5 ms·
It seems like they could replace the landing legs with a parachute, which they could catch in mid-air, as intended for the Genesis probe. Bringing the 1st stage
by stcredzero 11y ago
It seems like they could replace the landing legs with a parachute, which they could catch in mid-air, as intended for the Genesis probe. Bringing the 1st stage nearly to a stop at some point mid-air should be way easier than landing it on the ground.
For that matter, could a balloon be used as a recovery method?
Another alternative: Land in an artificial pond. The lake could be filled with a liquid specifically formulated to be kind to the rocket parts. (Perhaps just reservoir quality water?) The design could again dispense with the landing gear. Perhaps sturdy heat-resistant ballutes could inflate to take the water-impact and hold the rockets up and out of the water?
EDIT: Wow, so much anger! For one thing, all the above schemes involve first coming to an almost-hover mid-air. Also, why is everyone imagining such an amazing tone from my post? Please produce a quote that justifies this assumption. (Hint, it's irrational. Just take my brainstorming at face value.)
- TrevorJ 11y agoOnce you realize that the end goal is to be able to fly back rockets in places with a minimum of infrastructure it makes sense. Heck we landed on the moon the same way. Also, rockets are deceptively fragile so most variations of the 'catch and drop' type recovery won't be good for the rocket.
- srdev 11y ago> Bringing the 1st stage nearly to a stop at some point mid-air should be way easier than landing it on the ground. One thing to note about Falcon 9 is that it's impossible for it to hover since its thrust-to-weight ratio is greater than 1 at the time of recovery, even at minimum throttle. So you have to do a suicide burn such that you zero out velocity at your target. Someone already pointed out the problem with helicopters capacity compared to the Falcon 9 weight. The idea is not without merit, However. ULA is considering a similar approach for the Vulcan. The big difference is that they plan to eject the engine core and catch only the engines with a helicopter. See http://spaceflightnow.com/2015/04/13/ula-unveils-its-future-with-the-vulcan-rocket-family/ http://spaceflightnow.com/2015/04/13/ula-unveils-its-future-... The downside of this plan is increased complexity. Falcon 9's approach requires fins, some landing struTs and software. ULAs approach requires a system to eject the core, a shield for the cores re-entry, a parachute, a helicopter, and impeccable timing. I'm guessing that catching a parachute with a helicopter is an incredibly difficult problem just by itself. I would suggest that you watch the Vulcan development to see how your thoughts play out. Regarding the pool, I would assume that the issue would be finding an inert liquid, putting it in the middle of the ocean stably and enough quantities for a landing, and then getting the rocket into the liquid without damaging it. You'd likely still have all the same problems as just landing the rocket -- you have to zero horizontal elicits or the thing tips over and impacts the liquid too hard, and you have to zero verticle velocity or your impact is too hard. Ultimately you might as well just land the damn thing, which is also more versatile.
- cryptoz 11y agoThe atmosphere of Mars is not thick enough to support a parachute landing, so that's out. Balloons do not work well on Mars either; landing heavy payloads with balloons result in a lot of bouncing, which is bad for both equipment and for humans. There are also no artificial ponds on Mars. Additionally, water is not good for the rocket parts (salt water is terrible, but I think even fresh water is not good). SpaceX is iterating on technology that will eventually be used to land millions of people on Mars. Before they get to that stage, they are working on perfecting rapid, full reusability of rockets to 1) achieve lower launch costs to win the market, and 2) have a ready-to-go system for landing people on Mars. The primary design principles of the landing system must work on Mars as well as they do on Earth.
- DavidSJ 11y agoIt always amazes me how people see this video and immediately think "I need to redesign this for them" rather than "wow, that prototype is amazingly close to working beautifully". It's as if a complex software system is being tested for the first time, a couple bugs are found, and onlookers think the right answer is to redesign everything from scratch.
- grkvlt 11y agoI am also amazed that people seem to want to replace the SpaceX system where the rocket would land itself at an arbitrary location on land, ready for re-fuelling and re-use, automatically, with the existing launch engines and no extra technology required beyond somewhere flat - with a complex system of tracking radars to find the rocket, extra aerodynamic drag devices such as parachutes or balloons to slow it down, and a fleet of manned vehicles to retrieve it, using a dangerous mid air rendeszvous. It's pretty obvious that these systems have none of the useful properties of the SpaceX solution, so it's hard to understand why anyone would think they are superior....
