2 ms·
The "seniority" titles don't really measure anything useful; that's why they don't really transfer between companies. A "senior engineer" might become a "lead e
by derefr 11y ago
The "seniority" titles don't really measure anything useful; that's why they don't really transfer between companies. A "senior engineer" might become a "lead engineer" or just an "engineer" at a different company—which means there's no objective measurement going on there.
I much prefer a guild-like system for measuring actual aptitude:
• apprentices know one thing well enough to do it (the average "Java developer");
• journeymen have a good picture of the field, know what "the best tool for the job" is in most cases (even if they don't know that tool), and have the meta-skill required to efficiently pick up a new language/framework/paradigm/whatever else in order to solve a problem that requires it;
• masters have enough experience to flinch away from bad design/architecture. They've been burned by every category of problem it's been possible to be burned by, such that they have a complete high-level picture of all the moment-to-moment considerations involved in "the art." They know what questions to ask about a proposed pull request to determine its quality. To get here, they've likely completed a major "masterpiece" work on their own, and maintained it under heavy use by others.
These aren't categories that match social standing, or seniority, or experience, per se. In fact, they don't even form a tight match to the kind of "skill" people look for in job ads; you can become a "master" at 15 if you accidentally build something really popular, even though you still need a cheat sheet to remind you what's in your language's stdlib.
But these categories are able to be objectively fit to people (it's pretty clear in which one a particular person sits); they can be carried between organizations with no loss of meaning; each category is a strict superset of the skills of the former; and they tell you something that's very useful to know.
Interestingly, it would be fully possible to set up an educational curriculum that could make every graduate a "master" by the criteria above. Right now, though, colleges only make apprentices. Companies sort of make journeymen, though rarely. And no part of "the system" has any chance of making someone into a master; they have to pursue such a trial on their own.