3 ms·
What kind of equipment do you propose to use for a mid-air recovery of a fragile rocket stage that's 200ft long and weighs a couple dozen tons? A large rig sus
by stcredzero 11y ago
What kind of equipment do you propose to use for a mid-air recovery of a fragile rocket stage that's 200ft long and weighs a couple dozen tons?
A large rig suspended from beneath a large helicopter. If there's a parachute involved, then it supposedly has a mount point that can support the weight of the rocket under high g load. (And of course, that would add weight.)
What kind of liquid do you propose filling the pond with that won't destroy the rocket on impact? Hitting water at high speed is like ramming into concrete, and I don't think other liquids will be much better.
Points off for poor reading comprehension. The scheme is to replace the landing legs with inflatable ballutes. The 1st stage would still nearly land just above the water. The impact the ballutes would take would only be from a short distance.
Your ideas sound like, "What SpaceX is doing is far too easy, let's come up with vastly more difficult approaches so they have a proper challenge!"
Your comment sounds a tad bit sensitive and emotional? In reality, I'm just going through the intellectual exercise of seeing what would work, given the landing control getting no better than what we have now. I fully expect it to get better, however.
- lutorm 11y agoSpecifically, which large helicopter has the required payload capacity? Also, rockets are built to support compressive loads. The tensile loads imposed by a parachute slowing the stage down are completely different, so there's no guarantee you could even use a parachute without significant strengthening of the structure.
- stcredzero 11y agoSpecifically, which large helicopter has the required payload capacity? One might have to build one, and the scheme may well only be suitable for smaller rockets. Also, the point isn't to slow down the 1st stage from max velocity. It's to replace the landing legs after a near-hover.
- nether 11y ago> One might have to build one > One might have to start an entire aircraft development program, employing a hundred or so rotorcraft engineers, constructing test facilities along the way, that might take years and tens of millions to complete
- msandford 11y ago> might take years and tens of millions to complete Only if it's SpaceX doing it. If it were anybody else, I'd guess over a decade and hundreds of millions.
- mikeash 11y agoThe largest production helicopter ever made, the Mi-26, has a maximum cargo capacity of 20 metric tons, which is already insufficient. Making things worse, there would be a tremendous shock when the catch is first made. I guess if you want to add "building a helicopter far larger than any so far yet built" to the list of SpaceX's activities.... The stage will fall over on impact with water, so you're still talking about a 200ft drop for the top of it, and it's still going to hit hard when this happens. You don't appear to have any concept of the numbers involved here or the physical limitations, so I don't see how this could possibly be an intellectual exercise of seeing what would work. Saying "just catch it in mid-air with a helicopter," when no helicopter capable of doing this currently exists in the world, and building one that's suitable would be a massive undertaking, is intellectually lazy, not an intellectual exercise. I don't see where I'm being sensitive or emotional. I'm just pointing out that your suggestions are, in fact, a whole lot worse than what's currently being done, and are therefore kind of ridiculous to just suggest off the cuff. Brainstorming is fun, but is it too much to ask to do a basic smell test on the ideas before you start talking about them as if they were realistic?
- stcredzero 11y agoThe largest production helicopter ever made, the Mi-26, has a maximum cargo capacity of 20 metric tons, which is already insufficient. There are startups going for cheap access to space with a much smaller class of launchers. 20 metric tons might well be workable for such a scheme, and it would lighten the control requirement under rocket power, which is admittedly hard. Also, there isn't even a requirement for the aircraft to be a helicopter, so much heavier 1st stage boosters could be handled. Helicopters would enable much lighter logistical requirements, however. You don't appear to have any concept of the numbers involved here or the physical limitations, so I don't see how this could possibly be an intellectual exercise of seeing what would work. Saying "just catch it in mid-air with a helicopter," when no helicopter capable of doing this currently exists in the world, and building one that's suitable would be a massive undertaking, is intellectually lazy, not an intellectual exercise. You know, you're applying an awful lot of assumptions to make the general scheme not work: a particular booster, a particular kind of aircraft,... etc. You can also think of that as informing the limitations of the particular scheme and delimiting the size and purpose of the launches it's suitable for. I don't see where I'm being sensitive or emotional. I'm just pointing out that your suggestions are, in fact, a whole lot worse than what's currently being done, and are therefore kind of ridiculous to just suggest off the cuff. Brainstorming is fun, but is it too much to ask to do a basic smell test on the ideas before you start talking about them as if they were realistic? Your "basic smell test" takes very particular assumptions that produce a ridiculous result. It's intellectually lazy on your part to just leave it there.