- stcredzero 11y agoJust relax, man. I'm not claiming that I have "the answer." Seeing the landing 1st stage just makes me wonder about all the other possible schemes. (Probably the same thing happened when the Wright Flyer was first seen.)
- krschultz 11y agoHacker News is harsh to people suffering from the Dunning-Kruger effect, and doubly harsh for those critical of SpaceX. That said, your first comment really comes across about as aloof as some non-technical guy saying "how long will it take to build Facebook? It's a website right?"
- stcredzero 11y agoHacker News is harsh to people suffering from the Dunning-Kruger effect, and doubly harsh for those critical of SpaceX. The 1st doesn't apply, and the last one is only in the imaginations of knee-jerkers. That said, your first comment really comes across about as aloof Again, this has everything to do with some "tone" in your imagination.
- pothibo 11y agoParachutes are not a good idea because of how rockets are built. The parachute would apply too much stress on the structure of the rocket which would reduce its lifespan/potential for reuse. While it's normal to try to think and find better alternative, let me remind you that going into space is not simple. I always have a strong feeling about people over-simplifying hard problems with clueless alternative. I feel this shows a lack of understanding and respect to a field you clearly don't understand. Try to take this as a constructive criticism.
- stcredzero 11y agoParachutes are not a good idea because of how rockets are built. The parachute would apply too much stress to the structure of the rocket which would reduce its lifespan/potential for reuse. Thank you. I was waiting for this response! While it's normal to try to think and find better alternative, let me remind you that going into space is not simple. I always have a strong feeling about people over-simplifying hard problems with clueless alternative. I know I'm a layman in this field. Nothing wrong with asking questions. I feel this shows a lack of understanding and respect to a field you clearly don't understand. I know I don't understand everything, but you should know better than to just engage in harsh silencing tactics against anyone who simply asks a question out of curiosity. If you see something in my post suggesting this is not the case, please post a quote. Then if you can't find anything that isn't subjective "tone" then please know that this was all in your imagination. Try to take this as a constructive criticism.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mikeash 11y agoYou mostly didn't ask questions, though. Of the three possibilities you gave, the only one you expressed in the form of a question was the balloon one. I get it, you were just idly speculating and wondering about possibilities. But surely you see why people are reacting badly to it given that you did not just ask questions.
- mikeash 11y agoWhat kind of equipment do you propose to use for a mid-air recovery of a fragile rocket stage that's 200ft long and weighs a couple dozen tons? What kind of liquid do you propose filling the pond with that won't destroy the rocket on impact? Hitting water at high speed is like ramming into concrete, and I don't think other liquids will be much better. Your ideas sound like, "What SpaceX is doing is far too easy, let's come up with vastly more difficult approaches so they have a proper challenge!"
- stcredzero 11y agoWhat kind of equipment do you propose to use for a mid-air recovery of a fragile rocket stage that's 200ft long and weighs a couple dozen tons? A large rig suspended from beneath a large helicopter. If there's a parachute involved, then it supposedly has a mount point that can support the weight of the rocket under high g load. (And of course, that would add weight.) What kind of liquid do you propose filling the pond with that won't destroy the rocket on impact? Hitting water at high speed is like ramming into concrete, and I don't think other liquids will be much better. Points off for poor reading comprehension. The scheme is to replace the landing legs with inflatable ballutes. The 1st stage would still nearly land just above the water. The impact the ballutes would take would only be from a short distance. Your ideas sound like, "What SpaceX is doing is far too easy, let's come up with vastly more difficult approaches so they have a proper challenge!" Your comment sounds a tad bit sensitive and emotional? In reality, I'm just going through the intellectual exercise of seeing what would work, given the landing control getting no better than what we have now. I fully expect it to get better, however.
- lutorm 11y agoSpecifically, which large helicopter has the required payload capacity? Also, rockets are built to support compressive loads. The tensile loads imposed by a parachute slowing the stage down are completely different, so there's no guarantee you could even use a parachute without significant strengthening of the structure.
