respect them or not.
- dragonwriter 11y agoIf enough voters don't respect them, that stops being true. Police get the pay, benefits, etc., that they do as outputs of as political process that rests on those decisions not resulting in political costs to the politicians making them.
- meric 11y agoFrom the article, the way they are acting shows quite obviously they do care. If they didn't care about being insulted, they wouldn't be making the arrests. But they will continue to be insulted and viewed in contempt - it's akin to children demanding to be seen as being very grown up. They will continue to be paid - using monies from taxes and bonds and civil asset forfeiture. The will continue to demand raises, and it will continue to put pressure on the citizens. You and I don't have to do anything, there is nothing to do. Anything that don't last forever, won't.
- megablast 11y ago> There is no individual benefit to doing this. Completely wrong. It is how change happens. If we accept this bad behavior, it becomes ingrained, and we all suffer.
- bradleyjg 11y ago"You can beat the charge, but you can't beat the ride."
- Brian-Puccio 11y agoI've heard it as "you can beat the rap, but you can't beat the ride".
- my-bullshit-job 11y agoOr if you're Freddie Gray, 'You can beat the rap, but the ride will kill you'
- wtbob 11y agoYeah, that one entry about the pepper spray made me think, 'what if a judge could sentence an improperly-arresting officer to the same treatment?' I bet a nasty afternoon in a cell with pepper-spray in one's eyes would do wonders for some people…
- tptacek 11y agoCan anyone find a case in which epithets directed at a cop were the basis of a criminal charge that was (a) contested and (b) upheld? Every single case in this page resulted in exoneration.
- ch4s3 11y agoI've read that's it often used to charge people with resisting arrest. (sorry no citation)
- qopp 11y agoChaplinsky v. New Hampshire
- ghaff 11y agoIt's interesting that this (unanimous) Supreme Court decision seems to take a more restrictive line on permissible speech than the examples provided in the article. I'm not familiar, however, with intervening case law. ----- The complaint against Chaplinsky stated that he shouted: "You are a God-damned racketeer" and "a damned Fascist". Chaplinsky admitted that he said the words charged in the complaint, with the exception of the name of the deity... Writing the decision for the Court, Justice Frank Murphy advanced a “two-tier theory” of the First Amendment. Certain “well-defined and narrowly limited” categories of speech fall outside the bounds of constitutional protection. Thus, “the lewd and obscene, the profane, the slanderous,” and (in this case) insulting or “fighting” words neither contributed to the expression of ideas nor possessed any “social value” in the search for truth. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chaplinsky_v._New_Hampshire https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chaplinsky_v._New_Hampshire
- desdiv 11y agoSee https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fighting_words#Post-Chaplinsky https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fighting_words#Post-Chaplinsky Basically the fighting words doctrine from Chaplinsky has been steadily narrowed over the years.
- mc32 11y agoI'm of several minds on this. One, yes crude language is protected speech. On the other hand people who deal with lots of grief hourly deserve some kind of protection from daily verbal abuse. On the other hand, some of the abuse is likely attributable to "arrogance" on the public servant. So perhaps these people should receive training and become fireable, or at least reassigned if if becomes chronic. But being public employees and in a labor union, that's not going to happen. Still, I understand its a tall order to ask people to put up with awful abuse day after day. Imagine you are a woman and the majority of people you process through are unenthusiastic males. You are bound to get fed up.
- GuiA 11y agoIn the ideal society, all citizens are equal in rights and privileges. But we don't live in a perfect society, and so we have public servants: citizens who have more rights than other citizens (eg. blowing through a red light without repercussions for a police officer) in the intent of them using those extra rights for the benefit of society. This is a tremendous privilege; it cannot come for free. It comes at the price of being open to any and all forms of criticisms (public and private) from other citizens, whether this criticism is in the form of a polite letter or a middle finger. You could try to legislate that only "constructive criticisms" are to be tolerated, but that's a very slippery slope towards a police state. The cost of allowing citizens to call officers "assholes" is one that we absolutely want to take on.
- betenoire 11y ago> On the other hand people who deal with lots of grief hourly deserve some kind of protection from daily verbal abuse. hmmm.. do they? we are talking about law enforcement, which aside from being a public service is also _THE_ authority figure. The right to talk shit to authority is very important to me.
- mc32 11y agoOf course it is. and it should not be abridged, but we should not underestimate the abuse public servants who interact with people face daily. Ideally, there would be a way to balance this, but there isn't. So the fairest solution is for one side to take it for the team (society) and that is the public servant side (parking meter maid, police, bus driver, dmv employees, social services employees, etc. Still, it's not fair and I certainly would not work as public employee dealing with people who unload their problems on the face of the state.
- deckar01 11y agoI'm ready for a state to require verification of a crime before a person is detained. Put the person into the police car, connect to a video conference with a review board, review the footage of the police officer's FPV cam, and let the person go if no crime was committed. Having the power to waste someone's time is too much power.
