3 ms·
One thing I've learned over the years is that there is a certain level of tact one needs to have when talking about other peoples' work. It's very easy for peop
by gfodor 17y ago
One thing I've learned over the years is that there is a certain level of tact one needs to have when talking about other peoples' work. It's very easy for people to be offended when you talk about things they've worked on negatively. As I've matured as a software engineer I've come to realize that no, my code is not a beautiful unique snowflake, and yes, I am probably the dumbest guy in the room.
This means that generally I've shifted from the thinking "this other person's code is shit" to "I'm betting there was a reason they did it this way." As it turns out, there almost always is. With the benefit of hindsight, those reasons can sometimes seem foolish, but that's the thing about hindsight. More often than not though, once I take the time to understand them, the decisions of the original author turn out to be better than my knee-jerk response.
When your overall attitude is still in the "everyone else's code sucks" mindset it leaks out through your language, and I think that's what is happening here, however slightly. There is no reason to use the word "failed" or use the word "sucks" when talking about another person's work, particularly when it's work that people are using in production for free and work that is open sourced, like Sinatra or Prototype. Even moreso when you're promoting an iteration of improvements on a platform that benefits from the work and experience of many man-months of volunteers, an iteration that is still not even released yet.