16 ms·
I don't think he did much wrong here. It doesn't appear that he actually broke in to your computers, he just submitted lots of bets. If you're going to run a c
by jstanley 11y ago
I don't think he did much wrong here. It doesn't appear that he actually broke in to your computers, he just submitted lots of bets.
If you're going to run a casino (whose entire business model is based on exploiting weaknesses of others for profit), don't be surprised if people try to exploit your weaknesses for profit.
I'm not saying there's anything wrong with running a casino, I think it is fine. I just think that what he did is fine too.
EDIT: Except the part where you apparently didn't pay out all of his winnings. I'm not fine with that part. Also doxing one of your customers just because he made a profit out of you.
- danneu 11y agoJust because you actually do have a moral problem with casinos doesn't mean a malicious user is a "customer".
- Lawtonfogle 11y agoJust because you have a moral problem with the customer doesn't mean they are a malicious user. Even if a user's actions are outright illegal, illegal is neither sufficient nor necessary for saying something is wrong in the moral views of anyone who uses a moral system divorced from the legal system. In short, deeply held moral views can differ so greatly that a common language to describe the situation can be impossible unless one sticks purely to the facts which include accepting the legal system does exist and make judgment calls but putting no authority in those calls.
- swashboon 11y agoThe indicated that they emailed the exploiter and basically told them to stop playing. They have the right to refuse service, it was circumvented by making new accounts. I don't see any reason they would need to pay after refusing services.
- genericuser 11y agoBasically would be the key word in your description of their actions. As they do not mention actually telling the user to stop playing. They only mention "demanding" their bitcoins back. Demanding something you are at that point probably not entitled to from a user of your service, and informing them that you have decided to refuse future service to them may appear basically the same, but they are in fact not. "We reached out to Hufflepuff via his bitcointalk forum account and demanded the return of the coins, however this backfired unbelievably hard. "
- random28345 11y ago> If you're going to run a casino (whose entire business model is based on exploiting weaknesses of others for profit), There are plenty of casios, and many of them comply with the law. People who choose to gamble there might be exploited by some definition, but it is consentual. But Primedice is a casino that uses bitcoin to allow users to circumvent local gambling laws, and thus exploits weakness in criminal laws. (I will not discuss the morality of current anti-gambling laws in the US, as any rational person can see the hypocrisy in the current system of state-sponsored lotteries and state-granted casino monopolies) > don't be surprised if people try to exploit your weaknesses for profit. Primedice reusing a nonce/seed is like a casino dealing blackjack from a marked deck. It is so incredibly stupid that you are guaranteed to have someone notice, and clean you out while still playing by yor rules. Note that they are offering a reward for the "return of the [bit]coins". I assume that means they are offering that if someone hacks a bitcoin wallet and gives them the proceeds, they will share a fraction of the stolen assets. I would happily make the same offer; paying random people who give me bitcoins from hacked wallets some of the stolen bitcoin, except that I'm not an exploitive, criminal-minded narcissist rationalizing theft to support the operation of a gambling site based on a cyber-currency designed to facilitate extra-legal activity.
- jsprogrammer 11y ago>There are plenty of casios, and many of them comply with the law. There are plenty of Nazis, and many of them comply with the law.
- genericuser 11y agoAnd most countries with a sense of free-speech try to(pretend to, would ideally, take your pick depending on your view of how successful free-speech is) respect the law biding citizen's freedom to hold whatever views they want even if they are ridiculous. I feel like unless you are trying to troll, it is best to avoid all analogies that compare current events to what would be deemed by many as 'historical evil doers'.
- jsprogrammer 11y ago
- fweespeech 11y ago> EDIT: Except the part where you apparently didn't pay out all of his winnings. I'm not fine with that part. Also doxing one of your customers just because he made a profit out of you. They asked him to stop playing at that point and he created a new account to evade that. I'm not sure why you feel people don't have the right to refuse service.
- s73v3r 11y agoIt's not that person's fault that these guys suck at enforcing their own policies
- fweespeech 11y agoIf you are explicitly contacted and refused service, its actually illegal to do what the user did.
- genericuser 11y agoThey don't actually say they asked him to stop playing, they say they demanded their coins back.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- lcswi 11y agoHow do they know that it was the same person?
- icelancer 11y agoDefinitely agree with this, minus the 2nd duplicate account. That is not OK and they absolutely have the right to refuse payment on the 2nd attempt. Going after the person on a bitcoin forum and attempting to demand repayment is a joke, however. How did Primedice think that was going to work out for them?