3 ms·
I occasionally cycle in London. There are two schools of thought to making cycling safer: 1) Make cyclists brighter and more armoured. 2) dedicated infrastru
by SideburnsOfDoom 11y ago
I occasionally cycle in London.
There are two schools of thought to making cycling safer:
1) Make cyclists brighter and more armoured.
2) dedicated infrastructure.
Option 2 is much more costly and harder politically, but is the only school of thought worth taking seriously. Look at places such as as Amsterdam and Copenhagen where cycling is common and safe (1). Do they rely on helmets and glowing things? No they don't. Lots of ordinary people cycle in regular clothes on dedicated separated cycle lanes.
Yes, you'll be safer if you stand out by being brighter than everyone else. But new and interesting ways to ramp up the brightness wars are a frivolous distraction from what cyclists in London need. You should not need to "look like cross between Darth Vader and a Christmas Tree" (2) in order to ride a bike.
At lot of the current infrastructure is terrible:
Advanced stop line? You mean that white mark on the road with a minicab over it.
Cycle "superhighway?" You mean that blue stripe underneath the buses and trucks.
1) http://www.theguardian.com/cities/2014/oct/16/copenhagen-cycling-innovation-lycra-louts-green-wave-bike-bridges http://www.theguardian.com/cities/2014/oct/16/copenhagen-cyc...
2) http://lcc.org.uk/articles/cycling-what-not-to-wear-1 http://lcc.org.uk/articles/cycling-what-not-to-wear-1
- baddox 11y agoStill, for people or organizations who have no measurable ability to affect infrastructure, but have the ability to make protective or high-visibility gear, doesn't it make sense to do so?
- SideburnsOfDoom 11y agoHow well does that high-vis gear sell in Copenhagen? Even if it does make financial sense for these organizations to sell their glow-sticks in London, it doesn't mean that it is in the interests of the rest of us to agree with the idea that it's the answer? It isn't the answer.
- baddox 11y ago> How well does that high-vis gear sell in Copenhagen? I don't know, but it's not relevant. > it doesn't mean that it is in the interests of the rest of us to agree with the idea that it's the answer. Of course not. Like any product, each of us can decide whether it is worth more to us than the money required to acquire it.
- SideburnsOfDoom 11y ago> but it's not relevant. The point is, if a city does cycling well, extremes of hi-vis gear become irrelevant. The endless focus on hi-vis gear is a distraction from getting to that state. The good examples of Copenhagen and Amsterdam are relevant to that. When the mayor or some other official suggest that cyclist need "more shiney" and to "keep your wits about you" (1) it is a way of fobbing off with cheap placebos. I don't entirely blame a company for promoting their product, but calling it a "solution" is wrong, and seeing this "solution" roundly rejected here is encouraging. 1) http://www.independent.co.uk/voices/comment/boriss-comments-on-hasty-rash-precipitous-cyclists-is-classic-government-victimblaming-8940052.html http://www.independent.co.uk/voices/comment/boriss-comments-...
- usrusr 11y agoThey even have a hard time selling reasonable bike lights, because people feel safe enough with tiny little occasionally blinking magnet/coil contraptions that are giving the absolute creeps to any cyclist that has grown up breaking German StVZO all the time. (StVZO: technical regulations for anything on the road, the bicycle part is like JavaScript: lots of cruft, but a few really good parts)
- twic 11y agoThere is one other school of thought: 3) Stop motorists running people over Strict liability and improvements to the construction of and training of drivers for lorries are ideas that stem from this school. For all other kinds of potentially lethal machines, the law and public opinion are in consensus that it is the operator's responsibility not to kill people with them. Motor vehicles somehow became an exception to that.
- SideburnsOfDoom 11y ago#3 sounds good to me, but even better if it's in conjunction to #2, not instead of it.