3 ms·
Unpopular but not unreasonable. - software is a new form of literacy. Perhaps at some point in the past literate people could contribute to the communi - the
by lifeisstillgood 11y ago
Unpopular but not unreasonable.
- software is a new form of literacy. Perhaps at some point in the past literate people could contribute to the communi
- the fallacy of altruism. Developers working on an open source JS drop list widget are not being altruistic - their contribution to the community could as easily be say working at a soup kitchen, probably with more value to the world.
"Contributing to the community" is something we rely on Adam Smiths Invisible Hand to help us with 99% of the time. So while I use and appreciate the OSS developed to date, it has gone beyond a simple charitable model and into an Eco-system beyond any simplistic approaches. I would like nirvana, but it's dubious as a long term strategy for OSS.
- conflicts of interest always happen. When it is important enough, say Linus' salary, the community will either whither or find a way to build its own institutions to make the important conflicts managed - like Linus salary. This is part of building strong institutions we hear about so often
- getting better at begging vs better at selling seems to be the last point you make. Honestly I cannot see that as a honourable position of trade.
We don't have perfect solutions - but we are working on them
- joepie91_ 11y ago> getting better at begging vs better at selling seems to be the last point you make. Honestly I cannot see that as a honourable position of trade. Asking for donations is most certainly not begging, and I personally find that a somewhat offensive way to present it. Donations are a voluntary contribution in return for some kind of work that was done; begging, by definition, isn't in return for anything. They are two fundamentally different concepts, just as different as 'accepting donations' versus 'selling'.
- lifeisstillgood 11y agoOk - sponsorship. Donations is to my mind a charitable endeavour - the small amount of change is thrown over and not considered. In fact lack of consideration is probably the right legal term. Sponsorship involves some contractural form to occur - and so implies a trade of value. To be fair you could have been saying get better at donations by rebranding them as sponsorship instead of better at soliciting uncontracted contributions. But I still think we need to find a new and better way to monetise OSS contributions.