4 ms·
I would generalize the finding to: spend the money on something that rewards success and not failure. Giving money to failing schools rewards failing schools.
by ams6110 11y ago
I would generalize the finding to: spend the money on something that rewards success and not failure.
Giving money to failing schools rewards failing schools.
Giving money to the poor and unemployed rewards being poor and unemployed.
Giving money to the homeless rewards being homeless.
Use the money to create opportunity, not to reward failure.
- jat850 11y agoYour reply rubbed me the wrong way, as it implies that being poor, unemployed, or homeless are by definition failures. Perhaps you didn't intend that (or perhaps you do believe it). Not looking for a philosophical argument - just stating my opinion contrary to what yours comes across as.
- viraptor 11y agoHow is being homeless not a failure on multiple levels? You can be poor by choice and happy with it, I agree. But is any sane person homeless by choice? Not traveling, hermit, not able to function in society, or many other cases. Just wanting to live somewhere and able to do work, but not having a home. To me that seems like a failure on multiple levels: country - global situation that allows people to be homeless, local - no community support or path to employment or investment into people, self - well... unless we give some income to everyone, and you can't claim benefits for not being able to work, you're expected to work for a place to live. Unemployed is an artifact of the economy. I'd like to be successful enough to be unemployed, but rich and not homeless.
- jat850 11y agoIt is a failure on many levels - systematic ones, mostly. But if you read OP's post as not singling out the failure as being personally and solely responsible for their plight, rather than as a systematic failure, then we might simply differ on reading it. Donating money to combat homelessness at a systematic level is (in my opinion) probably a good thing. I just didn't get that sentiment in what I saw, though I allow for the (frequent and possible) chance that I am wrong in my interpretation.
- robotresearcher 11y agoEmpathy failure. I hope if you ever screw up really badly there is someone else to give you a hand.
- viraptor 11y agoThis is exactly what I wrote. Not having a community-level support for cases of "you screwed up badly" is a failure. Same for no benefits when "life screws you up badly". Not sure where you see the empathy failure.
- robotresearcher 11y agoSorry - replied to wrong comment - should have been the top-level comment by ams6110. Absolutely not aimed at you.
- zo1 11y agoIf one takes a very mechanical world-view, then yes, you could say that those properties are a signal of failure. Failure to plan, keep a job, save money, etc. Being very risk-averse myself, I would constitute all of the above under normal situations to be a failing on my part. Abnormal circumstances obviously change the dynamic a bit as they're almost always unavoidable. E.g. natural disasters, war, large-scale riots, etc.
- jat850 11y agoI agree that risk aversion, planning, and other factors are good preventative measures to avoiding homelessness. The contrary case I can think of is the child who is homeless because the parent is. I cannot rightfully view them as having failed.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- lmm 11y agoBut a "safety net" enables people to take risks that work out positive for society. E.g. in the US people are much more willing to start a business (something that should be a net positive for society) once they pass the Medicaid eligibility age, since they can be assured they'll have healthcare even if their business fails. Heck, the joint-stock corporation, the big innovation of capitalism, is basically a way to reward failure (by limiting investors' liability in failure cases). You do need to be careful about perverse incentives, but being homeless or unemployed is so bad for you that I can't imagine a few hundred dollars make it suddenly worth doing deliberately.