4 ms·
All capable states spy on each other. Enemy states spy on govt secrets and friendly states focus on industrial espionage. France, Israel and China are some of
by mc32 11y ago
All capable states spy on each other. Enemy states spy on govt secrets and friendly states focus on industrial espionage. France, Israel and China are some of the most vigorous at industrial espionage. Like it or not that's how the world operates and, unfortunately, we can't simply wish that away.
- sounds 11y agoI don't think he wished anything away, I think his point is that it reduces the value for all of us. Maybe take it as an appeal to logic: if nations are to grapple with the issues raised by the NSA and her sister orgs in the five eye countries, the best approach to raising the issue and proposing solutions (in my opinion) is to appeal to the logic of each individual and demonstrate how they are best served by dismantling these espionage operations.
- mc32 11y agoI think it's wishful thinking. I knew of a guy who wanted to open a coffee shop. He got to know another existing coffee shop owner and picked his brain for the dos and don'ts. He said, I'll be opening a shop (in a diff city) and I see yours is doing well... So what does he do? Opened a shop one block down and drove the fist guy out of business. Business is ruthless.
- J0-onas 11y agoTo argue that something clearly wrong is ok because everyone else is doing it is just plain stupid. In that fashion, ISIS could argue that their torture is ok and necessary because the USA is also doing it to obtain information.
- mc32 11y agoThey probably do make that argument.
- knodi123 11y agoI can't speak for ISIS, but al queda absolutely (and frequently) uses that argument when they blow up a mosque full of innocents.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- tamersalama 11y agowrong + wrong != right
- gress 11y agoNobody is arguing that it's ok. Only that it is necessary. Edit: I'm referring to spying, not torture.
- Retra 11y agoIt's not necessary, it's just an easy way to get a short-term advantage. It fundamentally degrades our ability to interact peacefully on an international scale, and it is one of the reasons our politicians form a privileged class. The only justification for it is "they did it first," which is both childish and irresponsible. Just because everyone else does it, doesn't mean it is correct, necessary, or justified.
- mc32 11y agoNo. The second use is to "keep them honest". It's not to gain a one time advantage or short term advantage, but it serves as a way to ensure your competition isn't doing monkey business. It's both an out of band communications channel but also provides a feedback loop. If your enemy or your competitor is engaging in something you all agreed to is out of bounds, you can respond to it with the information you have gained. EDS and Boeing will know if the other is underselling, bribing, receiving subsidies, etc. and be able to respond accordingly, for example.
- Retra 11y agoYou can also find all that out by doing investigations.
- mc32 11y agoCan you tell me what legal framework will allow you to undertake these investigations --to delve into and discover economic secrets? We have enough trouble extraditing criminals, nevermind politicians from sovereign nations. What court makes decisions and who in the court is making those decisions, to whom are they beholden? See how so many countries are rushing to resolve territorial disputes at the International Court of justice? Only the plaintiffs.
- forloop 11y agoFor a start, encryption could be used more widely. Which is the polar opposite of what some governments want[0]. It's almost as if governments are playing the terrorist card to push through laws which benefit them—the political class. Oh, but that's OK: everyone does it! --- [0] http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2015/jan/13/cameron-ban-encryption-digital-britain-online-shopping-banking-messaging-terror http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2015/jan/13/cameron...
- Zigurd 11y agoYou get what you pay for. Up to now we have paid tens of billions to get surveillance, and tens of millions to preserve confidentiality. It could be the other way around.
- digler999 11y ago> unfortunately, we can't simply wish that away. I know. If we ever hoped to get to that point, I think we'd need some esoteric unicorn shit like "checks and balances" built into our government.
- wpietri 11y agoIf only we had some government agency that helped large companies be less vulnerable to industrial espionage, making sure that secrets stayed secret. Encouraging strong encryption, discovering and preventing software bugs, generally promoting computer security. Hmmm... A nation-wide security-focused agency. Maybe we could call it the National Security Agency?
- higherpurpose 11y agoIt should probably be renamed to National Spy Agency at this point, because it does that much more than "security".
- TeMPOraL 11y agoI wonder if this even makes sense. Today multinational corporations are becoming sovereign trans-national governments. Why would the NSA want to help protect Corporation X or its US branch, if said corporation may be a potential threat to national security?
- rjaco31 11y agoI have yet to see any single example of 'sovereign trans-national' corporations, AFAIK big companies are definitely from their mother-country, no matter how many subsidiaries or branches they have.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoThere've been cases of big companies suing whole countries (Philip Morris vs Australia comes to mind). While they may be not technically sovereign entities yet, it seems to me that some megacorps have enough power to successfully compete with governments.
- rjaco31 11y agoSure, but they still remain US companies, and it's basically the main fact that allow them to do so (the US government negotiated treaties with countries so that US companies can sue their government).
- higherpurpose 11y agoSlavery is just the way societies work today. We can't just wish it away. - Most people a few hundred years ago, probably.
- mc32 11y agoThat's correct. It wasn't wished away. Slavery and other forms of cheap labor were part of the human condition for millennia. It took revolts, revolutions and changes in mores for things to advance to where they are today. Yes, some day, we may all enter a new world order where everything is placid. We're not there yet and thinking we can wish ourselves there in the near future, let's say, extremely optimistic, to the point if being wishful thinking. Perhaps most importantly is that servitude and slavery became economically untenable.