5 ms·
> In 10 years time, Github may be the tired old service that gets acquired by a hedge fund that decides to monetize their repos. Such things are part of the cor
by scrollaway 11y ago
> In 10 years time, Github may be the tired old service that gets acquired by a hedge fund that decides to monetize their repos. Such things are part of the corporate lifecycle.
So fix it in 10 years. Git makes that easy.
Point me to a good alternative to github that matches all your ideals. A free alternative to github - free as in beer, unless you're willing to fund this effort yourself, of course?
We migrated one of our projects from Sourceforge to Github, and all the stallmen came out of their rock to tell us how Github is evil, how Savannah is the only true alternative, pah. "Absolute freedom of software" is nice but it's not the only requirement. Savannah has the usability of a rusty wrench and will probably shut down without warning long before Github "turns evil".
Some people are just so far detached from reality when suggesting that stuff isn't perfect. Github is pretty damn amazing. If you want to use foss alternative like Gitlab, more power to you, but that doesn't make them ideal in every situation.
- yellowapple 11y ago> Point me to a good alternative to github that matches all your ideals. A free alternative to github - free as in beer, unless you're willing to fund this effort yourself, of course? Gitlab? Savannah (of the nongnu.org variety)? Bitbucket? Gitorious? A basic VPS with SSH and git?
- carussell 11y agoThe source for Bitbucket is no more available than that for GitHub. http://atlassian.bitbucket.org/ http://atlassian.bitbucket.org/
- yellowapple 11y agoThe only explicitly-stated condition was "free as in beer", which BitBucket is for even private repos. BitBucket also has a self-hosted equivalent, though said equivalent is not, alas, free-as-in-beer. The implicit free-as-in-speech condition is adequately fulfilled by other alternatives, like (as I mentioned) Gitlab and (IIRC) GNU Savannah (along with - again - just installing git on an SSH-able server).
- sytse 11y agoAt GitLab you are very welcome. Please let me know if you have any questions or concerns.
- scrollaway 11y agoProps guys, I think you do an incredible job. GitLab is in fact a reasonable alternative, I should have mentioned it in my post. The reason we went to Github rather than Sourceforge is because of the community. Nethertheless, I think it's fairly foolish to focus on the platform (in the case here of archiving) - it's just a host. Stuff goes on domain 1 instead of domain 2. In either case it's still open source, the archives are all there, git is decentralized and perfect for the job.
- sytse 11y agoNo problem, that for your kind comment. And feel free to update your post :)
- scrollaway 11y agoI would, but edits are time-limited on HN.
- sytse 11y agoAhh, good point, no problem. <3
- carussell 11y agoContradictory signals in your rationale here. It comes off as if you're filling in a post-hoc justification. Is it just an archive or isn't it? If it is, what's so important about the community, then? It's fine that you chose what you did, of course. It's just that that in your defending it, you can't seem to decide whether you want to have your cake or eat it. If you wanted, this would have been a perfectly fine reason to give: "We went with GitHub because it's just what we use mostly, and other stuff not so much."
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- anonbanker 11y agoThis post should be used as study material for how the next generation of anti-GPL assaults will be done: * free (as in speech) == "Stallmen", "detached from reality" * Guerilla evangelism == "came out of their rock" * "Freedom of software" == "nice but" * Free Software Reliability == "probably shut down without warning" with a cute little pull-back at the end to make it sound like you actually don't mind FOSS. Make no mistake, this is how FOSS's adversaries will work in the future. On the bright side, this means the direct assaults are failing, and they're moving on to new tactics.
- scrollaway 11y agoThanks? You completely missed the point of my post if you are taking this as an assault instead of criticism of the alternatives. So I'm going to repeat myself here: - Savannah is shit. Zero UX effort. Atrocious home page, branding, atrocious everything. - Unfunded efforts are unreliable. Get a grip on reality, man. This isn't afound foss or proprietary or whatever - it's about having a business model. - If you think it's OK to recommend shit products as alternative to good products because of ideology, you are a detriment to the cause you claim to promote. BTW, I'm the LXQt project lead and a huge proponent of free software. Some advice next time you attack someone, look them up. Oh and here's another piece of advice: Don't attack people.
- anonbanker 11y agoI'm simultaneously honored to have been flamed by the lead of a project I'm interested in, and saddened to learn that the best source of attacks against us will be words our project leaders used first. At the same time, if we're the ones generating our own bad press, we at least control the overall narrative. I guess that's a net win.
- scrollaway 11y agoTo answer your comment and dbbolton's simultaneously: My criticism of Savannah is based on aesthetics, but also on their model. Savannah has virtually zero funding. What do you think will happen, exactly, when an unfunded host can't keep running? Maybe their gnu website will receive some donation from Facebook or Google or something, but there is no incentive to keep the nongnu part running. It's just volunteer work. That model can work (cf wikipedia), but it's extremely rare, requires a lot of effort, a lot of bootstrapping and a lot of luck. It also requires $1 to pay for more than itself, so there are extra requirements regarding efficiency of spending, and diminishing returns of donations. Gitlab has a good model. In fact, I'd be curious to see what their CEO makes of what I'm saying here - I always find him scouring HN comments about github, git, hosting, sourceforge, all of these. This is the sort of effort you have to put into to get your product out there into the ears and minds of people. As I said earlier, yes there is a risk Github will turn evil. If they do, there will be warning signs (there have been warning signs about SF for 5 years). If such is the case, there will be alternatives by then (ever heard "if there aren't, I'll build one and get rich"?). If Savannah runs out of money and has to turn off the lights, how much of a warning sign will there be? A few weeks maybe? Maybe there just won't be any. And this is a very real situation, which you absolutely need to be ready to confront. Putting your fingers in your ears and calling everything "an assault" won't help. > if we're the ones generating our own bad press, we at least control the overall narrative It's a very bad sign that you care so much about the "overall narrative". It's reminiscent of your approach to flag criticism as assault again. You care about what people say, not why they say it. I'm not paid by an anti-FOSS group or just felt like shitting on the work of random people. There's a reason behind everything I wrote here and above; it's backed by experience. And you'll be hard pressed to find people disagreeing that Savannah is pretty terrible... you can't just go around "controlling the narrative" like you own the media. You have to fix the problem at the root.