7 ms·
Two Uber managers detained in France over 'illicit' low-cost service
- seren 11y agoJust to be clear, because it is not mentioned in the article, this is about UberPop. Uber is legal with some caveats.
- t_fatus 11y agoThat's nice: they will have time to (finally) explain to our government what's the difference between Uber and Uber-X services versus Uber-Pop when offered by unlicenced (for private hires) drivers. And we can hope that at least here they are safer than in the streets of Paris
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ddalex_ro 11y agoI like Uber's service, but it's obvious that they are a taxi. A better taxi company, but a taxi; and they should get their licenses in order.
- dylanjermiah 11y agoThe licenses are what made the taxi system so inefficient.
- therobot24 11y agoyou are correct, but blatantly ignoring the law is usually not the best way to fix that
- dylanjermiah 11y agoWhat would be a superior method?
- therobot24 11y agoI'm not a public policy expert by any means, nor do i claim to be one, however there's a pretty charted history of how laws can be changed. Examples include protests, lobbying, and ballot measures just to name a few. Don't fool yourself into thinking that Uber is on the moral high ground like some civil rights movement. The are a taxi company that is not following well-established procedure. If they want to continue to operate they should either adapt, or lobby for changing that procedure.
- Uberphallus 11y agoIt is, as paying fines is cheaper than paying for a license. When you get to that point, it's obvious that the regulation is backwards, and it's nobody but taxi drivers that made it this way: they got licenses for free, then fought for their right to transfer them for money, then they fought to limit new licensing. Basically they lobbied for free money and screwing customers.
- therobot24 11y ago> it's obvious that the regulation is backwards Not disagreeing here. However, fines are put in place as a deterrent. In this instance, their purpose is a punishment for breaking a law. Uber is treating them like a tax and the government appears to disagree with that interpretation. If this were a case of a chemical company continuing to improperly dispose of waste, i'm sure at some point you'd want the government to step in over continued violations (i.e., stop them when they are clearly not acting in 'good faith').
- dylanjermiah 11y agoImproperly disposing waste is not equivalent to providing a better service cheaper and quicker.
- therobot24 11y agoYou're right, but in both cases each company is doing the same thing, repeatedly breaking a law with no intention of stopping. Wouldn't you agree that the government has a duty to treat both cases equally?
- murbard2 11y agoTell that to Martin Luther King, Rosa Parks, Ghandi...
- sp332 11y agoThose people tried an awful lot of things before breaking the law. Uber doesn't seem to have tried very hard and just went for it.
- murbard2 11y agoPeople have tried to challenge cab monopolies for decades without any success.
- therobot24 11y agothat's why i used the term "usually" Do you honestly think Uber can be compared to the civil rights movement?
- ginko 11y agoYes, because providing unlicensed taxi service is the same thing as civil rights.
- murbard2 11y agoFirst of all, the OP was making a general point about the best way to go about challenging existing laws. Since the point is general, a counter example suffice, even if it differs from the specifics of the situation being discussed. If those specifics make a difference in the OP's point, the onus of outlining why they make a difference is on the OP. This is how logical reasoning works, but every. single. time. someone points out a counter example to a general statement, there is someone like who who comes and moves the goalpost by saying "oh yeah, because X is like Y", and we're all worse off because of this lack of debating etiquette. Second, you would be wrong to trivialize the importance of expanding the offering in cabs. Uber will go into neighborhood where Taxis don't, they can also be substantially cheaper depending on the city and the specifics. Having access to a ride late at night can mean the difference between being raped or not raped for many people living in high crime neighborhood. In addition, Uber provides a livelihood for a large number of drivers. The taxis that it compete are generally renting their license from a large company who is collecting the monopoly rent.
