6 ms·
> Can anybody counter Scalia, and say why the issue of gay marriage couldn't wait to be resolved by the states? For the same reason that slavery couldn't be re
by lisper 11y ago
> Can anybody counter Scalia, and say why the issue of gay marriage couldn't wait to be resolved by the states?
For the same reason that slavery couldn't be resolved by the states. For the same reason that racism can't be resolved by the states. Because these things haven't gotten resolved by states. The United States of America, sadly, has a significant minority of people who Just Don't Get It, and there are enough of them that if (when) they congregate they can form majorities in a number of states. And so the federal government needs to step in and dope-slap these people from time to time.
- madmax96 11y agoI think that gay marriage should be legal, but I disagree with this. Beware of the fallacy of analogy! There is no economic incentive for a state not to allow gay marriage, there was an economic incentive for states to keep slaves. Also, it wasn't the supreme court that ended up freeing the slaves...
- lisper 11y agoThere was no economic incentive to ban interracial marriage either. That didn't stop many states from doing it. And there are economic disincentives to racial discrimination. That didn't stop it from being institutionalized for decades. And I didn't say the supreme court needs to step in, I said the federal government needs to step in.
- madmax96 11y agoI could agree with the federal government stepping in, just not the court.
- borski 11y agoI agree with this being a fallacy of analogy, but yours is the wrong point. There is absolutely economic reason to prevent gay marriage - lower taxes for married couples, for one thing.
- angersock 11y agoYou know what a significant minority of people is when they have a majority? A majority. I'm not saying they're not idiots, mind you, but you can't go against the will of the majority (dumb as it is) and still wave the "democracy" flag. On a related note, this is why democracies suck: at least half the people participating are below average.
- lisper 11y agoWho is waving the democracy flag? Certainly not me. I'm waving the fourteenth-amendment equal-protection flag. The United States isn't a (pure) democracy. Never has been, never will be. Thank goodness.
- aaronem 11y agoYou're actually waving the tyranny-of-the-majority flag, in favor of equal protection for minorities. I'm not even honestly sure what to call that.
- lisper 11y agoCall it what you like. I'll call it the Equal Protection Clause of the fourteenth amendment to the Constitution of the United States of America.
- jmorphy88 11y agoSo, in other words, "the beatings will continue until you come around to our views"?
- lisper 11y agoNo, the beatings will continue for as long as you fail to respect the law. If you want to forbid gay marriage, it's very simple: repeal the fourteenth amendment. (Good luck with that.) It's like I tell my liberal friends: if you want to regulate guns, it's very simple: repeal the second amendment.
- defen 11y agoSo according to this ruling, the right for two men to marry has been "lurking" in the Constitution since 1868, right? But we just now discovered it? What I mean is that if someone had brought this case before the Supreme Court in 1870, the legally correct decision would have been to allow gay marriage? Things like that make me wonder what other "rights" (scare quotes because they are things that would not be considered rights today) are hidden in the Constitution, that will be discovered 150 years hence but would shock the conscience of nearly everyone alive today.
- lisper 11y ago> So according to this ruling, the right for two men to marry has been "lurking" in the Constitution since 1868, right? Yep. Just as the right to marry someone of a different race than you was lurking there but was not discovered until 1967.
- zzzeek 11y agothe word "regulated" is the third word of the second amendment.
- lisper 11y agoThat's true, but it doesn't mean what you think it means. In context (both textual and historical) it means "well-functioning", not "constrained." i.e. it means "In order to have a well-function militia, the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed." And the Supreme Court has (correctly IMHO) upheld this interpretation. I'm all for repealing the Second Amendment. I am vehemently opposed to trying to do end-runs around it.
- lmm 11y agoThen why have the states at all? Why have a tenth amendment?
- lisper 11y agoBecause even if you eliminate discrimination as one degree of freedom in the legal code, that still leaves a lot of room for experimentation. Some states have legalized marijuana, others haven't. Some states have high taxes. Some states have low taxes. Some states allow self-serve gasoline, others don't. I could go on and on. There's an awful lot of room for legal "biodiversity" left.
- nsxwolf 11y agoBased on this flowery language on the 14th Amendment in the majority opinion, I'm having trouble understanding why the 14th Amendment doesn't make marijuana bans illegal too.
- lisper 11y agoBecause marijuana bans apply to everyone equally.
- nsxwolf 11y agoThat sounds like an attempt at a constructionist argument. That's not what I'm reading at all in this opinion. I'm reading about the 14th Amendment being something that develops over time, helping people discover new freedoms, and be the very best they can be. It's fluffy stuff.
- lisper 11y agoYes, I agree, but the 14th amendment requires some kind of asymmetry in order to have effect. To violate equal-protection, something has to be unequal.
- pc2g4d 11y ago> people who Just Don't Get It Ah, but you clearly _do_ "Get It" and should have the right to impose your understanding of the universe on the rest of the country? Who gets to decide who "gets it"? Who decides in which situations those not-getting-it-majority-states should be denied their right to self-government and forced to adopt ways they oppose?
- lisper 11y ago> Who decides in which situations those not-getting-it-majority-states should be denied their right to self-government and forced to adopt ways they oppose? Ultimately, the Supreme Court, by virtue of the fact that the Union army won the civil war. If you don't like it, you can always try to get the Fourteenth Amendment repealed. Maybe the Thirteenth too while you're at it. Good luck with that.
