3 ms·
> I've not read anyone claiming that the Hyperloop is technologically infeasible Then you need to read this: http://www.leancrew.com/all-this/2013/08/hyperloo
by lisper 11y ago
> I've not read anyone claiming that the Hyperloop is technologically infeasible
Then you need to read this:
http://www.leancrew.com/all-this/2013/08/hyperloop/ http://www.leancrew.com/all-this/2013/08/hyperloop/
TL;DR: thermal expansion is a show-stopper.
- Animats 11y agoYes the columns are underdesigned. That's typical of paper designs for elevated railways. Compare fictional drawings of monorails with the many real ones.[1] The Tokyo Haneda monorail has held up well through several earthquakes. Assume the Hyperloop will need comparable sized columns. They're bulkier than the Hyperloop conceptual drawings, but they work. The expansion joint problem is probably solvable. Take a look at some standard piping expansion joint options.[2] A "bumpless" expansion joint is an unusual requirement, but one could probably be designed. Two tubes slipping over each other with an interior lining of braided mesh might do the job. The SF BART tunnel under the bay has huge rubber expansion joints. It survived the 1989 earthquake with no damage. The larger Hyperloop design (3.3m diameter) is probably more useful than the little (1.43m diameter) one. The smallest successful bizjet is about 1.5m diameter. Emergency exits will be a big problem. In practice, some form of emergency access every half mile or so will probably be necessary. Eurotunnel has a cross-passage between the tubes every 375 meters. [1] http://monorails.org/ http://monorails.org/ [2] http://www.flexicraft.com/ http://www.flexicraft.com/
- lisper 11y ago> A "bumpless" expansion joint is an unusual requirement, but one could probably be designed. Not just bumpless. It also has to be sealed against a large negative pressure differential. Those two requirements together take you into unexplored engineering territory. > The SF BART tunnel under the bay has huge rubber expansion joints. Not even remotely comparable. That tunnel is two orders of magnitude shorter than the HL, the walls aren't smooth, they don't have to sustain a vacuum, and the thermal gradients are much smaller underground. > Two tubes slipping over each other with an interior lining of braided mesh might do the job And what provides the vacuum seal? > The expansion joint problem is probably solvable Sure, but the interesting question is: can it be solved without prohibitive cost. The jury is still very much out on that. > Emergency exits will be a big problem Why do you think so? Pressure-sealed doors are a solved problem.
- Animats 11y agoThere are vacuum-rated expansion joints.[1][2] They have metal rings integrated into the flexible component to prevent inward collapse. Interior tube smoothness remains a problem. The Hyperloop air bearings float at only 1mm ± 0.5mm. Even fixed joints with that tight a tolerance are difficult. Anything other than plain tube (access hatches, etc.) will have to present a totally smooth inside. Not impossible, but runs up the costs. [1] http://www.ethylene.com/flexijoint.php http://www.ethylene.com/flexijoint.php [2] http://www.garlock.com/en/products/style-204-evs http://www.garlock.com/en/products/style-204-evs
- craneca0 11y agoThe conclusion of that article actually doesn't seem to be that the Hyperloop is technically infeasible - only that the original spec does have issues, and it glossed over those issues. "I’m not saying that the problems with Hyperloop can’t be solved. Money, time, and talent can solve any problem that doesn’t involve breaking physical laws, but I wouldn’t put my money, time, or talent in the hands of someone who takes me for a fool."