- crandycodes 11y agoSometimes it's exactly the best way to fix it. Have something so good and popular the law has to change. Prohibition didn't end because people missed the taste of alcohol; it was because people kept on drinking (and the illicit nature brought with it the trappings of criminality - corruption, violence, and murder). Gay marriage bans were hard to "ignore" because it requires cooperation with the government, but anti-sodomy laws were generally ignored until it became comical they were still on the books. And in general, these kinds of things are the way change happens. The first people at my work switched to git on their own discretion and against the "rules", but it caught on and was productive/popular enough that it's now common practice and no managers ruffle their feathers at the thought. The phrase is something like - "It's better to ask for forgiveness than for permission". That's because it's easy to say no when asked for permission ("The rules are there for a reason! Tradition!"); if someone has to think about why what you did was wrong, they may come to the conclusion that you were right.
- therobot24 11y agoI completely agree with your sentiment. Though the only comparison I think fits the most with Uber is prohibition (since alcohol can be considered as a luxury, while marriage is a legal right). Don't forget though, with prohibition there was a complex underground bootlegging market funding organized crime. Also there's the whole Great Depression thing which put the whole country in need of additional revenue streams...
- crandycodes 11y agoOh yeah. None of this is simple black and white. My main assertion is that systems are generally trying to maintain homeostasis. In order to change the system, it's sometimes necessary is disrupt/ignore the system; especially when other means of influencing the system are denied or ineffective.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ska 11y agoIt's not as cut and dried as getting rid of licenses. A couple of examples: - some things that come with licenses are plausibly desirable (commercial insurance, say) and have no other mechanism. Yes this argues for a different solution. - adding vehicles to road networks at or near capacity (e.g. dense metro areas) can lead to systemic inefficiencies that are plausibly much worse that the positives from a putative increase in taxi efficiency. - etc. This at least deserves a broader policy discussion, and it may well turn out that in some areas there is a public policy advantage to constraining this market.
- dylanjermiah 11y agoSure licences could be helpful, but, expectations needs to be separated from reality. Where there is power it will be abused.
- dalore 11y agoIt's not about adding vehicles. More ubers actually mean less vehicles since people who would otherwise drive and park all day would take an uber. You would argue that more and more ubers would come. But uber drivers would see they wouldn't be making enough money so they wouldn't do that.
- ska 11y ago"More ubers actually mean less vehicles since people who would otherwise drive and park all day would take an uber" That's a pretty strong claim - where I've see uber operate the vast majority of fares seem to be people who were taking taxis anyway, they just prefer uber. Do you have evidence that uber is actually eating into private car usage in any significant way in a dense metro area?
- nolok 11y agoMaybe, maybe not, but the situation as-is is that you need a license to operate in that business, if you disagree with that fight to get it changed, but you can't purposefully decide not to follow the law including the fines as operating expenses when others keep abiding to the same laws, and then pretend the justice system is wrong when they apply the laws.
- viola11 11y agoDefending law violations only by arguing that they make "the economy" more efficient is not very convincing. Especially in this case since the real innovations that Uber brings in terms of ride allocation are not incompatible with paying taxes and insurance. Rather, the technical innovations of Uber appear to in themselves not be enough to actually compete with existing taxis, hence why the second innovation of actually breaking the law under the guise of technology is so important. Uber has clearly pivoted into a taxi service, and as such it must compete on price, but somehow the fact they have an app for hailing cabs means they can be a taxi company that doesn't employ their drivers? How does that argument really work?
- dylanjermiah 11y agoTransportation being cheaper and more efficient means people save time and save money. Uber has also allowed hundreds of thousands of people with an income source. _That_ is a convincing argument to me. "Actually compete with existing taxis" They are competing, Uber is doing 3-5x more rides in SF than the taxis as a whole were doing before Uber. That's without including Lyft. So they're expanding the market, meaning more people can afford to pay for transportation.
- viola11 11y agoIndeed they are competing with existing taxi services, but not as a taxi company, but rather as a "ride share", despite providing a taxis service, and branding themselves as such. Given that they had the choice between acting and probably-illegally, I can find no reason to act questionably except profit expectations. This in turn means that Uber can reasonable be expected to have come to the conclusion that their technological innovations alone do not provide sustainable growth in the taxi market.
