3 ms·
From the article: But he is emphatic that computers will never truly replace human doctors for the simple reason that the machines lack instinct and empathy. “
by teekert 11y ago
From the article:
But he is emphatic that computers will never truly replace human doctors for the simple reason that the machines lack instinct and empathy.
“There are a lot of things you can deduce by what a patient is not telling you, how they interact with their families, their mood, their mannerisms. They don’t look at the patient as a whole,” Husain said. “This is where algorithms fail you.”
I don't understand this sentiment, instinct and empathy are just feelings that results from small cues that a physician can't exactly put into words. It does not put them into the realm of magic. And why exactly would a computer not be able to look at the patient as a whole? Of course a computer can (at some point) do that. It can even deduce heart rate an breathing rate from a camera image of a face, something a human can't.
Why do people always assume that if something is difficult to put in words it is impossible for a computer somehow? It seems like an invalid argument to me.
- rohit89 11y ago> Why do people always assume that if something is difficult to put in words it is impossible for a computer somehow? It seems like an invalid argument to me. Because if we don't really know how we are doing something, how can you tell the computer how to do it? Simply measuring a bunch of values doesn't mean it will be interpreted correctly. For eg, see the lie-detector.
- agumonkey 11y agoThe less we understand the more we think about it the more we attach ourselves to it ? And beyond that the most amazing part is the bias we have in this regard. Doctors fail too, most of the time accidentally (fatigue, stress, collaboration issues, lack of information,...) but some time out of hubris. Got to see this myself: one doctor told a condition required removing an organ, another one told what was wanted to be heard, guess which doctor had the job and what was the result ?
- gmarx 11y agoThe hardest thing in medical diagnosis/treatment for a computer to do is not running algorithms to determine diagnosis/treatment; it's taking the patient history. If you ask a patient if he has had any abdominal pain, a lot of patients think about it and decide they have had abdominal pain. It may just have been some slight discomfort from gas a couple of weeks ago, but doc asked so it must be important; wouldn't want to leave anything out. Other patients are stoic and wouldn't really call that raging appendicitis "pain", more like "discomfort". An experienced doc should be able to read the patient and tell these apart. Watson? Maybe someday. As with most tasks in medical analytics, the rate limiting factor is the data.