3 ms·
The thing it all hinges on is containing noise. Nobody complains about studying in a library. Because it's quiet. If you want an open workspace to work, you hav
by Zigurd 11y ago
The thing it all hinges on is containing noise. Nobody complains about studying in a library. Because it's quiet. If you want an open workspace to work, you have to make it quiet. Provide "phone booths" for phone calls and conference rooms or team rooms for groups talking.
- gambiting 11y ago>>Nobody complains about studying in a library. Because it's quiet. I actually always did. When I was at uni I would avoid the library like a plague. The problem with an ultra-quiet environment is that literally EVERYTHING is annoying. Someone coughing. Moving papers. Quiet laughter. Clicking pens. It was seriously million times more distracting than working in open space office is.
- anthony_d 11y agoThe problem is that people are different. I love working in the library; I can't get anything done in an open space office. A personal office is ok but not my first choice. Cubes are completely dependent on my neighbors. Businesses are really bad at accommodating differences.
- marssaxman 11y agoYeah, I can't work very well in a dead quiet environment, because every little thing distracts me - even the sound of my own breathing, sometimes. Distraction is always a problem. Blotting everything out by listening to music helps a lot, particularly music free of vocals.
- RogerL 11y agoStudies indicate it is more than that. Control of your environment, visual distractions, even airborne illnesses all are a factor as well. I do agree the quiet is required; I'm not countering your point, just adding to it.
- mitchty 11y agoMy biggest annoyance is having people behind me. I can't get rid of that prey feeling of being watched. Super annoying and distracting feeling. That and motion in the periphery of the rods always serves to get noticed. Headphones also eventually mat down your hair and no matter how comfortable hurt your head after more than a few hours. If these are the "walls" of modern offices, we might as well go back to having a guy atop a chair reading to all us factory workers.
- RogerL 11y agoYa, I mostly gave up on the headphones. I know correlation is not causation, but I've started to get ringing in my ears (the more likely causation is age). I don't do high volume, but these are my ears, no company gets to eff with them. If companies want low productivity and high dissatisfaction, why, they will get it. It's absurd, but its where we are.
- mtviewdave 11y agoI don't think ringing in the ears is a normal part of growing older. I would urge you to get that checked out by your doctor.
- artmageddon 11y agoYou're right that no company should eff with your ears indeed, but You may want to see an ENT doctor for your hearing. That's a little concerning and will only get worse(and not just because of age).
- zimpenfish 11y agoUntil last week, I was sat next to someone who drummed his fingers on the desk, drummed his feet on the floor, and swung on his chair like it was a playground ride. My productivity has shot up since I've moved away from him.
- Zigurd 11y agoSure, you can have other distractions, too. Even libraries can be distracting if people forget to turn off their phone ringers, it's too crowded, etc. The office environments that I have seen that are successful have team rooms, sometimes on a separate floor, do the traffic in and out of them is also separated, and a "hot desk" area where only quiet individual work is permitted.
- MatthewMcDonald 11y ago> The thing it all hinges on is containing noise. I think it hinges on is containing distractions, and noise is just one of them. When people see you just a few feet away from them, they rarely consider "is my question worth interrupting them so I can get an answer immediately" before asking it. Just having a wall or a door blocking their view of you forces them to make a decision to walk to your desk before asking a question. This seems like a minor barrier, but it's often enough to prevent a lot of interruptions for questions that don't need immediate responses.
- vonmoltke 11y agoIn addition to what others have said about distraction being more than just noise, this idea runs directly counter to the "official" reason for open plans: free flow of information and spontaneous communications. By necessity those make an open plan noisy. In fact, it creates a horrible contradiction: you are supposed to be able to simultaneously block out all this shit, but still pay attention for those moments of serendipity wherein you can interject something useful. The vast majority of knowledge workers can't work like that.
- artmageddon 11y ago> Provide "phone booths" for phone calls and conference rooms or team rooms for groups talking. My last job had these in the open office environment, it helped, but it wasn't nearly enough. See others' comments about shoulder-tapping distractions and visual pollution.