6 ms·
Europe's Moment of Truth
- yc1010 11y agoDidn't the Greeks pretty much do for years what the likes of Krugman and his fellow Keynesians advocate (more government spending etc)
- aikah 11y agoYou're are caricaturing. that's not what Keynesians say. Spending to stimulate growth during a financial crisis ? sure,that's what the USA just did. But not spending just for the sake of it. And bailing out private banks with public money is not Keynesian-ism. It's moral hazard.
- rors 11y agoKeynesians advocate for large amounts of public spending during recessions to stimulate the economy. They don't advocate for racking up a large amount of public dept to spend during the periods of growth, which is what happened in Greece. There are many other issues with the Greek economy such as clientism, the inability to collect taxes, etc that all economists would agree needs fixing.
- thrill 11y ago"If you ask me, it has been an act of monstrous folly on the part of the creditor governments and institutions to push it to this point." In Krugman's Nobel Peace Prize world, it's folly that creditors expect to be paid back, or to even require that debtors show a workable plan for such payment.
- Sven7 11y agoYup, in Krugman's world there is no upper limit on credit.
- andybak 11y agoWhat a silly over-simplification of his actual views.
- jjtheblunt 11y agoNot really. More of a damning distillate?
- sgift 11y agoIn that case I'll provide a "distillate" of the typical "but, but, money must be paid back" view: Too dumb to understand the concept of "risk in lending".
- autokad 11y agoI generally agree with statements like that about krugman, but in this case I believe he is right. demanding a country raise taxes during a recession, with no less than 25% unemployment, is ... well i don't know the exact word, but its bad. its clear that nations in joining in this union gain some benefits, but they loose the control of their own money. and that has been show to be more than just paper, they loose their sovereignty.
- Confusion 11y agoIf you believe the proposed solution was 'increase taxes', you are uninformed and should have refrained from commenting on this topic.
- rockinghigh 11y agoThe offered deals included reducing pensions and increasing tax revenues.
- Confusion 11y agoYes, increasing tax revenues. That does not mean increasing taxes. A major problem in Greece is that taxes aren't being paid. Raising taxes does not solve that problem.
- pvaldes 11y agoIncreasing VAT means increasing taxes. The funny fact is that the experiment backfired totally in other countries and both Tsipras and the Troika know it. When Spain increased VAT forced by the Troika, revenues dropped instead to increase. People just started refusing to buy at the new prices and the government lost millions in its expected tax revenue, increasing the crisis instead to solving it. Maybe by design. The troika for instance force the government to raise VAT from 4% to 21% in barbershops. As result of this, more than 13.000 small beauty salons, otherwise doing reasonably well, closed in only two years. This means adding about 34.000 people to unemployment statistics (and also that VAT revenues from those business fell suddenly from 21% to 0%). Finally, as expected, troika nonsense is hurting also Deutschland. As companies were earning less and being taxed more, some closed or relocated and people get fired and stop buying as happily as before. German products are losing grip in the market at the new tax prices imposed by germany, just because China can always offer cheaper replacements. Germany industry was selling 'trust', not 'cheap', but troika repeated failures blowing up the middle class had damaged seriously the trust or the need to the germany expertise.
- zurn 11y agoThis is also how the market participants see it. Or to put it in terms of art, the creditors are expected to estimate credit risk and price loans accordingly, and it is folly to underestimate it. When loaning to a government it is called "sovereign risk".
- gonvaled 11y agoCreditors charge a healthy premium risk for the eventuality that they will not be paid back. Sometimes, the risk materializes and they do not get paid back. It is their right to get mad and stop giving more credit, but it does not follow that it is not in their interest to give more credit, and try to solve the problems without forcing the debtor to bankrupcy.
- IndianAstronaut 11y agoGood choice on making Greek voters make the call. It is still amazing to me that with all our technology, we aren't going to the people more to make decisions.
- r0naa 11y agoExcept that this is just a manoeuvre from Tsipras to gain time and put the blame on the rest of the EU when they are forced to leave the Eurozone. The referendum is planned for July 5th while Greece's obligations to pay their debts are on June 30th. It's clear in the eyes of everyone that it's a political move. Tsipras has been feeding lies to the Greek people. He is a populist. The following scenario is likely to happen on June 30th: - The European Central Bank will maintain ELAs to their current level, it means that Greek banks will have to default. - The Greek government will have to refill their bank and nationalize them. Since they have no power over the euro, they will start printing their own money which will be worth very little.
- gonvaled 11y agoTsipras does not have mandate to do the opposite of what he promised during the election. He can still do it, but for this important turning around in the promised politics, and for this important decission for the greek people, asking them in a referendum makes sense.
- Confusion 11y agoHardly any citizen can make an informed decision about this topic. We elect leaders, who decide to trust certain experts, precisely so we do not have to be informed about every subject under the sun. The Greek government should decide and accept the blame for the consequences. Calling for a referendum is farcical.
- ra1n85 11y agoWhat kind of precedent would it set if Greece's debts were forgiven? Would there be any willing future creditors should another (very likely) financial crisis arise?
- chkuendig 11y agoDepends... Globally? None. This has happened before (even in similarly developed countries - see Argentina) and will happen again. For Europe? It's now clear that countries in the euro zone can default. A few years ago this was associated with the risk that private lenders will turn away from other Southern European (Portugal, Italy, Spain) countries, in turn raising their interest rates and thereby also pushing them into bankruptcy. Now that most debt of Greece is owned by either the ECB, EFSF or the IMF and the bond markets seemed to be back to business as usual this isn't a huge risk anymore. Long term it might mean that lenders will do some due diligence even for countries of the euro zone (then again, many of them got to sell the Greek bonds at full value to the ECB, so who knows...) Edit: As you wrote "forgiven" - debt is usually not forgiven but renegotiated once the indebted country stops (or threatens to stop) servicing said debt in the hope that an agreement can be found which is better then a unilateral default.
- calibraxis 11y agoGermany owes its prosperity to Europe writing off most of its debts in 1953. (Despite acting like total Nazis.) Not to mention getting out of paying Greece for WWII reparations. (http://www.cnbc.com/id/102495059 http://www.cnbc.com/id/102495059) So it can work out quite well! Also, the debt run up by a US-supported Greek dictator is “odious debt”, and not owed by the population. (http://www.euronews.com/2015/04/17/chomsky-says-us-is-world-s-biggest-terrorist/ http://www.euronews.com/2015/04/17/chomsky-says-us-is-world-...)
- Canada 11y agoWas all that German debt borrowed or was it largely war reparations?
- r0naa 11y agoThe kind of precedent that the Eurozone does not want to see happen. Spain, Ireland and Portugal have taken loans and paid them back or are paying them back. If any country can default their debt without consequences I leave it to you to imagine the new crazy interest that a EU country will have to pay given the "risk" of a default. That's pretty bad for the three country mentioned above.
- jayess 11y agoIf there are any Greeks on HN, I'd love to hear the sentiment on the ground.