- qopp 11y agoIn the big picture an arrest and the subsequent legal proceeding isn't a big deal in someone's life if they are exonerated. We shouldn't short-cut the legal process with a quick, possibly faulty process.
- deckar01 11y agoThe current faulty shortcut is to plead guilty for a crime you didn't commit [1]. That is not justice. Being processed in a time frame that matches the severity of the crime seems more fitting. [1] http://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/the-basics-plea-bargain.html http://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/the-basics-plea-barga...
- prutschman 11y ago> isn't a big deal in someone's life if they are exonerated It is if they lose their job because they're in jail. It is if they don't have anyone else to look after their kid while they're in jail. It is if they can't afford court fees.
- uhwhat 11y agoCourts are overwhelmed because laws rarely get revoked, revised, or modernized. 6th amendment to the US constitution: In all criminal prosecutions, the accused shall enjoy the right to a speedy and public trial, by an impartial jury of the State and district wherein the crime shall have been committed, which district shall have been previously ascertained by law, and to be informed of the nature and cause of the accusation; to be confronted with the witnesses against him; to have compulsory process for obtaining witnesses in his favor, and to have the Assistance of Counsel for his defense
- barlescabbage 11y agoFolks are getting really carried away with this type of thing. If you curse out a cop, you're probably up to no good and you will be harassed or detained. If not then you're an idiot. Why curse out a cop? Why? Crime could possibly get worse with the consequences of this recent anti-police sentiment which isn't really fact driven but an availability bias drummed up by the news, social media, etc. By injecting excessive bureaucratic checks in the manner in which police keep the peace, we're putting a hurdle in front of their ability to provide it.
- wfo 11y agoThe anti-police sentiment is certainly fact-based. The apologists claiming "it's really not that bad" because they desperately wish it to not be that bad aren't really fact-driven, they are illusory-comfort-from-a-place-of-privilege driven. Social media and the news just make it possible for us to hear the facts; normally they would never surface because the police lie to cover each other. And about the cursing, sometimes when people are being abused by bullies who are supposed to protect them they get angry and mouth off; they are human. It's obviously not a measured logical decision, it's a natural response to someone abusing their power, being a jerk, or even just doing their job when it happens to cause problems for you. Cops aren't gods who get to beat you up and lock you in a cage because you don't act like an obedient servant. Is it smart? No. But it's fully understandable, emotional, and human.
- Retra 11y agoThere's a lot of "argument from ignorance" style "if it doesn't happen to me, it doesn't happen at all" thinking when it comes to understanding disparate communities and their perceptions.
- mbillie1 11y ago> If you curse out a cop, you're probably up to no good I just want to point out that this is an overwhelmingly class-based statement. If you are materially comfortable, especially if you're white, you would likely never have the slightest reason to curse at the police. If you are constantly seeing friends harassed and detained without cause, shot and killed, or experiencing it yourself (as at least a few of the folks in this article seemed to experience it), you might think a little differently. It's easy to make the fallacious argument that "anyone mixed up with the police was up to do good in the first place" when you live in a relatively affluent area, when you are not perceived as a "dangerous minority", etc.
- tallerholler 11y agoI was arrested for "resisting arrest" after questioning two young punk cops that dragged my younger sister backwards from her bedroom during a house party at her house in college. I continually asked on what grounds they were arresting me and was never given an answer other than that I was arrested for resisting arrest. It was total bullshit but the whole point is that the cops can do whatever they want to you, like it or not. PS once they put me in the cop car and I knew they were seriously going to take me to jail, the cop in the car said "I bet you hate it when men grope your sister..." as his partner was frisking her outside the car... Real quality humans.
- MichaelApproved 11y agoDepending on where this took place, "resisting arrest" can mean obstructing. You can be charged with it if you're interfering with an officer. I'm not saying it's just, I'm just explaining that the name of the charge isn't necessarily descriptive of the underlying statute. http://www.shouselaw.com/resisting-arrest.html http://www.shouselaw.com/resisting-arrest.html
- tallerholler 11y agodefinitely.. and that's where the cops have true power. anything show of defiance or questioning can be construed as obstructing or interfering no problem...
- ende 11y agoWe need a police force for the police force. They can't arrest citizens, only police officers, and they are completely independent of the primary power structure. They answer only to a permanent rotating grand jury. If a cop is accused of abusing their authority, it's not their precint captain or internal affairs that they will answer to. They'll be arrested themselves and brought before brought before the grand jury with plenty of ACLU advisors on hand.
- anon4 11y agoYou mean something like a Court Martial? I agree.
- veidr 11y agoSorta interesting article, but I wish it gave more details on the outcomes. Obviously, as a society we should demand that police officers uphold extremely high standards of conduct, given their power and position, and this certainly includes being called a fucking stupid asshole pig (or whatever) without responding violently/illegally. It's not a crime to insult a cop, and if pepper spray and handcuffs are used in absence of a crime, there should be negative consequences for the police officer and his department. More info an the Greene case: http://law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/F3/310/889/495675/ http://law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/F3/310/...