8 ms·
Bitcoin is Unsustainable?
- TheDong 11y agoAnother dynamic of bitcoin is that mining is not purely motivated by block rewards; even if there were no rewards at all, people who owned bitcoins would be incentivized to continue mining in order to secure their own currency holdings. For example, if I had 100BTC and I feared that they would halve in value if the bitcoin network had a successful technological attack, it would be quite reasonable for me to spend up to half the amount of coins I had in mining/securing the network, regardless of other profit... and that arms race also continues even with no money gained from mining due to increasing vested interest. I think this dynamic is often lost in people estimating what amount of mining a rational actor would undertake.
- Someone 11y agoHalf of the money over what time frame? If that's per year, you're facing 50% devaluation of your property per year. That may be your best choice, but it surely isn't enticing for people to enter the game, or keep playing it. So, that would kill Bitcoin.
- dperfect 11y agoAs long as markets exist to transfer bitcoin to other currencies, I believe that effect is probably negligible. If a miner holds a significant portion of their rewards in bitcoin and there exists a credible threat to the network, it will almost certainly be more advantageous to convert that value to another currency rather than continue mining in hopes of saving the network.
- reddytowns 11y agoIf you owned stock in Pepsi, and their business looked like it was going to go under, would you drive down to the plant and help them bottle the stuff? The rational response in your scenario would be to sell your BTC and diversify into other assets. Trying to secure the network yourself suffers from the tragedy of the commons. There is no real incentive besides altruism to not let others bear the cost of doing the work and ride on their coattails.
- beaner 11y agoYou might not, but if Pepsi produced 90% of the demand for drinking bottles, the bottle makers might. Similarly, bitcoin companies which are not currently miners but which profit from providing bitcoin-related services might have incentive to step in. (Coinbase, Circle, BitPay, etc.)
- chaostheory 11y agoSomeone I know covered his roof in solar panels. Instead of buying a big battery, he just runs a BC server farm. It's not unsustainable.
- cryptoz 11y agoThat only works if it becomes part of the BTC protocol that you can only mine if the electricity comes from renewable, non-polluting sources. Otherwise, due to solar not being the cheapest, most accessible source of energy everywhere that people want to mine BTC, you'd have lots of people choosing to increase greenhouse gas emissions in order to fill their own pockets. It would be interesting to see estimates of the cost of those greenhouse gasses, in terms of extinct species, effort to clean up the atmosphere, or other expensive/bad things that can happen when you claim that increasingly using energy in non-efficient ways is just fine. Are these costs higher or lower than the value of the money created? Perhaps BTC is sustainable, but your argument certainly does not refute the article's claim - at least, until we've already solved our energy & pollution problems.
- chaostheory 11y agoIf bitcoin does become even more mainstream, given its energy requirements and the potential strain it may put on existing traditional infrastructures; will solar and other alternative power sources always be more expensive?
- lmm 11y agoThere's no economy of scale for solar - just more and more panels, in contrast to more traditional power sources where running one big boiler / set of turbines can be more efficient. So I think solar gets worse off as electricity demand increases.
- eru 11y agoThere's an economy of scale in producing solar panels. And there can be economies of scale in installing them.
- FatalLogic 11y agoThere is no question mark in the original title, though probably there should be one. It's only one character, but adding it has significantly changed the meaning of the title. The article is full of confident statements of opinion, presented as facts, so I don't think the writer intended to make that title into a question and invoke Betteridge's Law of Headlines. Whether it's correct or not, it does seem like the issues raised in this article have been discussed many times before during the past 5 years. Is there anything really new? Here's some reaction to it from the pro-bitcoin side: http://redd.it/3bj0vo http://redd.it/3bj0vo
- javajosh 11y agoThe central problem that banks solve is the shared-truth problem, and banks solve it by being the score-keepers. Alice's bank owes her $100; Bob's bank owes him $100. If Alice pays Bob $50, Alice's bank owes her $50, and Bob's owes him $150. That's all there is to it. The key is that the banks have to agree on the truth. A check from Alice to Bob is a statement from her saying "I pay Bob $50", he endorses it, saying, "I accept $50 from Alice" and then the two banks at some point say "1-2-3 go!" and make the change simultaneously. Until I understand how Bitcoin does that, I will not believe in it. And don't give me hand-wavy bullshit. Speak plainly. EDIT: Yes, downvote me for wanting to understand, you bitcoin bastards.