- stcredzero 11y ago
- lutorm 11y agoI'm curious what device you would use to "catch it"?
- stcredzero 11y agoSomething suspended from underneath a large cargo helicopter, or a large cargo helicopter specially constructed for the purpose. As in the Genesis probe, the device would be catching the parachute.
- lutorm 11y agoMass of genesis probe: 494kg according to Wikipedia. Mass of an empty F9 stage: not public, but http://www.spaceflight101.com/falcon-9-v11.html http://www.spaceflight101.com/falcon-9-v11.html estimated it at 23,000-26,000 kg. That's almost twice the 14,000 kg payload of the heaviest helicopter I could find, the CH-53E. Do you really think designing and building a new helicopter with twice the payload capacity of anything built will be a more cost-effective plan?
- stcredzero 11y agoThat's incredibly light! It couldn't be done with an existing helicopter, but it could be done with an airplane. Do you really think designing and building a new helicopter with twice the payload capacity of anything built will be a more cost-effective plan? Specifically for the Falcon 9, no. For the record, I think SpaceX knows what it's doing, and if they've concluded landing the 1st stage is the best way to go, it probably is. But it's fun to think about spacecraft recovery and huge machines. (Unless you're being piled on by tons of emotional HN commenters who imagine you holding strawman positions and speaking in imagined tones.)
- nether 11y agoThat's actually the approach being used with the ULA Vulcan to recover the first stage: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vulcan_(rocket) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vulcan_(rocket). I think it is an easier method with less flexibility than self-landing. As typical SpaceX is shooting for the stars.
- ceejayoz 11y agoPart of the first stage - just the engines.
- Animats 11y agoJust landing on a larger target than their barge would be easier. The April landing probably would have succeeded if they hadn't had to make a big horizontal move just before landing to get into position over the barge. Once they get the barge landing working once, they plan to switch to landings on a landing pad, which can be made much bigger than the barge.
- koverstreet 11y agoThe horizontal correction at the end was part of the plan. I suspect the purpose is to come in at an angle so that the direction of the final correction is approximately known, and they can correct only by varying the amount of thrust, not the direction of the thrust (which is presumably slower). Vs. coming in right on target - you'll still have small corrections to make at the end, but you have to gimbal the thruster in a random direction.
- TrevorJ 11y agoThey come in at an angle so that the rocket is not over the barge for long, that way if it fails higher up it doesn't fall onto the barge with a lot of kinetic energy.
- iamcreasy 11y agoFalcon 9 first stage it too heavy to catch mid air, and using parachute isn't viable trade off because the required parachutes will be too heavy.
- lutorm 11y agoPlease produce a quote that justifies this assumption. How about "It seems like they could replace the landing legs with a parachute ..."? Or "bringing the 1st stage nearly to a stop at some point mid-air should be way easier than landing it"? Rather than continuing to assert that there is absolutely nothing about your post that implies you know better, you really should drop the ego and dispassionately read your own posts from an outsider's perspective. Understanding how you come across to others will be helpful when formulating yourself in the future.
- Doji 11y agoOne of the design goals is the ability to land on Mars, and none of these ideas satisfy that constraint. Powered landing also has advantages in control, ease of recovery, etc.
- classicsnoot 11y agoThis (the whole chain of comments stemming from this parent in parent) is as ridiculous as it is entertaining. A lay person asks a question but uses phrasing that could be construed as declarative at first glance and suddenly everyone on HN is a rocket scientist, a SpaceX PR spokesperson, a SpaceX fanboy, or all three. Adorable. The true irony is that all of the people responding with righteous indignation ( typically a good sign that the speaker has lost their objectivity) are 'defending' SpaceX from the violent attack from a person that is just Wonder if there may be another way to do something. Priceless. And just to be crass, there are many fucking ways to skin a cat, assuming you get to build the cat, the skin, and the implement(s) to be used. I'm pretty sure the wizards at SpaceX are ok with people thinking stuff and writing it online. All of you apologists may be better off sitting in quiet contemplation of the place the Crowd takes in literally every story of innovation. Just my .048 BTC
- srdev 11y agoIt's kind of funny because "catch it with a helicopter" is ULA's plan, with the caveat that they're only catching the engines and not the whole rocket.