4 ms·
> The popular misconception was that anyone flying the Confederate flag during the war did so out of seething hatred towards anyone not white. The even more pop
by AlexandrB 11y ago
> The popular misconception was that anyone flying the Confederate flag during the war did so out of seething hatred towards anyone not white. The even more popular misconception is that by extension, anyone flying that same flag today does so out of the same reason.
I think that's a strawman. In actual fact the soldiers of the Confederate army were fighting to keep the system of slavery intact in the south. That's historical fact[1]. Most of them weren't monsters but what they were fighting for was monstrous.
Even though the flag Confederate may represent things like the valour of the Confederate soldiers it primarily represents the cause of the Confederacy, which was slavery. That's why it's a problem to glorify it. You can't reasonable separate the two meanings.
[1] http://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2015/06/what-this-cruel-war-was-over/396482/ http://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2015/06/what-thi...
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoThey fought for 1000 different reasons, of course. They volunteered (at first), and the vast majority were not slaveholders. A common reason was simply to repel the invaders of the north from their homeland. The North made the first move after all. I'm from Iowa, have no skin in the game. But its simple demonizing to make blanket statements about the intentions of vast groups of people.
- Jtsummers 11y ago> The North made the first move after all. The Confederate troops fired first, at Fort Sumter.
- krisdol 11y agoThe North still made the first move, by occupying the confederate fort and refusing to leave. This is middle school history, no need to hide the facts.
- Jtsummers 11y agoIt was not a Confederate fort to begin with. It was a Federal fort, though construction hadn't yet finished on it at the time of that SC tried to secede. I'm not hiding any facts, you just had a bad middle school history teacher.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- AlexandrB 11y agoWhether or not they were slaveholders. The fundamental reason the South went to war was to preserve slavery. That many of the soldiers did not own slaves themselves does not clear the flag of its meaning. Considering that the states were united until the south started to secede (again, because of slavery), I'm not sure how the war can be framed in any other way. The north can only be called invaders in the context of the secession.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoThe flag was the battle flag of one general. So what does it mean? Why did that general fight? Its flown for lots of reasons. I don't fly it; its repugnant to me. But I didn't have anyone die under it.
- seivan 11y agoSo do you also think that about Islamic flag(s) and symbols? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islamic_flags https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islamic_flags or does that get a free pass? Apart from the atrocities committed in the past, it is today used by ISIS to butcher Christians and Yezidis. Also used by Saudi to kill "deviant" homosexuals, witch-crafters and adulterers.
- AlexandrB 11y agoI admit I must plead ignorance on this point. I know ISIS is creating a bloodbath in the middle east, but I don't know the history well enough to comment on whether there's a flag that symbolizes that slaughter. Out of curiosity, which flag do you mean? Be specific. One of the first flags on that page is the flag of Turkey so you probably don't mean all of them.