3 ms·
I wonder whether, for example, Java's "double sinh(double x)" from java.lang.Math could be found to be infringing on the pre-existing "double sinh(double x)" fr
by pcwalton 11y ago
I wonder whether, for example, Java's "double sinh(double x)" from java.lang.Math could be found to be infringing on the pre-existing "double sinh(double x)" from math.h. The API is literally textually equivalent, right down to the variable names, despite the language being different.
(I'm genuinely curious what case law now considers the line to be; this isn't a rhetorical question.)
- rayiner 11y agoInfringement requires copying, not just text equivalence. If the C programmer was "writing C" and the Java programmer was "writing Java" there is probably no infringement because there is no copying.
- pcwalton 11y agoThanks, that's helpful. (java.lang.Math is awfully similar to math.h; I actually wonder if, historically, there was copying.)
- jacobolus 11y agoHistorically, almost everything in computing is a copy of a copy of a copy, usually ultimately leading to some pseudocode in an academic journal somewhere. If everyone along the line asserted their copyright, the whole field would collapse.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]