6 ms·
No, “the revolving door” refers to people spending time working as legislators/executive officials, and then going to work in the same industry they were regula
by jacobolus 11y ago
No, “the revolving door” refers to people spending time working as legislators/executive officials, and then going to work in the same industry they were regulating, and basically getting time-shifted favors/salary in return for their help while in office.
Spending 6 months or whatever working as a programmer for the US Digital Service and then going back to a job in industry is something quite different.
- rayiner 11y agoWon't argue that doesn't happen, but it's overstated. People from industry go into government for the same reason people join the digital service: because they think that the skills and knowledge they gained in industry can let them do the job better than the government can without them.[1] And these appointments are temporary for the same reason digital service appointments are temporary: people are only so willing to sign on for salary-capped government positions for so long. The only difference is the intent and motivation you're ascribing to the respective actors. [1] I think very few people would disagree with the assertion that a Googler knows tech better than anyone in government. The fact is that pretty much everyone in every industry feels the same way. Everyone thinks that the public interest would be served if only the government folks in charge were people who "get it" like they do.
- walshemj 11y agoThat's a big ask Googles software requires a different mind set than say correctly calculating veterans pensions. From googles perspective having 2 or 3% suboptimal query's is fine but that wont pass muster for other types of work. Try building billing systems for a global Telco and have one of Vint Cerfs reports nudge you and say this had be right otherwise we are both out of a job :-)
- linkregister 11y agoI'm pretty sure that a billing error in Adwords would cause a fairly large controversy!
- walshemj 11y agoTrue and I bet that they pay more attention to detail on that but what proportion of googles SE's work on ad words billing.
- Kephael 11y agoCalculating a pension and building a billing system is rather basic CRUD work compared to scaling software to handle millions of concurrent users. Google's hiring bar is relatively high compared to any government position in terms of quantitative skills you'd need to demonstrate.
- noir_lord 11y agoLast year there where 279 changes to the federal tax code. That system handles hundreds of millions of people and trillions of dollars. Calling it "rather basic CRUD work" is incredibly myopic and/or arrogant.
- walshemj 11y agoQuite Google can take a relaxed view about things eg getting geoloaction wrong 1 time in thousand on a query. Calculate 1 in a 1000 tax returns or bank statements wrong and some one will want blood.
- jrochkind1 11y agoI don't understand what you mean by "2 or 3% suboptimal query's", or really, in general what you mean.
- walshemj 11y agoThey don't have to be 100% right but say an accounts system must reconcile.
- jrochkind1 11y agoA google query? What does it even mean for a google query to be "100% right"? I'm not sure that's even a thing. But I think you misunderstand software engineering and the nature of engineering skill or fields of experience. There may be no such thing as "100% right" when it comes to which hits are included in the result set for a google query, but I have no doubt that nearly any google engineer needs to write all sorts of code on a regular basis that indeed needs to be 100% right with regard to specifications or requirements.
- walshemj 11y agoAh so hobby programmers then and given some of the quality of the published google apis's I am not surprised. Sorry after having been one of my country's 3rd line osi team I take a fairly hard line on correctness.
- jrochkind1 11y agowhat the heck are you on about, man.
- walshemj 11y agoGoogles code quality isn't all its cracked up to be and you have a least heard of OSI? You know the other networking standard that was at least a decade ahead of the internet back then.
- sliverstorm 11y agoThe "revolving door" is all about the fox guarding the chicken coop. How do software engineers working for the USDS fall into that basket?