- pc2g4d 11y agoSo your preference is for fundamental changes to the institution of marriage to be propagated by the force of state power rather than through reason, persuasion, and organic change. I'm afraid the Union Army wasn't fighting for gay rights, so I don't quite see how that applies. Nor do I see the relevance of your curious implication that because I question the appropriateness of the Supreme Court proclaiming gay marriage by fiat, I must also be interested in bringing back slavery. ("Maybe the Thirteenth too while you're at it.")
- lisper 11y ago> So your preference is for fundamental changes to the institution of marriage to be propagated by the force of state power rather than through reason, persuasion, and organic change. Of course not. But that is, sadly, not an option. The forces of ignorance and bigotry are too deeply entrenched in the U.S. That is one of the costs of freedom. People are free to be ignorant, and they are free to be bigots. But the government -- neither federal nor state -- does not have that freedom, thank God. > I'm afraid the Union Army wasn't fighting for gay rights, No, they were fighting for the union. But then, having won the war and established the nation as a sovereign power, when the fourteenth amendment was duly enacted it became binding on all the states. Sometimes when you fight for things you end up accomplishing more than you set out to do.
- prewett 11y agoI'm one of those who I think you would say "Just Don't Get It." Judging from your rhetoric, you clearly don't understand why some people do not think gay marriage is a good thing for the country. I don't think you have earned the right to say we "Just Don't Get It" and need to be "dope-slapped" until you actually get why we disagree with your viewpoint. If you can coherently argue for my position (even though you disagree), and you still don't think I'm being reasonable, then maybe you can use that kind of rhetoric.
- lisper 11y ago> you clearly don't understand why some people do not think gay marriage is a good thing for the country I've been studying this issue (and writing about it) for twelve years. I doubt very much there is an argument on either side I haven't heard. But this is a red herring. It doesn't matter whether gay marriage is or is not a good thing for the country. (I think it is, but that's irrelevant too.) What matters is if it's protected by the Constitution. So here's the test: do you think that states can Constitutionally ban interracial marriage? If so, then we'll just have to agree to disagree. But if not, then I submit that you cannot oppose same-sex marriage without being a hypocrite. There is no argument against gay marriage that cannot be applied just as well to interracial marriage. If you think there is such an argument, I'm listening.
- dllthomas 11y agoThere is clearly such an argument: "marriage is about biological reproduction." Of course, consistently applied, that should also argue against marriage of straight couples unable to have children (and probably also all the straight couples uninterested in having children). "No marriage after a hysterectomy" is not a position I've encountered.
- lisper 11y ago> marriage is about biological reproduction No, that argument applies (and was in fact applied) to interracial marriages as well: interracial marriages produce undesirable hybrids which have no racial identity and therefore cannot be integrated into society. > "No marriage after a hysterectomy" is not a position I've encountered. Of course you haven't, because no one really takes the reproduction argument seriously. When you dig into it, it's just an obvious smokescreen to cover up the bigotry which is at the heart of all opposition to gay marriage. If there were an actual argument against gay marriage, any demonstrable harm that comes from it, don't you think that the Right would be shouting it from the rooftops? But they aren't. All they're shouting from the rooftops is how horrible it is to ram social change down people's throats. The fact that this is the best argument they can muster is proof that sometimes you have no choice but to ram social change down people's throats, because some people are simply impervious to reason.
- tzs 11y ago> or the same reason that slavery couldn't be resolved by the states. For the same reason that racism can't be resolved by the states. Because these things haven't gotten resolved by states. I'm not so sure that the states would not have resolved it (Edit: gay marriage, not slavery). 13 years ago, there were 0 US states with legal gay marriage. 6 years ago it was 3. 2 years ago it was 12. Yesterday, it was 36 states (plus DC, Guam, and a whole bunch of native american tribes). 70% of the US population lived in areas with legal gay marriage. You might argue that a few states abolished slavery, too, but that was not going to lead to nationwide abolition without war. I think gay marriage would have been difference, because 1. We have much more interstate trade interdependence now, and 2. We have much more personal mobility. More and more large national companies are including support for same sex couples in their benefits, and when opening new facilities will take into account if the location is friendly to all their employees, including the LGBT ones. I think as soon as one or two of the hold out states lost some big project that would have brought a lot of jobs and money, and the awarding company cited as a reason for picking a neighboring state was that the winning state is more friendly to their LGBT employees, you'd see a lot of the hold out states changing their tune.
- abawany 11y agoUnfortunately, the southern states were going the opposite direction. There were states that strongly abolished gay marriage. Even after today's ruling, Texas is making passive-aggressive moves to make it difficult by encouraging county employees to use the "personal objection" reason to not issue licenses.
- dctoedt 11y ago> I'm not so sure that the states would not have resolved it [slavery]. Opinions among historians seem to vary, but the impression I've gotten (albeit not with any careful study) has been that the slave states likely would have been extremely slow to abolish slavery, because: 1) the dollar value ascribed to enslaved people represented a huge proportion of the wealth of politically-powerful slave owners; and 2) many non-slave-owning voters in the slave states --- all white males, of course --- aspired to become slave owners and thus tended to sympathize with the interests of slave owners.