13 ms·
This isn't being 'buried' it just isn't that interesting. All of the money the client gives to the agency gets spent, some goes to the agency, some goes to the
by ChuckMcM 11y ago
This isn't being 'buried' it just isn't that interesting. All of the money the client gives to the agency gets spent, some goes to the agency, some goes to the networks, some goes to the content providers. That isn't news at all.
Fraud is rampant. Also not new, although it is also also pretty easy to spot and block.
Almost nobody pays per 'impression' because, well that went out of style about the same time Yahoo! banner ads did.
Eventually the advertisers are going to pay for performance, and to do that they are going to have to fix the way they do advertising so that their ad, leads to their landing page which identifies who delivered the ad. Then they are going to pay based on whether or not the person who landed on their page actually buys something (service, good, or subscription). No money, no ad payment.
Most companies other than Amazon really aren't set up for that, and Amazon won't do it yet because, as far as I can tell, they aren't being forced too.
Its a shame that "affiliate" ads like the ones they let bloggers use have 100X there ROI of "CPC" ads and yet they have convinced the bloggers they can pay then a nickel and they should be happy when Google gets $13 - $23 for the same result.
I started building this system out of disgust but never finished it. It isn't that technically difficult, but it does have a lot of moving parts, and it does require infrastructure on the advertisers web site which can create durable transaction records. Some day I think.
- omarchowdhury 11y agoAlmost nobody pays for impressions? Do you know how much money is spent on display ads on a CPM basis? Billions.
- BorisMelnik 11y agois true, and not just display ads even a lot of facebook is still CPM/CPC
- ChuckMcM 11y agothe point of this article though, is that folks are slowly learning that CPM/CPC is completely worthless. No amount of fraud detection is going to get it under control, and when your typical click frauder can spin up 10,000 micro instances on Amazon and generate a couple of billion false "impressions" you realize that its not cost effective to try to play that game. I agree though that many people have yet to learn this lesson, especially on Facebook but it is happening.
- BorisMelnik 11y agooh, totally agree with that. your point not to mention all of the "ad intelligence" bots or "systems" driving up the prices.
- gull 11y agoYou know a lot about this area. How would one flip advertising around?
- mozumder 11y agoNot worthless... just more expensive. If half of all banner ads are never seen, then that just means the cost is $10 CPM instead of $5 CPM. Marketers then manage their budgets with this in mind. Also, traditional display advertising (TV, Print, Radio, etc..) aren't directly measured at all. They have to go through indirect survey channels for any feedback. Yet, advertisers still use them and it has worked fine for a century+. CPM will be fine forever. Intuitive people don't need direct measurements.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoThere is a common flaw in this line: > If half of all banner ads are never seen, then that > just means the cost is $10 CPM instead of $5 CPM. It assumes that web sites are infinite, they are not. Delivering web pages, and processing clicks, costs CPU resources and bandwidth. A fraudster can put up a bogus web site and throw fraudulent clicks at it and steal fractions of a penny in the millions. And because it is all fake they have very low over head. But an actual web site that is putting up actual content is (hopefully) paying authors, doing research, paying license fees for images, etc. So click fraud drives the price an advertiser is willing to pay downward since, as you point out they know what they are willing to spend to get their ads shown, and it drives the price below what a legitimate web site needs to continue operating. Or in Facebook's case the cost of combating fraud overwhelms the price people are willing to pay for a click. Same problem. Or Google for that matter, the fact that CPC rates have fallen over the last 5 years isn't really something they have been able to fix, and its cutting into both their operating margin and their user experience as they try to make up the revenue in "inventory". > CPM will be fine forever. Intuitive people don't > need direct measurements. Come back and tell me that next year on the 1st of July. (seriously I just added a calendar item to check CPM rates in July 2016). Web advertising is either going to change or die. Since there is a lot of money involved I'm betting on change.
- chuckcode 11y agoSpent some time a few years back working in web analytics and my experience was similar to what ChuckMcM describes above - advertisers were relatively sophisticated in general and wanted to pay for performance rather than impression. There are certainly agencies/networks that will waste you're money in advertising if you're not paying attention in digital or traditional media but controlling fraud wasn't terribly difficult. Lots of advertisers would run their own beacons to check and make sure they were getting the audience they were sold. The thing that made them the most nervous was when they couldn't audit their campaigns and the person measuring the audience was the same one selling it.
