3 ms·
Science is not engineering. In engineering, we understand the problem domain enough to make everything reproducible, the governing principles are well enough un
by epistasis 11y ago
Science is not engineering. In engineering, we understand the problem domain enough to make everything reproducible, the governing principles are well enough understood that reasoning from first principles can usually come up with answers.
In contrast, in science, we are trying to discover those first principles. So if something doesn't replicate in another lab, we have a responsibility to check it out, but that doesn't mean that the scientist has to discover all the first principles before making a publication! The non-replication could be due to new, solid, first principles, and the assumption that it should be "reproducible" exactly from the English words on a sheet of paper are a faulty assumption.
If you want to be able to pick up the scientific literature and read it like a science text book, you're doing it wrong. That is not the purpose of publishing papers.