- throwaway3453 11y agoYou're being downvoted because you didn't put in the effort to explain why you misunderstand Bitcoin transactions. Further, your tone is aggressive and instigative.
- iopq 11y agoBitcoin is a distributed ledger of all transactions. Alice mines 100 BTC. That "mining" transaction is recorded on the ledger and distributed to all the other miners and they accept it because it has the correct math behind it. Bob wants to buy 100 BTC because he wants to deposit to an online poker site and the regulations don't allow him to deposit using a credit card. He goes to Alice in person and gives Alice USD and Alice transfers Bob 100 BTC. Carol mines the block that contains the transaction. Carol gets some BTC for mining and also verifies that the transaction from Alice to Bob is legitimate because it was signed by Alice. Therefore, since Carol mined a legitimate block it's accepted by all the miners. Now all miners agree that Bob has 100 BTC. The answer for all of this is math. Cryptography proves that these things happened.
- DanWaterworth 11y ago> Until I understand how Bitcoin does that, I will not believe in it. And don't give me hand-wavy bullshit. Speak plainly. You're probably being down-voted because that information is available to you. You just need to look for it.
- facepalm 11y agoThere seems to be a factual error in this: other than what the article claims the number of transactions should not change the amount of energy required. The Mining network mines a block roughly every 10 minutes, no matter how many transactions there are. If the amount of transactions rises, the cost in Bitcoin per transaction rises, not the energy required. The cost in Bitcoin rises because you have to give the miners an incentive to actually process the transaction (that is, include it in a mined block). Since the number of transactions per block is limited, there is a bidding competition. What increases the energy required is only the mining, which depends on the value of Bitcoin. The more valuable Bitcoin is, the more miners will be thrown at it, consuming more energy. Correct me if I am wrong...
- lhl 11y agoThere is currently a (ballpark) 7tps limit due to the current 1MB block size limit although this is currently under the subject of intense discussion/debate and will likely be solved in the coming months/years by a combination of increases to the block size (imminent), and the deployments of technologies like side chains and lightning network (both under development).
- HappyTypist 11y agoThe author of this article has a misconception that the marginal cost for processing a bitcoin transaction is "1.57 American household's yearly consumption". That's not correct -- the marginal cost is closer to the electricity spent by your processor in rendering this web page. It is the upfront cost of getting a partial SHA256 collision and being able to add transactions to the blockchain that is massive, at least for this level of transactional volume. Bitcoin becomes more sustainable the more people use it, as the average TX costs goes down. Whether other consensus systems like Proof of Stake should replace Proof of Work is a more interesting question.
- uhwhat 11y agoProof of state only further incentives hording, generally making it undesirable for economic activity.
- reddytowns 11y agoThis is why I hope that Proof of Stake currencies currencies like Neucoin take off.
- liamzebedee 11y agoExactly. Many like to focus on the shortcomings of Bitcoin (of which there are many, I agree). Some more even like to predict the 'death of Bitcoin' based on these. However we shouldn't ignore the fact that cryptocurrency is developing rapidly (hell, it's only 6 years old), and many obvious issues are being slowly but surely worked on (privacy, wallet security, energy consumption, mining decentralisation, sustainability and tx fees, microtransactions, contracts, scripting, etc.). As for when it hits mainstream consumer adoption, who knows. I'm here for the ride.
- Animats 11y agoThe mining farm linked in that article is from last year. A more modern one is shown here.[1] This new one is located in a cold, mountainous part of China next to an underutilized hydroelectric plant, so they have free cooling and cheap power. They've been able to avoid cable clutter; their power distribution uses aluminum busbars, and they seem to have an in-house network that doesn't require vast numbers of long cables. (The data rate for a Bitcoin miner is very low; you only need to talk to it when setting a new block starting point and if it finds a block.) [1] https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=1072474.0;all https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=1072474.0;all
- awjr 11y agoThat link is absolutely fascinating and a very honest account.
- personjerry 11y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong, but the idea of the blockchain is that everything is recorded in it right? So there is more and more information stored in there, redundantly. So eventually it'll take way too much space for everyone? (And the more adoption there is, the faster this process is)
- beaner 11y agoTwo points, which are not by any means the whole story but simply things to consider: - Hard drive space is increasing faster than the blockchain size - New protocols like sidechains and the lightning network could help offload much of the transaction load, making certain bitcoin transactions essentially an settlement representing many thousands, thereby dramatically reducing overall data size.
