3 ms·
I think you are conflating the two because of the case of Soviet Union. A) Soviet Union was not communism. Communism never happened. Communism/communist societ
by lqdc13 11y ago
I think you are conflating the two because of the case of Soviet Union.
A) Soviet Union was not communism. Communism never happened. Communism/communist society is an ideal.
B) Soviet Union was a totalitarian state, yes.
C) One of the main concepts in communism is that there is/should be no state. Totalitarianism assumes that there is a state. This is in every definition of communism and totalitarianism. Here I'm going to quote it from the first line of each from Wikipedia:
"Totalitarianism is concept of a political system in which the state holds total control over the society"
"Communism ... absence of social classes, money, and the state."
- fche 11y ago"Communism ... absence of [...] state." So yeah, "hasn't been done right yet". Could you hypothesize who in a true-scotsman communist non-state would regulate people's output ("ability") & input ("need")? Who would enforce the laws? If "everyone and anyone" is an enforcer, then claiming there is "no state" is sophistry.