2 ms·
If the Federal Circuit decision stands, software might have finally encountered the lump it can't digest as it eats the world. † In the United States. The app
by Silhouette 11y ago
If the Federal Circuit decision stands, software might have finally encountered the lump it can't digest as it eats the world.
† In the United States.
The apparent legal position following this result seems crazy to me. Even in the world of intellectual property law, there has been some recognition that the interests of interoperability and ability to communicate may outweigh the benefits of monopoly protection as an incentive to create and share. The US, for example, takes this view in declining copyright protection on the design of typefaces (as distinct from font files that contain software describing those designs in one specific way). And in Europe, good luck getting a software patent that blocks anyone from using your file format or communications protocol.
Given that programming to an interface is essentially the way we enable interoperability between different software products, allowing the protection of such interfaces to stand seems absurdly counter-productive. This is particularly true if the protection holds retrospectively for APIs that were previously believed not to be protected in that way by those who chose to write code against them, which would presumably be the case here.
If the US allows this position to remain, it could cripple the US software development industry very quickly if the lawyers start throwing their weight around. In practice, as often happens under the US legal system, I expect it would be particularly damaging to the little guy, while the big players would all cross-license their respective portfolios somehow to make the issue go away.