3 ms·
Reading Is Forgetting
- j_s 11y agoI wonder how this concept ties in with my preference to be vaguely aware of as much as possible, filling in the blanks (via Google, etc.) only when needed?
- pkkim 11y agoI've never read any book more than seven or eight times, but here's another view from a "centireader" (should that be "hectoreader"?): http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/feb/09/centireading-force-reading-book-100-times-great-idea http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/feb/09/centireading-fo...
- TodPunk 11y agoMy sister will read a novel in about 4 hours, and I'll take 14 hours for the same. Afterward, I'll remember just about everything, and she will remember major plot points but few details. I don't know if the hours and retention rates are related, but I will say that reading and retention rates are not universal between people and should be separate as concepts from remembering and memory in general. The artistic understanding aspects of the article are far more interesting to me, though I have little to add there.
- lfowles 11y agoI like to blaze through fiction. But I'm reading for the effects and emotions it stirs up inside of me, not the actual content. (I will note this is an issue for long running series if I ever have to take time off inbetween books.) If I try the same with nonfiction/technical books, the retention is abysmal.
- Kenji 11y agoEver since my first year at uni, my reading has been transformed. The lectures forced me to read highly mathematical and algorithmic books, some of which took multiple hours per page if you want to comprehend everything. Now, my reading has slowed down drastically (10-100 times slower) but when I'm done with reading something, I understand it well enough to explain all the key concepts to someone else. Another thing is that I somehow memorize where things are, that is, when I remember some passage, I know where to look in the book almost down to the page (this doesn't work for PDFs which is one of the reasons why I avoid them). But I've lost the ability to read for pleasure, I used to be able to finish a novel in an evening.
- somerandomone 11y agoI'm curious because once you have the ability to understand several-hour-per-page materials reading novels should be a breeze?
- vanderZwan 11y agoI suspect it's similar to my experience with many video-lectures: on one hand, they are almost always filled with enough new information to keep my attention. However, the pace at which this information is fed to me can be just a bit too slow, meaning that my brain has to do too little work to process it. This combination of keeping attention while not activating my own thinking has an ability to put me sleep in a very drastic fashion. As in, trying to pay attention to the lecture and literally falling asleep in the blink of an eye. The only way to counter this is to download the lectures and play them back at an increased pace - 1.2x to 1.5x, depending on the difficulty of the subject. Perhaps the novels have the same issue for Kenji: too little stimulation to keep the mind going, even if it keeps your attention.
- HenryTheHorse 11y ago> But I've lost the ability to read for pleasure, I used to be able to finish a novel in an evening. I'm convinced there is such a thing as a "reading muscle". After being "lost" for many years in the "I can no longer read fiction" territory, I dove into it unexpectedly one weekend and found my fiction-for-pleasure groove again. (Ironically, it took a long non-fiction book to do that!) But this does mean I no longer allow myself to aimlessly binge on TV or the web for pleasure. Reading certainly requires a stronger intention and attention.