3 ms·
On the other hand, the scale of economic aid to Greece is unprecedented, with lined up bailout of €240 billion. For a foreign aid that's quite an amount, I'm no
by varjag 11y ago
On the other hand, the scale of economic aid to Greece is unprecedented, with lined up bailout of €240 billion. For a foreign aid that's quite an amount, I'm not sure even what to compare it to. Marshall plan?
Mind you, we're speaking of a nation of 11 million. The whole former USSR got an order of magnitude less financial aid throughout the 1990s with an order of magnitude more population, and being in worse shape than Greece to start with. I don't think it's unreasonable for creditors to care how the money are spent with this type figures.
- pjc50 11y agoThat figure is a loan, and is smaller than the national debts of many larger EU countries. It's not the size of the debt that matters in absolute terms, but the ability to make payments. I don't see anyone arguing that the holders of the US$14trn debt should get to run the country simply because of the size of the debt. Errata: for "ECB" read "EU as represented by the Commission. The ECB are providing life support for the Greek banking system and trying desperately not to either get dragged into the politics, lose all their money, or blow up the EU banking system.
- varjag 11y agoA loan is still aid: much of it elsewhere is in form of loans too. Take Ukraine (broke, 45 million people and at war with Russia), who has a two year IMF lifeline amounting to $27 billion, most of it in form of loans. It takes the money and complies its economic policy with IMF advisory board. Most of the aid to Russia was structured as loans throughout 1990s as well, but much of these were written off as it often happens. > It's not the size of the debt that matters in absolute terms, but the ability to make payments. Well this is what the fuss is about, isn't it? The lenders don't see Greece being able to repay unless they implement austerity measures.
- coldtea 11y ago>On the other hand, the scale of economic aid to Greece is unprecedented, with lined up bailout of €240 billion. It's not aid per se though (like the Marshall plan you compared it to). First, it still is in the forms on loans. Yes, the "aid" is just further loans (with lower rates), that are piled up on the previous debt (with interest on them repaid normally all these years). Second, the aid goes this way: from EU taxpayers and the Greek state (its payback to the aid loans), to EU banks. The aid money are not given to Greek government to pay salaries, etc. or any such purose. They go directly to the creditors. Like the "too big to fail" Wall Street bailout, this is too about siphoning money to central European banks to protect them from toxic assets they had accumulated. Third, this "non-aid" aid (essentially letting Greece near-default and then lenting them money month-to-month to repay its debt under certain conditions), was used to bully Greece to take a number of tax hikes, austerity measures etc, who killed its economy (30% unemployment and up to 50% youth unemployment, 40% loss of wages, etc) to give money for the "aid" loans (which never touched Greece), and to Fourth, all this is even more damning considering that Germany in WWII invaded Greece, resulting in 700.000 deaths from famine, thousands of deaths from executions, and massive destruction of infrastructure. They also took a "loan" from the occupied country, which they never repaid, without also repaying their war recuperations. Germany was absolved from doing so in the early fifties, despite the harm they caused to Greece, because they were new cold war darlings and valuable US allies (and ditto for Eastern Germany / USSR). And what could Greece do about it anyway? Here are some thinking points: http://www.forbes.com/sites/afontevecchia/2012/02/21/greek-bailout-deal-a-farce-to-benefit-banks-at-the-expense-of-greece/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/afontevecchia/2012/02/21/greek-b... http://in.reuters.com/article/2012/06/29/spain-germany-bailout-ifr-idINL6E8HTFC820120629 http://in.reuters.com/article/2012/06/29/spain-germany-bailo...