- dylanjermiah 11y agoMy last post already addressed this but...The taxi system is not a free market, the supply was artificially restrained and prices monopolised. Hence for the Uber system to work as it does now it would be impossible to be a 'taxi company' because the laws, in effect, have outlawed a cheap and efficient means of transportation. The SF market is proof that they are not only obliterating the former taxi market, their service is so superior that it's expanding the market 5 times.
- david_p 11y agoSo as to make things clear, UberPop has been outlawed in France months ago but keeps operating. The fines are considered "operating costs" by UberPop, who takes care of paying the fines when UberPop drivers are getting caught. You can remove the quotes at illicit.
- sp332 11y agoThere are quotes on "illicit" because it is a quote.
- aikah 11y agoTo be accurate, the website and app itself (UberPop) aren't outlawed YET. BUT it is illegal for UberPop drivers to continue taking clients and driving for UBER. So technically UberPop isn't illegal, UberPop drivers ARE on the other hand performing an illegal activity. HOWEVER in France, it is illegal to promote an illegal activity. Yesterday I heard an ad on GenerationFM promoting Uber and recruiting drivers. So on this ground, managers at Uber France can be sued. I think it's foolish to work for Uber France. Uber might pay you a lawyer or any fines if you get sued, but If you're sentenced and sent to prison? is it worth it to go to prison for Uber? or to have a record? because you're career will basically be over. And good luck moving to US with a record even if it is what Uber promised you if it would happen.
- makeitsuckless 11y ago> The standoff reflects larger tensions in France over how to regulate fast-moving technology and stay globally competitive while ensuring labour protections. This kind of biased journalism just pisses me off. Uber has nothing to do with "fast-moving technology". They could have done this service with on old fashioned phone dispatch in the 50s and it would still be the same illegal operation. Sure, they've added some bells and whistle, but that merely serves to disguise what it really is: offering a cheaper service by breaking multiple laws. Uber is about breaking the law, not about technology, and I'm glad they finally get treated as the criminals they are.
- andrewtbham 11y agoUber uses machine learning to route drivers, not dispatchers.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- dylanjermiah 11y agoI think the 2 million-ish rides per day is evidence that the laws are backwards and needed to be broken. They were anti-consumer and only served to protect the taxi cartel.
- kristofferR 11y agoYeah. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pvri8hpMViM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pvri8hpMViM
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- hyperion2010 11y agoThey pay the fines and the fines are cheaper than complying with laws designed to protect monopolistic interests. You can call it illegal, but when the economics works out such that the fines for something illegal are less than the competing regulated service something needs to change.
- jkoudys 11y agoEvery time this topic comes up, the discussion always revolves around whether or not Uber is properly licensed, or if it's fair for them to operate. What's often overlooked is the very reason so many of these licenses became as valuable as they did in the first place, and like so many economic issues it boils down to one thing: trust. For example, anyone who's seen more of NYC than just JFK airport and Times Square knows that that city has plenty of unlicensed rides available. This was true long before uber: white cars whose driver will only say "do you need a taxi?", and dollar-vans are everywhere. Yet, even though they offer an identical service to a licensed cab, people value them far less and fares are often 1/4 what's paid for a yellow taxi. When it's an officially licensed taxi, you trust that their fares are regulated, your driver isn't a violent criminal, and that their vehicle's in safe working order. This is the real value uber brings: geolocation and well-designed apps are nice frills, but ultimately people are deciding more and more that they trust a business with a rating system for drivers + passengers, upfront rates (even if they vary), and GPS so in the unlikely event you are detained, you can be found. Seriously, unless you're a lawyer, I have no idea why you'd go around debating what's legal or illegal. Instead, as citizens, we should look at the regulations we have and ask if they still serve to protect people as they once did, or if they now exist to protect political and business interests.