- x0x0 11y agoIt's not at all obvious that advertisers are going to pay for performance, where I assume you mean buy ads on a cpa basis. There's risk, and someone will bear, and get paid to bear, that risk. If advertisers buy on a cpa basis, they pay more for the privilege. And frankly (imo) that's all for small to medium advertisers anyway. Bigger advertisers buy 3 month ios and, if you don't perform, don't reup. My experience at a large DSP is this: no-one comes in as a big account; they're all grown. You get $50k for 3 months and told to demonstrate performance. If you do, your account managers call up and demand 3-5x the money. Wash rinse repeat. You do get $3-$5mm/year accounts, but they all started under $100k/3 months. And in any case, all DSPs / ad networks will be measured on a cpa basis. Don't perform, and next quarters ios don't materialize. They're just not sold cpa. If you aren't aware, btw, there are huge fights about attribution - last view is ridiculous but what most people use, leading to all sorts of gaming behavior particularly in light of cookie churn.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoI am aware of the fights, and cookie churn is a symptom of the a challenging and, to my way of thinking, a not very good way of identifying origination. Lets say I'm content provider A, I get your ad and it has an encrypted URL that lands back on my site. When it lands on my site I can decrypt it and know who sent that click to me and note it. Then, on conversion, pay that person. The challenge this system has is that it doesn't let you throw your ads into a distribution bucket and wait for them to land on some site that is buying some traffic from some traffic provider. You have to know the sites (and presumably their IP addresses) where it lands. I need a relationship between the site showing the ad, and me. Then I can be sure that anyone who clicks on that ad, and then buys something from me, I can credit the sale to that site. What is useful (and to some extent different) about this scheme is that you can compute ad spend against revenue generated. There is no 'fraud' because you don't pay unless someone "converts" (the term for making transaction). What it does do however is cut off all the shady ad networks and packagers and skimlinkers and what not because they don't add value for a large brand like Macy's or Target or Amazon. So a blog like TechCrunch with a relationship with Target can give target an exact number of how much business has arrived at Target because of their ad on Techcrunch stories. And Target can compute exactly how much revenue the clicks that landed there from TechCrunch generated. And from their existing understanding of life time value of a customer who has landed on their site and made a purchase, they can price the value of that advertisement fairly precisely. TechCrunch gets feedback on how much their ads are worth to Target and can choose to make every ad a target ad if they think it will maximize revenue, base on the performance not on the click through rate. Target could lie about conversions, but that would be self defeating in the long term (they want people to land on their site and want people to carry their advertising). If we learned anything from the meteoric rise of Google as an advertising behemoth it is that people will pay for metrics and demonstrable results. If you can provide the best metrics and the best results, you win.
- zaroth 11y ago> Its a shame that "affiliate" ads like the ones they let bloggers use have 100X their ROI... Sounds like an incredible market opportunity. What are the companies that are building ad marketplaces targeting high performing affiliate bloggers which demonstrate their value better to advertisers, and share a higher proportion of profit with the bloggers? Are there fundamental issues trying to scale up a business like this? Not everyone can spin their own custom 'sponsership' packages like DaringFireball, but there is a lot of good blog content out there. I remember seeing some bespoke ad networks in the designer space, can't think of their name off-hand. Had the feel of a high-end web ring, if that's not an oxymoron.
- pstrateman 11y ago> Eventually the advertisers are going to pay for performance, and to do that they are going to have to fix the way they do advertising so that their ad, leads to their landing page which identifies who delivered the ad. I've setup a system that tracked that. The result was a 95% drop in payments for referrals.
- Maarten88 11y agoI heard of (large) brand advertisers where marketing managers bought fraudulent clicks on their own campaigns to "guarantee" success of these campaigns, for internal politics/career reasons. These advertisers probably like it the way it is, and keep their offline marketing colleagues in the dark.
- jmngomes 11y agoI founded a startup creating an innovative media for mobile that, while probably not "immune" to fraud, had very little space for, and provided accurate and real measurements on engagement and content exposure. While trying to sell this, I heard multiple advertisers say that they only buy TV ads because it would look "weird" with their hierarchy if the company is not on prime time TV, despite knowing that TV ads are hardly profitable and nearly impossible to measure. The same thing goes for billboards on roads with heavy traffic in the capital.
- JOnAgain 11y agoThe majority of mobile is still CPM. I dare say the vast majority. Source: I ran a mobile DSP until recently.
- jackgavigan 11y ago> Eventually the advertisers are going to pay for performance, and to do that they are going to have to fix the way they do advertising so that their ad, leads to their landing page which identifies who delivered the ad. Then they are going to pay based on whether or not the person who landed on their page actually buys something (service, good, or subscription). No money, no ad payment. This already happens. It's referred to as an "acquisition" and "cost-per-acquisition" (CPA) is a fairly standard term in the advertising industry these days. However, it doesn't necessarily involve money (e.g. a car company might define an acquisition as someone signing up for a test drive).
- jgalt212 11y ago> Eventually the advertisers are going to pay for performance, That assumes that you can actually measure performance or attribution. This is far from a solved problem. As such many publishers are reluctant to sell on this basis. Trivial rebuttal: User clicks on ad, buys product. Who's to say that ad caused the sale? Maybe they've seen that particular ad or a variant on dozens of different publisher sites. Or even better, maybe the true product awareness was driven by an offline interaction (billboard or word of mouth). In the general case, you simply cannot measure direct attribution or performance with any real sense of confidence.