3 ms·
If the findings of parapsychology are always false, then it's only because things cease to become parapsychology as soon as there is an established mechanism. T
by Alex3917 17y ago
If the findings of parapsychology are always false, then it's only because things cease to become parapsychology as soon as there is an established mechanism. Things go from being parapsychology to psychology all the time.
Synaesthasia, mirror neurons, and mystical experiences are three completely different parapsychological phenomena that have become accepted by mainstream science within the last ten years. I see no reason why science won't keep validating more paranormal theories in the future.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- Alex3917 17y agoSo there are several names for the same thing: mystical experience, primary religious experience, enlightenment experience, etc. But it's basically the experience of leaving your body, traveling through a tunnel toward a bright light, and then learning one or more of the noetic truths described here: http://csp.org/experience/docs/stace-states.html http://csp.org/experience/docs/stace-states.html This experience is said to feel more real than real life, and to be largely ineffable. This is obviously problematic for science for a number of reasons. (For example, if it's true that there is such a thing as an ineffable experience, this means that the basic assumptions underlying all of science are false.) Anyway in 2006 scientists were able to recreate mystical states in 60-70% of participants using a high dose of psilocybin. These experiences corresponded very well with the traditional mystical states as described by all the world religions. (Basically the vast majority of religions were created by people who had a 'primary religious experience'.) If you want to experience this for yourself, you can sign up to be part of the next round of experiments at csp.org. Although there are definitely some pretty serious risks, so you wouldn't really want to sign up until reading a few books on the subject so that you understand these risks and can make an informed decision. There is a podcast called Gnostic Media that has a really good interview with the researcher who did the 2006 Hopkins study. I'd highly recommend it. All of their interviews are actually really good.
- joeyo 17y agoThis experience is said to feel more real than real life, and to be largely ineffable. This is obviously problematic for science for a number of reasons. (For example, if it's true that there is such a thing as an ineffable experience, this means that the basic assumptions underlying all of science are false.) Aren't all our subjective experiences ineffable? In other words we can only communicate our experiences to each other because our experiences are shared and by communicating egocentric analogies. Or to put another way: if a bat tries to explain to you what it's like to navigate with sonar it's going to seem pretty freaking ineffable to you! That's why they call it the Hard Problem. :-)
- gort 17y agoif it's true that there is such a thing as an ineffable experience, this means that the basic assumptions underlying all of science are false. Isn't the fact that these experiences can be induced by using a physical collection of molecules to do something physical to the brain an indication that, actually, they're just the sort of physical processes that are compatible with materialistic science?
- pmichaud 17y agoOf course it's compatible! But that doesn't rob it of its magic. Just because we discover the lever, doesn't prove there isn't something tugging on the lever. I have a couple articles on my site about how the concept of the "supernatural" is incoherent, but that it doesn't matter: we experience such a small subset of "reality" that we need a concept "outside the normal realm of experience." I called it "Hypernatural," for lack of a better term already in use.
- Alex3917 17y agoThe issue is that if a phenomenon is indescribable through either words or math then how can we collect any independently verifiable data? It would be impossible to create any laws governing such a phenomenon, because we would never be able to see whether or not the laws fit the past data and were capable of predicting the future.
- kurtosis 17y agoWhat's a mystical experience? I find parapsych pretty interesting, but I've never heard of this, at least in the context of mainstream science.
- a-priori 17y agoTwo examples I can think of: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Temporal_lobe_epilepsy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Temporal_lobe_epilepsy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_monoxide_poisoning http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_monoxide_poisoning (the "haunted houses" section)
- Alex3917 17y agoThose aren't mystical experiences. An experience is only a mystical one if it scores above a certain threshold on the empirically derived Mysticism Scale, and ghost experiences definitely would not qualify.
- joeyo 17y agoSuggesting that mirror neurons were ever somehow parapsychology seems like a bit of a stretch.
- Alex3917 17y agoMirror neurons themselves were never parapsychology, but they explain phenomena that were considered paranormal before their discovery: http://health.howstuffworks.com/synesthesia.htm/printable http://health.howstuffworks.com/synesthesia.htm/printable
- gwern 17y agoHold on. This is a historical question; electromagnetism explains stuff that could be considered paranormal as well, but that stuff wasn't. Were the mirror neuron phenomena actually noticed, classified under parapsychology, and investigated by parapsychologists, producing results that had any connection to their eventual uptake by mainstream psychology/neurology? The link doesn't mention anything like that; if anything, the example of the woman who thought mirror-touching was perfectly normal & universal suggests the opposite.
- joeyo 17y agoNo, I strongly doubt Rizzolatti and his colleagues considered their discovery to be parapsychology.
- JulianMorrison 17y agoNo, those were just wrongly categorized to begin with. "The physics-defying spooky fact of X" belongs to parapsych (and I'd casually bet my life on the null hypothesis under good enough testing). "Experience of X" belongs to neuropsych (and it reflects poorly on them if they dump it over the fence on the parapsychologists because it just sounds so spooky and unprofessional. Bah humbug.)