- Shivetya 11y agoWhen government conspires with business to create a shortage it needs to be shaken up. The cost to entry for taxi services should not be the absurd numbers quoted in many cities, a number which only exists to benefit the existing companies and the politicians they support. What likely annoys these people the most is that their little game is being called out. Regulation has its place, that is not stifling competition and restricting people from having jobs
- mcuk2k 11y agoThe good thing about governments conspiring to create a shortage is that taxi drivers make a reasonable income. This is an aspect that Silcon-Valley-style technology platforms have no apparent interest in supporting. For example, as time progresses Adsense might sign up more and more publisher capacity, yet that pushes down the income and discourages respectable publishers from using the service. You go from a fairly well respected public service, to something that's got a nice brand and run by virtual slaves.
- steve19 11y agoI am astounded that the French government is doing exactly what the violent Taxi protesters (rioters?) wanted. This sends a clear message to any other groups: burn enough cars and blockade an airport and you will get what you want. I thought the Taxi drivers would be condemned by politicians and the French public.
- dylanjermiah 11y agoThey're rewarding violence, destruction and kid napping. Terrible.
- renaudg 11y agoI'm French and astounded too. You are exactly right. Petitions in support of Uber are being run very successfully at the moment, and most people around me (working in tech) have vowed to never ever take a taxi again after what happened, but I'm not sure the general public cares that much :(
- Kurtz79 11y agoTaxi drivers ae a large, compact and numerous community. Politicians will be queueing to show their support, hopefully to be remembered come election time.
- golergka 11y ago> burn enough cars and blockade an airport and you will get what you want I was under impression that that's how French government, as a lot of other European governments work anyway.
- Tomte 11y agoMaybe Uber staged those protests, so that nobody would think about stepping in against them. ;-)
- hussong 11y agoGenerally speaking: how many violent protests do you need before you consider changing the law? Nasty as that may seem, but without violent protests, France would possibly still be a kingdom (and the US a colony).
- crdb 11y agoThe context is important. France happens to have a very influential taxi monopoly headquartered in Paris. The broad lines have been sketched by a recent Nouvel Obs article [1]. Amongst other things, the former head of the French FBI is now chairman of one of the group's taxi companies, right after he delivered an internal government report skewering taxi competitors (and that was probably just the tip of the iceberg). No new licenses were given in Paris between 1990 and 2002 despite a 49% increase in airport passenger traffic and 17% increase in population. The system itself is designed to maximise revenue; for example, taxis will not be allocated on the basis of proximity to the customer, but on the basis of which has waited longest, time that (according to the Nouvel Obs anyway - I haven't taken a taxi in Paris in ages) is charged to the customer immediately. Drivers pay a fortune to the company and often work 7-day weeks to make ends meet as a result. This, by the way, is why drivers on call in Paris will often refuse to drive you if your destination is too close. Uber's strategy was simple, to gain so much popularity as to make it extremely expensive for the lobbying effort to continue. Rule of law? Personally, I do not think that people buying themselves favorable laws should be legal and defendable. For both executives to be on police watch when they are clearly not a flight risk is a sign that the monopoly is well connected and has obtained favour with the government. [1] edit: link is now offline, Web Archive: https://web.archive.org/web/20150317180809/http://tempsreel.nouvelobs.com/economie/20150212.OBS2398/comment-le-roi-des-taxis-compte-contrer-uber-au-detriment-des-clients.html https://web.archive.org/web/20150317180809/http://tempsreel....
- at-fates-hands 11y agoAre there no unions in France? I thought this was a big part of the argument as well.
- jwildeboer 11y agoInteresting. I read French articles that claim two drivers were arrested, not managers. http://www.europe1.fr/faits-divers/uberpop-deux-chauffeurs-en-garde-a-vue-a-paris-1361708 http://www.europe1.fr/faits-divers/uberpop-deux-chauffeurs-e...
- ForHackernews 11y agoGood. You don't get to just pay a fine and ignore the law because you've got the money. Would that the US followed this example and started sentencing flagrant lawbreakers to jail time.
- karambahh 11y agoThey are also detained for unlawful data retention (the 1981 "Information & Libertés" law, which is seen by many as very strict regarding personal data). It seems likely they will get them either directly or indirectly (ala "AlCapone" who got caught on tax related offences, not alcohol smuggling).