4 ms·
He wasn't as bad as James Callaghan, John Major, or - IMO - Margaret Thatcher. And Blair was - and is - a war criminal. The politicking between the two was juv
by TheOtherHobbes 11y ago
He wasn't as bad as James Callaghan, John Major, or - IMO - Margaret Thatcher. And Blair was - and is - a war criminal.
The politicking between the two was juvenile, but I'd rather blame Brown for his insistence on semi-privatised (and ruinously expensive) funding for public projects through the misuse of PFI.
That aside, Sen may actually be right in that Brown kept it together after 2008.
The Tory press love to blame him for 2008 in its entirety, including the parts he had no control over. But that's because the Tory press is full of vile liars, criminals, and frauds. (Some of whom have spent time in jail now.)
A more sober assessment is less unkind to Brown as an economist - if perhaps not as a politician.
- gadders 11y agoHe could have made a very good academic. He's obviously a bright bloke. He appeared to be temperamentally unsuitable to leadership though. To your other points: - Calling Blair a war criminal is just childish name calling. - Thatcher is one of the best post-war Prime Ministers, together with Clement Atlee, depending on your politics. - The left-wing press has its own share of liars and frauds. The Daily Mirror was at least as complicit as the Murdoch press in phone hacking. And Johan Hari, Guardian Journalist, is probably the biggest liar in journalism of moderd times.
- TheOtherHobbes 11y agoIt's not very realistic to write off Blair's record as "childish name calling." We're still waiting for the Chilcot report, but the US side has more or less admitted that the pretexts for the Iraq war were made up nonsense. At least half a million people died in that war, and the results for the region were catastrophic - although very profitable for certain contractors. I'm not quite sure what else you need to describe someone as a war criminal. But it's not just my opinion: it's a sentiment that's been voiced in the House of Lords. As for Thatcher - charisma hardly maps to competence, and many of Thatcher's protectees and associates were - let's say - questionable company for a moral leader, with some extremely unsavoury hobbies that are being investigated by the police. This hardly speaks well of her judgement or character. The Daily Mirror has very limited political influence, and last time I looked there was no one from the Mirror in the Cabinet running Communications for No 10 - until they were tried and jailed. It would be interesting to find out exactly how and where phone hacking started. I suspect it wasn't invented by the Mirror. Naturally I can't prove that. But I do know that as far back as 1994 journalists from another newspaper were handing out illegal addictive drugs in return for tip-offs. So phone hacking is just the tip of the iceberg. And Johann Hari actually wrote for the Indie, not the Guardian. Considering the Mail regularly "repurposes" content from the entire web without attribution, accusing him of being the worst journalist ever is slightly hyperbolic - although to be fair the Mail does usually try to rewrite the content at least a little, which makes it okay, I guess.
- gadders 11y ago>>It's not very realistic to write off Blair's record as "childish name calling." We're still waiting for the Chilcot report, but the US side has more or less admitted that the pretexts for the Iraq war were made up nonsense. I don't think that's the case. Even countries that were against military action, such as France, believed Saddam had WMDs. >>I'm not quite sure what else you need to describe someone as a war criminal. But it's not just my opinion: it's a sentiment that's been voiced in the House of Lords. The same as for any other criminal - a conviction by an actual court. >>As for Thatcher - charisma hardly maps to competence, and many of Thatcher's protectees and associates were - let's say - questionable company for a moral leader, with some extremely unsavoury hobbies that are being investigated by the police. This hardly speaks well of her judgement or character. I suspect we won't agree on her political competence but if you implying some of her ministers were paedophiles, I suggest you also look at Grevill Janner (Labour) and Cyril Smith (Liberal). >>Considering the Mail regularly "repurposes" content from the entire web without attribution, accusing him of being the worst journalist ever is slightly hyperbolic - although to be fair the Mail does usually try to rewrite the content at least a little, which makes it okay, I guess. I think repurposing or copying content from other websites is not as serious a journalistic sin as inventing large parts of stories. Hari didn't just plagiarised, he knowingly lied. He also cyber-stalked people on wikipedia as well. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/07/20/johann-hari-fabrication_n_904456.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/07/20/johann-hari-fabrica...