- beedogs 11y agoThe blockchain can be truncated to move old transactions off. There's also no need to work with the entire thing unless you're mining. http://bitcoin.stackexchange.com/questions/2798/are-there-any-studies-into-the-size-of-the-blockchain-scaling-over-time http://bitcoin.stackexchange.com/questions/2798/are-there-an...
- ucho 11y agoYes, that's one of main argument raised against increasing transactions per block - it would increase block size and ledger growth rate.
- beaner 11y agoIncreasing the block size doesn't increase the transactions per block. Usage does.
- Hermel 11y agoYes, that's why using a blockchain is only feasible for applications that do not generate too much data. With one transaction being 500 bytes in size, a billion transactions occupy 500 GB, which is still managable by an average PC. Once Bitcoin reaches Visa-level transactions rates (100 million per day), there's 500 TB of transaction data per year. That would be a problem for today's network, but it is still in the realm of feasibility as long as the professionalization continues.
- retrogradeorbit 11y agoSo what is not covered is how this cost of bitcoin compares to the cost of the present central-bank full-fiat system. Take into account the London whale, the libor scandal, forex fixing, comex cartels, all the fees and charges that are skimmed at every stage and flow into the ridiculous levels of Wall Street/The City profits. Take all the criminal actions and the fact that it seems the financial law enforcers are incapable now of bringing financial criminals to justice. How does the bitcoin cost compare to those costs? I don't know, but if I was a gambling man I'd bet that bitcoin is orders of magnitude less expensive. Does anyone have any figures to compare these?
- Hermel 11y agoThe implementation of FATCA alone is estimated to cost 100 billion USD. And that's just one regulation of many.
- lhl 11y agoBitcoin will not eliminate most of the market inefficiencies you've listed - certainly not forex, by definition for example. There are already Bitcoin derivatives and other financial instruments being built already. However, the most comprehensive (and perhaps, relevant) analysis I've seen looks at the costs of printing/minting money and its distribution (banks, ATMs) is here: http://www.coindesk.com/author/hass-mccook/ http://www.coindesk.com/author/hass-mccook/ It's from mid-2014 now so the mining article is a bit out of date but there's no reason it couldn't be turned into a spreadsheet to account for current mining efficiency (and modeled against new developments increased block size or lightning network, for example).
- modeless 11y agoHow can the author write this entire article without mentioning the real numbers that matter? The mining reward is currently 3600 bitcoins per day in block rewards, plus about 20 bitcoins in transaction fees. That means if miners are rational they will collectively buy about 3620 bitcoins worth of electricity per day. 3620 bitcoins buy a lot of electricity for sure. But it won't always be like this! The block reward halves next year, and transaction volumes will probably increase. Then rational miners will spend perhaps around 1830 bitcoins on electricity per day, while processing more transactions. Wow, we've more than doubled the efficiency in a year! Furthermore, the block reward keeps halving every couple of years until it goes all the way to 0! At that point, the only thing funding the miners will be transaction fees, so the full costs of running the network will be borne by the users, and market forces will decide the appropriate level of resources to spend on running the Bitcoin network. It could be higher or lower than 215 MW, depending on how useful Bitcoin becomes to users.
- slg 11y agoI mean this in the strict economic sense and not the "Bitcoin is irrational" sense, but is there any proof that Bitcoin miners are rational actors as either individuals or as a community as a whole?
- darawk 11y agoIf people are losing money mining, they'll either stop mining or run out of money to pay their electricity bills. Either way, problem solves itself.
- slg 11y agoYour first point is a tautology because it relies on the assumption that miners are rational. I can certainly see scenarios where they continue to mine without it being immediately profitable. For example, people are bad at dealing with sunk costs. Imagine a miner paying money for a mining rig and then continuing to mine even when it is unprofitable to "pay off the rig". Or perhaps they have the somewhat more rational belief that Bitcoin will increase in value in the future so they are comfortable taking an immediate loss on the electricity. Your second point relies on the assumption that Bitcoin is a closed system. Without people injecting value into the system, Bitcoins would be worth $0. So you are basically predicting that people will suddenly stop bringing money they earned elsewhere to support mining Bitcoin. This point also relies of the opposite of the old Keynes "the market can stay irrational longer than you can stay solvent" quote. If we are waiting for people to go broke to keep the market rational, how long will that take and will the market be able to endure however long it is?